datestampFriday, August 8, 2008

Slow learners

I haven't been very political on this blog (my unkind comments about Scott McClellan notwithstanding), which isn't being very true to myself because truth is, I have a passion for politics...world events...C-SPAN.

I've struggled getting excited about the Olympics this year.
And now I think I more clearly understand why.

Did anyone else catch the Opening Ceremonies of the Olympics tonight? I have it on right now, whilst doing things around the house (and trying to get some more miles in). I quickly found myself sucked in right from the get go. I was at first impressed by the magnitude of the 15,000 cast production. And then in awe...in awe-ful awe.

In 1936, Adolf Hitler hosted the world for the Olympics held in Berlin.
They say it was one of the most brilliant acts of propaganda.
For, little did the world know what lie ahead.
Little did they know who they had just let host their celebration.

Did we learn nothing?

I'm disturbed that we are having such a celebration in a country that has been and CONTINUES to be the means for so many crimes against humanity.

It's hard for me to see the President of the United States sit calmly in the stadium while thousands (and perhaps hundreds of thousands) sit in "re-education camps" just miles away. He's the leader of the free world, watching a show in a land where people are not.

I don't think Ronald Reagan or Margaret Thatcher or Pope John Paul or even JFK would be sitting there...acting like it's all okay.

It's not okay.
And it just doesn't feel right to me.

Matt Lauer and Bob Costas talk as if we are witnessing nothing more than a well choreographed production.

But the precision of 2000+ young men drumming (unbelievable to see) and thousands more cast doing karate moves in perfect circles is disturbing. The discipline is impressive. But, it's a reflection of their culture and government.
Does no one see that?

This is a communist regime. A country ruled by few over the many.
There are no freedoms here.
There are no liberties.

I am tempted to be touched by the beauty and pagentry of it all.
The sweet children are a nice touch.
But, let's not forget what we are witnessing.

Much apparent beauty can be created when everything is in perfect harmony.
Communism creates that perfection by force.
That was someone else's idea of executing a plan, if i remember.

I hear Matt Lauer talk about how there is no seen direction for this cast of thousands. "They seem to know this cold," he says.

Yes, they seem to know this cold.
It's all just too cold.
(What if those people wish for something more? A different life? They have no choice. They have no options. Why are we acting like this is normal? Like it's all okay?)

I've been sensitive lately to how willingly we have assisted a communist power to become a viable economic and political force (a force for power while their people have none). We did that. I've done that. Our insatiable appetite for cheap products and "stuff" has given them money to buy us.
They own us.
We are in debt to them.
It bother me.
It scares me.

And now, we've come to their party.

But there are millions...MILLIONS of people in that country not partying. They are working for pennies a day...living in extreme poverty...with nothing that is their own...allowed to only have one child...coerced to follow one path.

The PEOPLE of China deserve this.
Their government, however, does not.

We saw what happened after 1936.
What will happen after this?

We have to stay on our guard...and not be such slow learners.

(Is it bad that in the midst of my political passion I also can't help but think the Netherland male athletes are totally dreamy? I'm a horrible person.)

10 comments:

Steph said...

Yeah, our world is falling apart. And only the strong will stand at the end. It's a scary thought, but the end is here.

David said...

You've made me think...I don't 100% agree...but I thoroughly enjoyed our conversation...and you've made me think.

On another side of this 8-sided coin...there are good things occurring. With the influx of international visitors, the mass population of China has an opportunity for their eyes to be opened. The government can only control so much. And there are good members of the Church there. Although we cannot proselyte, the Spirit cannot be restrained. Eventually the Church will be allowed into China.

I'm not saying the Olympics needed to be hosted in China for these good things to happen...but perhaps it is one tool the Lord will use since the Olympics are there.

The Berlin analogy was interesting. I see a lot of truth to that. Thanks for making me think.

--dave

marialuigi said...

Hi, long time reader first time commenter...

I am also currently watching the opening ceremonies and I could not disagree with you more. The propaganda that is floating around this tremendous event is what scares me. The way people will embrace and fall whole-heartedly into a school of thought that is SO...popular...for lack of a better word. This is an ATHLETIC event.

