| Game | Players | # Investigators | Ancient One | Result* | Expansions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Me | 3 | Nyarlathotep | Loss | None |
| 2 | Me | 3 | Ithaqua | Loss | None |
| 3 | Me Carl James | 3 | Nyarlathotep | Draw | None |
| 4 | Me | 3 | Cthulhu | Win | None |
| 5 | Me Carl James | 3 | Yig | Win | None |
| 6 | Me | 3 | Shub-Niggurath | Loss | King in Yellow |
| 7 | Me James | 4 | Yog-Sothoth | Loss* | King in Yellow |
| 8 | Me James | 4 | Ithaqua | Loss* | King in Yellow |
| 9 | Me James | 4 | Hastur | Loss | Lurker at the Threshold |
| 10 | Me | 3 | Abhoth | Loss | None |
| 11 | Me | 3 | Azathoth | Win | Lurker at the Threshold |
| 12 | Me James | 4 | Yog-Sothoth | