Showing posts with label DCnU Supergirl 27. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DCnU Supergirl 27. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Sales Review: January 2014


Sales numbers for January 2014 were recently posted and the news for DC Comics continues to be concerning. As usual, I will refer you to ICv2 for the whole story:http://www.icv2.com/articles/news/27835.html

DC's market share continues to shrink while Marvel continues to hold a dominant percentage. I am starting to wonder if next year at this time, Image will be the #2 comic company. One thing that I have to tip my hat to Marvel about is the way the conglomerate it is one with uses its power to advertise.

Marvel is owned by Disney, as is ESPN. Driving into work, listening to ESPN radio, there was commercial for ... Marvel Comics ... which name checked not only Guardians of the Galaxy and All-New Xmen, but also the story 'The Trial of Jean Grey'. Incredible.


Supergirl #27 came out in January, the second part of the Tony Bedard Lobo story and the last issue before the Red Lantern arc.

This was a good issue with Shay Veritas' origin partially revealed, the re-introduction of Blaze to the New 52, and a Supergirl struggling to hold it together. Yildiray Cinar's art was great.


Unfortunately, the new team and promise of a new direction hasn't budged sales. The book dipped below the 22K mark, down 3% in sales.

It looks like sales on many DC titles is slowly eroding. I will be very interested to see if the Red Lantern issue brings people in. And I wonder if a bump in sales will make DC think that people want an angrier Kara.


More surprising to me, to be honest, was the sales numbers of Action Comics.

Greg Pak and Aaron Kuder are just crushing it on this book right now. The stories are universally lauded by critics. It feels like the perfect amalgam of Superman ages.  Visually it is stunning.


I thought for sure this book would be in the upper echelon of sales. That buyers would notice.

Instead, the book is selling just over 36K, about half of what I thought.

Maybe word hasn't spread yet??

Friday, January 24, 2014

Review: Supergirl #27


Supergirl #27 came out this week, the second issue of the Tony Bedard era as writer and the last issue before the 'Red Daughter of Krypton' arc.

Given that the next issue starts a new and controversial storyline, I thought that the Lobo story would be completely wrapped up by the end of this issue. Instead, Bedard has this issue end with a decent cliff-hanger, infuses some scenes to help the reader understand the slide into Red Lantern plot, and adds a lot of new plot hooks.

While I know I don't agree with the idea of the Red Lantern arc, it might be a sort of catharsis for the character, literally and metaphorically burning away all the rage and angst in Supergirl since the inception of the New 52. And, now knowing it won't be some drawn out lengthy arc, I am suddenly a bit more accepting of the move.

But setting that aside, Bedard really does a good job beefing up the book immediately. We learn a lot more about Shay Veritas, setting her up as a supporting character in the title. My spider-sense is still tingling about her. I still wonder if she'll end up a villain. And we re-introduce a classic Superman villain to the new 52 but setting her up as a Supergirl villain, a move that already seems so natural I don't know why it hasn't been done.

Yildiray Cinar does the art here and bring a smooth clean sensibility to the book. It is a shame that he will only be on the book for four issues.


Last issue, Supergirl 'killed' the new Lobo when he attacked the Block. After the wicked right hook, Supergirl immediately felt remorse. It is one more brick in the wall of frustration Supergirl has been crashing against Supergirl #1.

Bedard does a good job in this issue having Kara speak about her feelings. There is a hint that everything has piled up so high in her mind, in her soul, that she is simply reaching a breaking point. It makes sense for Supergirl to feel overwhelmed right now. This hasn't been an easy transition. So here, when she talks about simply losing control in the fight against Lobo ... everything going red ... implies she is simply losing control.

This isn't the first Supergirl to have a crazy upheaval in her life. The others have all basically returned to the core of her character ... she wants to do what's right. Like Loeb and Kelly's version, this Supergirl has intentionally isolated herself, not leaving her any access to help dealing with her feelings. If you arrive alone and you make yourself isolated, of course you will feel overwhelmed.

So I am hoping when this whole blows over, we get that likable Supergirl, the one who wants to help back. And I hope she takes a look in the mirror and realizes that she needs friends and family. That she can't do it alone.


 Here is one of those panels I love when words and art complement each other so well.

First off, we get a sense of the enormity of the block. This place has to be a tesseract of some sort, bigger on the inside than it is from the outside.

But moreover, Veritas' words about Supergirl being so strong in such a fragile world, 'walking on eggshells' invoked in me a feeling of claustrophobia, or delicacy in movement. And that feeling is contrasted with the space in this place. Kara should feel at home here, or a bit freer than she is on a crowded street.