You liken this to Hitler's Germany Olympics...I will NEVER forget the image of Jesse Owens, an African-American man, competing and blowing away the competition...so profound and so impactful and SO proving Hitler wrong...on a world stage. And, when Jesse Owens went up to Hitler to shake his hand, Hitler refused...a blatant and obvious racial burn...indicative to the evil that WAS Hitler...that is not happening in China. All are welcome. And, people DID know what Hitler was about...in the early 30's...the U.S. was an isolationist country at the time...WE chose to take care of our own problems at the time...we were not a super power...we did not know what was going on...all the OTHER countries knew...they knew Hitler was a fascist...Europe was very afraid. The U.S. said, "we cannot intervene, because it is not our business"...that changed later. People didn't accept Hitler. His propaganda put forth in the Olympic games that were held in Germany was exactly that...propaganda...well, people were not fooled...they knew...countries were afraid...the comparison that you made tonight is not relevant...nor fair...nor true.

My parents are currently living in China. They are impressed by the pride of these beautiful people...and, the Olympics should be representative of the people...not the government. They attend an expatriate branch in the city that they live in...and, the native members attend their branch right before them...the native LDS love God, they love their country, and their hope is that the world will NOT judge the common man by the communist government.

Also, one of my dearest friends is from Canton...she is proud of her country, proud of her history, proud of her success and opportunities that have only recently opened up to her people...and, her hope is also, that there will not be a general vilification of her people. She has noticed a massive change in her country…and hopes that it will continue. Oh...and, the one child PER family thing...it is enforced loosely in many cities and villages. My sweet friend from Canton comes from a family of 3 girls and 1 boy. All native Chinese...all born in China.

It is too easy to follow the popular school of thought...the U.S. population always loves a big, bad enemy. We have seen countries change, we have seen walls come down, the Chinese are children of our Heavenly Father...along with their government officials. I hope a prayer for those sweet and wonderful people. And, a prayer for a softening of the hearts of their leaders. I mostly pray that WE will soften our hearts…and think…and remember.

Oh...and, sweeping racial generalizations are not good. In the 40's people made similar comparisons to the Japanese..."they are too cold, too precise, too controlled."...WE did the Japanese internment camps...here, in the United States...think...remember.We have come a long way as a country...other countries can too.

You are a VERY powerful writer... people will embrace ALL of your words…without thought…please, be careful…you are excellent, by the way. I enjoy, so much, your writing and the thoughts that you share...I just disagree with you tonight. And no, I don't agree with Communism one speck...I do, however, love history and get so bothered by "pet" topics of the day.

The end.

Laurel said...

Maria: Thanks for this. Honestly. It's good to challenge any thought we aren't comfortable with.

I'm totally acknowledging that I need to study up on this more (and absolutey agree that we all have a responsibility to be careful with our words). I just want to reiterate that this was NOT a commentary on the people of China...I said that they deserve this great experience. It was a commentary on the government.

I first read "Life & Death in Shanghai" when I was 16. Next to the scriptures, it is the only book I have read again and again. Nien Cheng who was imprisoned during the cultural revolution. To this day, I feel this odd connection to this relatively unknown woman from China. I was emotionally impacted by her story and how she was SO unfairly and horribly treated by a government who refused he so many basic freedoms.

The impact just came alive last night.

But, I am open to seeing that my opinion is not accurate nor fair nor just. And I'm going to study it up more.

Just wanted to say that it wasn't a pet discussion for me, but could absolutely have shared it more cautiously.

BTW, you really could just be my new favorite person.

Email me.

jamie said...

Laurel- this was a great post. It's funny, while Abe and I were watching the opening ceremonies we both talked about how they are trying to intimidate the world, telling us to "watch out or we'll pummel you" and I added, "with precision". Their precision was incredible and eery all at the same time. I had a lot of the same sentiments that you did while watching, but I see things a little differently. You CANNNOT allow the free market to come into your country and NOT expect your people to demand more. It can't be done, case in point, 1989 and the berlin wall. The free market will always win once a people get a taste of it and isn't it marvelous that China's middle class is on the rise?! I don't know when it will happen, a year from now, 5, 10, 50 years, but the more the government allow their people to taste the power of the free market, their own people will cry for more. We have seen this from the farmers revolting when the government tried to seize their lands a few months ago. They won't stand for it. Now a billion people is a lot of people to reach before the power of the free market start something, but I'm predicting a revolt by the chinese people and they will demand democracy over communism. Am I naive? Am I too optimistic? Maybe, but I believe in the power of a free market. I pray that my appetite for cheap products made in china is adding to the fuel of a revolution, a revolution of freedom. Once again, a country that has never had a middle class has one. It's incredible. There is no other system in this world that works and allows people to dream and fulfill their dreams. Japan embraced the free market and they flourished, south korea embraced the free market and flourished, russia didn't full embrace the free market and their people suffered. I hope and pray that all of this in China is a precursor to the opening of that country for freedom and religion. The church will enter their land, but it will happen only when the majority want it and demand it. :) (P.S. I too have a lot of reading up and studying up to do, and do not consider myself an expert, but from what I do know, I believe wholeheartedly, the free market will empower the chinese!)

Jeanelle said...

I agree with most of what you said. I heard on the radio yesterday (true or not, who knows) that journalists have been instructed to call the smog around China "mist" or else they'd be censored. I also get tired of the pandering by the NBC on-air staff because you know they have to stay in China's good graces and are trying to make back the bazillion dollars they paid to broadcast the games. I will have my TV tuned to CBUT for the next couple of weeks. Less pandering, more global coverage. Thanks for your honesty...

Jill Manning said...

Oh Laurel, I would have loved to have watched it with you. Ty even said during it, "Is it me or is the Chinese using this as a way to make themselves look good to the world?" Oh yes, it was total propaganda. I told him, I love the Chinese people but I have huge issues with the CHinese government. Its all about keeping face with them and appearing to be something more than they are...its pure ego. I even read one article of a man that couldn't get over the moment when the Chinese all stood and sang their national anthem and the pride and robustness of their singing. I felt bad for that author because little did he know that the time the anthem was written, China was at war with Japan and the song is all about killing the enemy (Japan) and the title, "March of the Volunteer," what Mao considered to be "volunteers" the rest of the world would consider to be slaves. So yes I agree, the People of CHina deserve this, but not the government. BTW, you should check out the New Zealand athletes, particularly the rowing team...holy dreamy!

Jill Manning said...

Oh and ps. if you want a good book on how China got to how it is today, you should read the book about Mao (it is all packed up right now so I can't remember the name or the author) but it is written by the same lady that wrote, "Wild Swans" (another great book on Chinese history following three generations of CHInese women starting before the Cultural Revolution). I would actually read that one first. Mao spent a lot of time compensating for the lack of love and acceptance in his life and he took it out on the Chinese people.
As you can probably tell, I have a little place in my heart for all things Chinese.

Anonymous said...

one name. Pieter VanDenhogenbahn. (sp?). Love him.

thanks for the passion in your blog.

Anonymous said...

I actually didn't watch the opening ceremonies. I couldn't bring myself to do so. It's also possible and probable that in my old age I've gotten a tad more jaded.

I seem to recall a very similar circumstance involving the Olympics being held in Russia when I was a teenager. At the time the decision was made to boycott because of their invasion of Afganistan. Then I thought that politics should never be involved in the Olympics. The "Spirit" of the Games is outside politics and the athletes should be allowed to play, to show us for the best that we can and hope to be.

I'm afraid I understand that decision more now than I did then. I still wonder how China escaped this fate. It just makes me go hmmm...

But then, I will also admit, when they split the Olympics and started having them every 2 years (not to mention athletes that get sent home)- well it also took a bit of the shine off for me.

So I guess I'm back to my original assessment, that it's more about how jaded I've become about the games in general.

And isn't it interesting how people can't help but respond about something political :)