Wednesday, October 09, 2013
Three things of merit
Thursday, January 10, 2013
The new 52 isn't working for me
My problems with the new 52 are many. I appreciate they wanted to provide an all new jumping on point for new readers. I appreciate they wanted to revitalise their intellectual property. However, part of the reasons I love DC's comics is the 70 odd years of history you get with each title. That tightly wound continuity, the banter and Easter eggs you get within titles. The knowledge that what is happening in one title will impact upon and be referenced by other characters - maybe not in the same week, maybe in a years time, or five years time. I loved discovering what each new chapter brought and immersing myself in the world. I loved building up the history of the cities, the houses, the philosophies, the religion, the characters, the technology, the leaders, the poor, the everything. Most of all, I loved how the old DCU worked.
Now I don't have that. Not in my titles. My current pull list (for new 52 titles) is:
Animal Man, Green Arrow, Superboy, Demon Knights, Birds of Prey, Supergirl, Wonder Woman, Teen Titans.*
I used to buy 20 odd titles a month.
But for those I am buying, all those series have been restarted from scratch. I was getting Justice League and Aquaman. Aquaman wasn't rebooted (much) but Justice League was. I know Batman and Green Lantern kept their history but I am not interested in reading them regularly.
Now the DCU is just 5 years old I cannot understand how Batman has had so many teen sidekicks. I have no idea how the old Justice League stories that I love fit in to the new history. Guy Gardner's origin has changed (he's now no longer an ex-teacher but an ex-cop) and I am just not interested in reading a rebooted version of him.
Dinah Lance and Oliver Queen - one of my favourite couples in the DCU - no longer are a couple and haven't even met yet.
Superman is no longer a source of hope and compassion.
Wonder Woman's backstory has been pulled away from the women led utopia. She is no longer an inspiration to me.
Supergirl is an entirely new character, losing all the history and humanity the Gates/Igle run put into her.
Superboy has been rebooted, yet we seem to be retreading the same old ground.
Birds of Prey is all new, and again, has lost all the rich history.
Teen Titans, well Wonder Girl, Solstice and Kid Flash are entirely new characters. They are not anywhere near the same as they were pre-new 52. Robin also seems like a new character. Bunker and Skitter are actually new and I am vaguely interested in reading about them.
The good things are that Animal Man has kept his history, and has always had a slightly odd series of his own anyway. Demon Knights provides historical context to the DCU.
Another thing I do not like is the way DC is approaching their 18-35 demographic. They seem to be going for a very narrow interpretation of what this demographic will like, and they appear to be going for mindless shallow fight scenes and little depth of storytelling. Like the very worst of Hollywood blockbuster films.
Most adult characters have been de-aged to mid-twenties. I am not interested in reading about characters that are all of an age, and an immature age at that. I want heroes in their 30s, 40s and 50s. I want a rich life tapestry for them to draw on. I want the conflict and discussion that comes when you have a group of people from different backgrounds forced to work together. I want heroes with different personalities and aims.
Most of all, the stories just aren't very good.
I just don't feel like I'm getting that in the new DCU.
I have a theory about what happened in the DC offices. I believe they got taken over by Warner Brothers a couple of years before this new 52 started. I think that someone came in to investigate DC's creative output. What was selling, why it was selling, who they could sell to, what was and wasn't working and what the potential for new sales is. Basically to recommend an overhaul of the company so it could become viable. We all know that the big 2 comics companies are in trouble, sales wise.
I think what happened was that Warner Brothers took over they told the top brass to raise their sales figures or get sacked. I think the new 52 is a last ditch attempt by the parent company to squeeze some money out of the publishing arm and I think that if it doesn't succeed DC comics will be downsized and only the biggest sellers will continue being published - Wonder Woman, Superman, Batman, Justice League and anything else that ties into film and TV products. I think anything that does continue being published will look radically different to what is being published now.
Maybe it will all be electronic. Comixology has shown that the market is there for digital comics. I'd be happy with that.
I am not willing to support titles I am not enjoying. So I am going to cancel Superboy, Birds of Prey and Teen Titans. Animal Man, Supergirl and Wonder Woman I will continue buying in hardcopy format and Green Arrow and Demon Knights I will buy ad-hoc digitally. I will dip in and out of titles on the shelves but I will not make myself beholden to any one title. If Wonder Woman, Animal Man and Supergirl don't improve I will probably also drop those. I will replace my old DC floppies with trades. I will sell the floppies on ebay (or to anyone who wants them) and buy the collections that I treasure, love and enjoy.
I shall try out some Marvel titles. Because I think they are going to offer me what DC aren't - character depth, history, continuity and complex storytelling.
If you've got this far through, please can you recommend me non-DC titles you think I might enjoy. As I told twitter, I like pretty art, good characterisation, good storytelling and dinosaurs.
*I also buy Ame-Comi girls and Smallville, but they are not new 52. It is quite telling that these are my absolute favourite series currently being published.
Friday, March 02, 2012
Perfect, perfect comic panel
Perfect colour,s perfect motion, perfect perspective, perfetc layout, pefect design.
Perfect.
Found on Slay, Monstrobot of the Deep!
Thursday, October 13, 2011
Monday, August 08, 2011
Black/Hispanic Spider-man!
Revealed in Marvel Comics' Ultimate Fallout Issue 4, out Wednesday, the new Spider-Man in the Ultimate universe is a half-black, half-Hispanic teen named Miles Morales. He takes over the gig held by Peter Parker, who was killed in Ultimate Spider-Man Issue 160 in June.
In his first appearance, he simply breaks up a fight. But readers will learn the true origin of Morales and how he became the new Spider-Man when Ultimate Spider-Man relaunches in September with a new No. 1 issue.
"The theme is the same: With great power comes great responsibility," says writer Brian Michael Bendis. "He's going to learn that. Then he has to figure out what that means." The new Ultimate Spider-Man series, as well as Wednesday's Ultimate Fallout issue, will be available digitally the same day as in stores.
In the regular Marvel Universe, Peter Parker will still be the same web-swinging Spidey as he has been since his first appearance in 1962. But in the Ultimate line, launched in 2000 to tell contemporary stories, he received a new origin and a reimagined supporting cast that paralleled the Spidey in regular Marvel continuity.
Morales' journey will be a similar vehicle for today's fans, says Marvel's editor in chief, Axel Alonso.
"What you have is a Spider-Man for the 21st century who's reflective of our culture and diversity. We think that readers will fall in love with Miles Morales the same way they fell in love with Peter Parker."
In addition to an alliterative name, Miles has a connection to his predecessor in how he received his powers. But he will have different abilities, too. Supporting characters such as Peter's Aunt May and Gwen Stacy also will give Miles nuggets of wisdom to help his transition from young kid to New York City superhero.
Italian artist Sara Pichelli, who was integral in designing the new Spider-Man's look, says, "Maybe sooner or later a black or gay — or both — hero will be considered something absolutely normal."
-------------
Wednesday, September 22, 2010
Where are all the Deaf superheroes?
Peter David put a couple of lipreaders in his Supergirl and Young Justice comics and Green Arrow/Black Canary had that villain last year that was deafened by Dinah, but that's it. Where are the rest? We've got Babs in her wheelchair, Chunk, Professor Xavier, Daredevil, Dr Midnight, Speedy/Red Arrow, Tony Stark, Dr Niles Caulder, Captain Marvel Junior, Osiris, Crazy Jane. I'm sure there's more, that's just what a quick google search turned up.
Where the Deaf heroes? I'll tell you where there's one - Echo, from the Daredevil comics. That's it. I should be able to name more.
Echo first turned up in Parts of a Hole (soon to be reviewed over at New readers...) and I was stunned when the story actually constant reference to her lack of hearing. Her abilities aren't linked to her Deafness, unlike Daredevil's abilities and so I felt like I did when I read Venus Envy - it's a regular superhero book about a woman who happens to be Deaf.
The book isn't about her Deafhood, but because she is Deaf she experiences life different to a hearing person, and so the story show that. On the whole it does this well, and it also explores Daredevil's blindness well. There's a great scene where they are in the cinema and Echo is describing the action on screen and Daredevil is describing the dialogue when the actors are off screen.
But. (You knew there was a but coming didn't you?) It isn't quite good enough. The problem with having just one Deaf hero is that she becomes representative of all Deaf people and the mistakes that are made are amplified and picked upon over and over.
For example, Echo can mimic any physical action she sees. This makes her an ace fighter. Luckily for her she's also quite bright and so can work out how to put the moves together in order to win a fight or choreograph a dance show. I imagine that being able to mimic physical actions must have made it easier for her to learn the handshapes and movements needed for American Sign Language (ASL).
But, this ability is used in book to explain why her speech is not slurred. Because she can copy mouth patterns I suppose... Wait. Just back up there one moment, what? Most speech isn't formed on the lips. Lip reading is hard, very hard. If it was easy to lip read everybody we wouldn't need trained lipspeakers. How on earth is Echo meant to see and mimic the movements of the tongue and the throat in order to produce clear speech?
Ignoring all that, the in text reasoning seems to assume that no Deaf people have clear speech. Well, quite frankly that's bollocks. The level of speech will depend on things like when the person lost their hearing and what speech therapy they've had. Ooh it makes me angry when people get basic stuff wrong.
What else, oh yes, how she learnt ASL. Apparently her father taught it to her using Native American folk stories, and possibly shadow puppets. Well I'd be really interested to know where he learnt it and how she developed her knowledge of the language. Because we see nothing of this in the book, she doesn't sign once. I don't think I've met a signer who never signs when they speak. When a sign language is your first language you tend to use it alongside your spoken language. You just do.
Echo somehow manages to lipread people in the dark and never makes a mistake when she is lipreading. The former is impossible and the latter is highly unlikely. But, I guess if you had a book full of communication errors it would get a bit dull and prevent the flow of the story. For the same reason we don't tend to see protagonists going to the toilet. So I'll forgive them the perfect lipreading. The rest isn't really forgivable, it's just ignorant.
This is such a shame because it's clear that the writer has done his research - there is so much stuff in the book that is Deaf aware. It becomes an odd half and half mix. I'm very keen to read more about her and I just hope that other issue build upon the solid base that this book gave, but improved the rookie errors.
And I want more Deaf, deaf and hard of hearing heroes. Please.
Incidentally, Echo's sign name would either be the sign for Echo, a handprint across the face (she wears this when she performs), or possibly dancer. Daredevil's sign name would be the devil horns on his costume. Matt Murdock (Daredevil's civilian identity) would be lawyer I reckon. His partner Foggy Nelson's sign name would be Fog.
Monday, September 06, 2010
Comics!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Superman/Batman 75
Eh look, the Legion didn't piss me off. And then there's a scene where Batman is mopping Superman's brow. Because Superman has kryptonite poisoning. Bruce is getting more tender, dammit! That is actually a very adorable scene.
The rest of the book is 2 page stories where the creators seem to be letting rip and having lots of fun - this is what Superman/Batman should be. The rest of the DCU can go to a dark and dank hell but this book should be fun. There's a parody of the floppy format by Steven T Seagle and Teddy Kristiansen (them who did It's a bird...) which I really wasn't expecting as this was touted as a sequal to It's a Bird.
The Con story was great - there are 2 kids, each dressed as Superman and Batman, and they start hassling a guy dressed as the Joker, concluding with plans to launch a groin attackk!!! then they spy Catwoman and her reactions is just priceless.
Adam Hughes does a wodnerful spread of Batgirl and Supergirl - he gives Kara a lovely face, which looks similar to Helen Slater.
Friendly Advice is Tim and Dick and Con and Kal talking about the Cass/Con/Tim love triangle. Dick is teasing Tim something chronic.
And the most unexpected story - a continuation of the chibli story arc from Superman/Batman 51 and 52, where we find out that tiny Superman isn't really dead, he's just sleeping! awwyeah!
Krypto vs Ace. Nuff said.
Then some odd stories - Joker vs Lex done Calvin and Hobbes style, Batman/Superman as a grown up Connor/Damian, and a weird story about a kid and his dad.
But the rest were ace.
Green Arrow 3
This is bewildering. Ollie was brought back to life by the mystic wood (i'm trying to work in a bush joke here) and a knight named Galahad. Yes that Galahad. I think I liked it.
Gotham City Sirens 15
Aww this was all about Harley and Ivy. One of ma favourite female friendships in comics. Aww. Selina's in it too, but this is really def all about Harley and Ivy.
Wonder Woman 602
Diana startsher trials to earn the mantle of Wonder Woman. She take soff her jacket and reveals some strappy gold bits to the bustier which some people reckon is gonna be her lasso. I like the strappy bits. I also liked the sacrifices angle, them pesky Gods, wanting you to prove your faith in blood. I'm a little unclear where Diana got that sword from, but I think this goes to prove you shouldn't piss off an Amazon.
Daredevil 55
You are correct, this isnt usually on my pull list and is in fact quite an old title. I got it cos I'm trying to locate soem Echo stories - she's a Deaf girl in the Marvel universe. This is the start of a story arc named Vision Quest and is by David Mack, so the art is all painted and the way it;s put together it kind of looks more like a collage than a regular comic book. I suspect I'd get more out of it with the whole arc but it was an OK read. Her Deafness is integral to her experience and came up regularly throughout the issue so that was good.
Hey, it's poll time!
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
bum bum ba BUMMM!!
Quite apt that my scan accidentally cut his head off don't you think?
Lets take a closer look:
See they don't have to be green to be good!
Edited to add that I put a review of this book up on New readers... if anyone is interested. there's no bum over there tho.
Saturday, June 05, 2010
Who shall wear the rings?
Orange (Avarice): Lex Luthor. The canon choice works for me.
Yellow (Fear): Scarecrow. As for Lex. The guy peddles in fear, an obvious choice.
Green (Willpower): Hal. Well why not. Superman Red Son: Elseworlds convinced me of his willpower even if the GL comics didn't.
Blue (Hope): Superman. Because, c'mon. he's the foremost icon within the DCU. The symbol of all that is good and all that humanity can strive for. He keeps our egos in check and makes everyone who meets him feel like they can be a better person and make a difference in the world (unless you're a villain, then you're fucked).
Indigo (Compassion): Wonder Woman. As was noted in the blogosphere at the time, Diana's emotions and feelings for the world are centred around compassion, not love. Making her the pink lantern was a supremely sexist choice, made worse by that godawful outfit.
Violet/Pink (Love): Wally West. Because of Linda being his anchor. Those two are, to me, the most perfect example of love within the DCU. More so than the Hawks.
Thsi leaves Red (Rage). Mera didn't really work for me, her transition to Red Lantern felt forced, altho once turned, she made a very good angry vomity hero. I really don't know who I'd pick. If this had all occured back when Kara was new returning to the DCU, she'd have been a good choice. If somewhat ineffective (because I feel that she wasn't trained well enough and would be a loose cannon. Maybe that would make her very effective, I don't know).
Guy got a red ring then was cured, so I don't want to count him.
Other than that I came up with the Hulk. Yeha I know, wrong universe. I'm not too good on DCU villains (other than the rogues who certainly aren't rage filled).
What do you all reckon? If I get enough answers I'll put up a poll.
Tuesday, June 01, 2010
Coming out in Comics: Bling
This is from X-Men: Legacy and it appears that Bling's preference for women is well known to the other characters, but this is the first time the reader finds out about it. Nicely done, I'd like to see more of this.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Coming out in Comics: Runaways
Here are some scenes from Runaways where we see that Karolina is gay.
We have seen hints seeded throughout the previous 4 volumes that Karolina may be gay, however the first 2 scans are where she officially comes out. We see Karolina, an alien, hitting on Nico, a witch:
It is unclear whether Karolina thinks she is a freak because she is gay or because she has just been turned down by Nico. Note also that Nico is unconcerned as to Karolina's lesbian status. Then think how this is a book aimed at teenagers and featuring teenagers!
Skip forward a few pages and we have a strange new visitor named Xavin. He is a super skrull, but a good guy, who is betrothed to Karolina and has come to Earth to find her to arrange the marriage and start working on putting their worlds back together. This could come off as really creepy and forced, but it doesn't. Karolina is asked simply to join Xavin and to get to know her fiancee before any sort of romantic relationship is formed. Before this can happen however, Karolina says she can't mary Xavin because she likes girls. To which Xavin, as a shapeshifter, simply morphs into a female form:
Note Chase Stein's reaction and Gert's comlete lack of a reaction. It is very cool that Xavin doesn't give a stuff about the gender s/he presents as, but then as an alien, presenting as human would probably be the main issue. At any rate we have a gender swapping person added into the mix. Later volumes look at what it means for Xavin's identity to present as female vs male and human vs skrull. It is made clear that Xavin wishes to learn how to be human and that she identifies as female first, so she is not a male masquerading as female and therefore tricking Karolina.
Runaways is an awesome set of books. How I wish I'd has these as a confused teenager!
Scans taken from Runaways Vol 5 Escape to New York.
[And don't forget about my poll! More than 3 of you must know who Supergirl is and have an opinion, c'mon, make your voice heard!]