Anyways, I liked this panel a lot.


And we finally get a bit more backstory about Veritas.

As hinted before, Superman saved the Block from some cosmic storm called the Eternal Maelstrom. But that save had any number of weird consequences. The Block is now out of phase with reality in the core of the Earth. All the other scientists - male and female - had their genetics rewritten with Veritas' genome. And everyone is trapped because leaving the block could cause a space/time rift. Odd.

Her being trapped makes her sort of a technological Baron Winters, stuck forever in her 'mansion' without being able to leave, talking to 'agents' to do her outside work. Plus, there is this odd feel of impending villainy on her part. I don't know if she is evil. But I think she is so obsessed with what she is doing that I bet she doesn't care what happens to those in her wake. She seems so eager to study things that she doesn't think of the consequences. There is a sort of Luthor narcissism mixed with Brainiac thirst for knowledge.


Veritas talks to Kara about seeking help from others and the response is ... no surprise ... anger. In the end, I think some of this is anger by Supergirl inwardly directed for putting herself in this situation but transferred to others.

Supergirl derisively talks of Clark's 'duty and obligation', feelings drilled into his head. And then she yells about how Clark worked towards destroying Krypton again (in Krypton Returns) despite knowing that Krypton's existence was unraveling the universe.

As I said above, I want Supergirl to see the best in people, to want to help people,and to learn lessons on how to do it right ... the hero on a journey. So this set of panels, flashing into anger over Kal who has done nothing but leave her alone as she requested, just seems off. I suppose it adds to why a Red Lantern ring would choose her.

Again, I would be much more upset about this is the Red Lantern story had no apparent ending. This isn't Supergirl.


 Veritas offers to be Supergirl's friend. But I am so wary about her. That line read more like 'you can be my test subject' rather than an extended amicable hand. And here, Veritas talks about being interested in lots of things including extra-terrestrials.

I am not convinced that all her science is done for the betterment of the world or humanity. There is something shady about this.

Now I have really glossed over Lobo's part in this story because he is the least interesting part. It turns out he was faking his death, revives himself, and goes after Veritas. He takes out Supergirl with hypersonics, forcing Shay to run for her life through the Block.


 First Veritas turns on a 'fusion globe' to flash-burn Lobo.

But then she runs into 'Xenocontainment Module 5'. Hmmm ... is this a prison? A zoo? Natural habitat for something she is studying? This looks like a Escher style labyrinth ... Hellish.

And she asks whatever is housed here to help defend her.

The tone of the conversation makes it sound like the being in this 'containment unit' is being held against its will. Again, the feel of malevolence under the shroud of 'advancing science' is strong. Veritas isn't a wholly good person. And maybe that is another brick in Kara's wall of anger. Even this person who seemingly wants to help her is really hoping to use her.


 And then we see who is being housed there ... Blaze.

Blaze was the demon sister of Lord Satanus in Superman lore. A true denizen of Hell. Last time I saw her was in Reign In Hell. Surely she isn't being held in the Block willingly. Maybe the 'phase' of the place crosses dimensions? Either way, it furthers my thoughts of Veritas' character.

I love Cinar's design of Blaze, huge, gangly, powerful, but with the classic helmet shrouding her face with huge horns. Perfect re-imagining.

Lastly, this is such a perfect addition for Supergirl's rogues gallery I am surprised it hasn't been done before. It is a great idea.


But Blaze doesn't need to get involved. Before Blaze can engage with Lobo, Supergirl, revitalized by the 'yellow fusion globe' that Veritas ignited, shows up and she is ... not surprisingly ... angry. I suppose I should have guessed that the 'yellow fusion globe' would help Kara. Those words basically describe a yellow sun.

And, mega-charged, Supergirl talks about killing Lobo on purpose this time.

Sigh.

Okay, there is no stopping this train. Supergirl is going to be a Red Lantern soon. And this story does its best to show just how much Kara has bottled up inside her. As I have said before, I am more easily able to deal with this stuff knowing that the Red Lantern arc seems to be relatively short. If we didn't know when Red Daughter was ending, if I didn't see a 'normal' Supergirl on the cover of the JLU, I probably would be wailing and gnashing my teeth.

And with Blaze and Lobo and Veritas all still active at this cliff-hanger ending, we probably have to wrap things up here before she dons the ring. I wonder if the last page of next issue is the ring arriving.

Despite the rage aspect of the story, there is so much to like in this issue. The increasing details of Veritas' life and her home make her more 3-dimensional. I think she is going to end up heading down the evil road. And Blaze is just an inspired addition to the Supergirl mythos.

Add to those story elements Yildiray Cinar's beautiful art. From the Blaze design, to the expressive nature of Supergirl, to this last power pose splash, this book is just great. And the perspective panel of the Block with tiny Supergirl and Veritas was slick.

So we are moving towards a new Supergirl.

Overall grade: B+/B

Friday, October 25, 2013

January 2014 Solicits



I swear ... I think DC knows people might have gift money to spend after the holidays. Their January solicits always seem heavier than usual. The complete solicits are up in multiple places. Here is the link for Newsama's coverage:http://www.newsarama.com/19238-dc-comics-january-2014-solicitations-collectibles.html

As usual there are lots of standard comics. But this month has a number of surprises, including some Annuals which look very interesting. Here are the issues suitable for commenting on here.

SUPERGIRL #27
Written by TONY BEDARD
Art by YILDIRAY CINAR
Cover by GUISEPPE CAMUNCOLI and CAM SMITH

Part Two of Kara’s confrontation with the deadly new Lobo. After last issue’s shock ending, this issue we discover an even greater threat in Shay Veritas that will force Supergirl to make a deadly choice!

So we enter the second issue of the Tony Bedard era of Supergirl and the story sounds interesting. I don't care about Lobo but the prospect of Dr. Veritas becoming a villain ... and a Supergirl villain to boot ... would be a great thing. That is a fantastic!

http://www.comicbookdb.com/graphics/comic_graphics/1/73/26242_20060512013407_large.jpg


And the cover is a nice homage to the Dan Jurgens cover from the Dead Again storyline, an arc where Brainiac convinces the world that Superman remained dead after the Doomsday fight. Nice.

On to the rest of the month.



ACTION COMICS #27
Written by GREG PAK
Art and cover by AARON KUDER

Superman takes on the brutal Beast Lord as startling revelations are made about our Earth’s underground world! Plus: more on the mysterious Ghost Soldier!

I like the look of this Beast Lord character with his armor made from creatures he has dispatched.

I have to say, I am really looking forward to the Pak/Kuder team on this book.



SUPERMAN #27
Written by SCOTT LOBDELL
Art by KENNETH ROCAFORT
Cover by KEN LASHLEY

The Parasite can’t be stopped—and he hungers for the power that Lois Lane possesses. Is there anything The Man of Steel can do, or will he lose his best friend? The answer will surprise you!

We heard about this issue in the NYCC. And, as predicted, The Parasite is going to try to purge the Brainiac psionic energy from Lois. Should we be happy that Lois is in the book in some form?



SUPERBOY #27
Written by MARV WOLFMAN
Art by ANDRES GUINALDO
Cover by RAFA SANDOVAL and NORM RAPMUND

The son of Superman finds himself trapped with the Teen Titans in a future that may kill all of them.

This is it! The first issue of the Jon Lane Kent era of this book. And frankly, Marv Wolfman has one issue to grab me. I hate this concept. I feel for Superboy fans. And I don't think I am going to stick around too long.

I mean, when was the last tome a Marv Wolfman book grabbed me like that? 1987?



SUPERMAN/WONDER WOMAN #4
Written by CHARLES SOULE
Art by TONY S. DANIEL, BATT and SANDU FLOREA
Cover by TONY S. DANIEL

The secret of Superman and Wonder Woman’s relationship is out and the world’s reaction is mixed, but that’s the least of the power couple’s worries as Zod seeks to release Faora from the Phantom Zone!

We knew that the Superman/Wonder Woman relationship was going to leak out, probably on ClarkCatropolis. Maybe that story is what keeps the blog (and Clark and Cat) financially afloat.

Now Zod and Faora as another 'power couple' are worthy foes. I just wonder if it might be too soon from the Ultraman/Superwoman fights to feel fresh.


BATMAN/SUPERMAN #7
Written by GREG PAK
Art and cover by BRETT BOOTH and NORM RAPMUND

Batman versus Superman! Trapped by the Toymaster and Mongul, our heroes turn on each other! Who will save Batman and Superman if they can’t save themselves? This epic issue is presented in a special sideways format!

Batman vs. Superman has been done so many times it feels pretty played. I am hoping that the presence of Mongul will make this story crackle.