Monday, July 13, 2009
Reviews part 5: 3 collections and some old crap
These notes will cover Extreme Justice, Green Lantern: Rebirth, Marvels and Strawberry Marshmallow volume 2.
Extreme Justice
This is some old crap. Macho posturing rubbish with appalling art to match. Amazing Man inexplicably changes from black to white and back again every other panel, I think it might be dependent on the powers he’s just absorbed, or on the other hand, it could be a shit colourist. Read at your peril. Me, I must be knee deep in peril cos I’ve now read 12 issues and will be reading to the tiresome end.
Green Lantern: Rebirth
Overall I enjoyed this. The one punch reference to Giffen JLA made me chuckle as did all the bits mentioned in the preface. I think I’d have got more out of it had I known more general Green Lantern history and Hal’s history specifically. The book is one for the avid fans, not a general introduction to comics or Green Lanterns - people who don’t know much about the characters won’t get as much out of it.
Marvels
This was bought (as was Rebirth actually) with the voucher my sister got me for being bridesmaid at her wedding. I got this book a good 4 weeks ago but it has been sat on the side table waiting for me to find a good time to read it. A time when I didn’t feel rushed and like I could actually savour it – I’ve had precious few of those recently.
I had already read the book as our local library had a copy. I think this book was my introduction to Alex Ross’ art and Kurt Busiek’s writing, both of which are wonderful. It follows the career of Phil Sheldon, a newspaper photographer, from 1939 to the present day. At the start he’s a young man waiting for his chance to be sent to Europe to photograph the war and make a name for himself. Then the first Marvel, the first Human Torch, appears and over the next few years Sheldon comes to believe that the real story may be found not in the war but in the Marvels back home in the USA.
The rest of the book covers the key events in the history of the Marvel Universe – the arrival of Namor the Sub-mariner, the creation of Captain America, the role of Superheroes in the war, the arrival of the X-Men, Gwen Stacey’s murder, the Sentinals, Galactus and the Silver Surfer, the forming of the Fantastic Four and the Avengers. The book is told through Sheldon’s view so we get to see the general public’s view of the Marvels.
I really really like this book. It’s a great introduction to the Marvel Universe and it looks beautiful. An exemplary piece of comic storytelling.
Strawberry Marshmallow volume 2
Fun. A new character, Ana from England is added to the mix. She decides she is losing her Englishness so resolves to never speak Japanese in school, only English. A fine idea, except she didn’t account for her automatic greeting of people in Japanese or that she wouldn’t be able to talk to anyone if she only speaks English.
She accidentally speaks Japanese to Matsuri and so falls in with friendship group This is pretty much the same stuff as volume 1, just with different adventures. If you like volume 1 you’ll like this. If you don’t like this then you don’t have a soul. Fact*.
EDIT: I forgot to mention that one of the kids in this is wearing a Super Furry Animals top. That pleased me no end.
Currently listening to: Rico
*Actually, that's probably not true. If you don’t like Azumanga Daioh then you don’t have a soul. If you don’t like Strawberry Marshmallow you are merely of dubious character.
Sunday, March 30, 2008
DC figures are lame
We got the tube to Tottenham Court Road, turned onto Charing Cross Road and noticed a shop called Orbital comics. This was the awesome - lots of 80s to the present stuff for 50p, a manga selection my ever picky boyfriend was impressed with, to the point of going back later and purchasing 2 books, and this awesome Nightwing figure:
Which I'm now kicking myself about not getting. I'd just spent 12 quid on comics and thought I'd see what Forbidden Planet had to offer.
We got to Forbidden Planet and the DC selection was rubbish. The 12 inch batgirl dolls looked liked men. the material for the costumes all sucked, and the Women of the dc universe ones were rubbish. The expressions were all wrong or they were naked (hello Big Barda). The Zatanna and Donna Troy Wonder Girl ones were good, but not 50 quid of good. Anything of Power Girl and Wonder Woman had the expressions all weird.
I looked at the Marvel section, specifically the Marvel zombies, and they were awesome! Zombie spidey and Mary Jane? Check. Zombie Spidey about to beat someone to death with his own leg? Check. Zombie Cl America? Yep! Even the Harry Potter ones were better!
So I bought bundles of comics for a quid each. I'll wait for the next wave of mini mates to come out instead. And buy the Nightwing one.
Sort it out DC.
Wow. That was a boring post.