BATMAN/SUPERMAN ANNUAL #1
Written by GREG PAK
Art by JAE LEE, ED BENES and others
Cover by ED BENES

It’s the first meeting of Supergirl and Red Hood, Steel and Supergirl and more as the competing Batman and Superman families must battle for the control of the missing Mongul’s fortress! And at the heart of it, Batman and Superman deal with their grief over their fallen comrades.

But this annual really grabbed me. With the specter of the recently dead legacies, Superman and Batman and their families - Batgirl, Supergirl, Steel, and Red Hood - team up to fight off some new version of Warworld.

Supergirl teaming up with Superman. And really teaming up! That's a great thing.


WORLDS’ FINEST #19
Written by PAUL LEVITZ
Art by R.B. SILVA and JOE WEEMS
Cover by EMANUELA LUPACCHINO

Desperate times call for desperate measures as Power Girl and Huntress reveal their true origins to this world’s Superman and Batman! 

I don't always include Worlds' Finest in my monthly solicit post. But I had to include both WF books this month here as both are key and touch on things I want to see. The first is that finally Huntress and Power Girl decide to let the E1 Batman and Superman know they exist.

I have been waiting for that for a while.



WORLDS’ FINEST ANNUAL #1
Written by PAUL LEVITZ
Art by DIOGENES NEVES and MARC DEERING
Cover by EMANUELA LUPACCHINO

In one of their first adventures together, Earth 2’s Supergirl and Robin team up to face their world’s Wonder Woman!

But this is the one I am really excited about. I have been wanting to see some of the pre-Earth 2 destruction Supergirl and Robin adventures. We have seen a little of them in the first issues of Earth 2 and Worlds' Finest. We saw more in Worlds' Finest #0. I can't wait for this. Levitz seems to have a feel for 'classic' Kara so let's hope this matches my expectations.



ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN #9
Written by CHRISTOS N. GAGE
Art by EDUARDO FRANCISCO
Cover by DAN PANOSIAN

Avert your eyes! Down on the ground! It’s not a bird! It’s not a plane! It am Bizarro!

The Bizarro stories in Adventures have been fun so far. What could be better than a classic take on Bizarro!



SMALLVILLE SEASON 11: ALIEN #2
Written by BRYAN Q. MILLER
Art by EDGAR SALAZAR and DYM
Cover by CAT STAGGS

When Superman revealed himself to the world, he knew some repercussions would be out of his control. He never expected this, though! Meanwhile, Lex Luthor’s trip to Russia brings him face to face with a Monitor—and his own mortality.

I have been waiting ... waiting for this book to move closer to the eventual crisis mentioned way back in the first issue. So a Monitor means we are getting close.

The cover is interesting though. Is this someone who accidentally killed themselves pretending to be Superman?


SMALLVILLE SEASON 11 SPECIAL #4
Written by BRYAN Q. MILLER
Art and cover by CAT STAGGS

Jay Garrick has opened a school for youth with special talents and abilities, to train a promising new generation of Super Heroes. However, things fall apart as a mysterious foe, determined to take down the new Titans team, attacks the San Francisco Pier—pushing these young heroes to their absolute limits.

And then an added bonus! The introduction of the Smallville Titans. Miss Martian! Superboy! Blue Beetle! Arrowette. Seems like the Young Justice crew! And Jay Garrick too!

Plus internal art by Cat Staggs!



SUPERGIRL VOL. 3: SANCTUARY TP
Written by MIKE JOHNSON and FRANK HANNAH
Art by MAHMUD ASRAR, SAMI BASRI and others
Cover by MAHMUD ASRAR

In these stories from issues #13-19, H’El convinces Kara that he intends to return them to Krypton prior to its destruction. When presented with the opportunity to return home, Kara fails to see that H’El’s plan will leave the Earth in ruins. Wonder Woman and The Flash must show Kara in the truth before it’s too late! 

Now this seems like a foolish trade to put together, given that it includes the 2 chapters in the H'El on Earth in the middle of this. I can only hope there are some extras in the trade to make it worth the while of the Supergirl fans.



ALL-STAR WESTERN #27
Written by JUSTIN GRAY and JIMMY PALMIOTTI
Art by MORITAT
Cover by GIUSEPPE CAMUNCOLI and NORM RAPMUND

Hex’s journey through the modern age continues! Guess whose attention Hex attracts as he makes his way to Metropolis! 

And then the last and weirdest item. Superman teaming up with Jonah Hex??

So all in all a packed and expensive month.

Alas, probably the last Superboy month for me unless something dramatic happens.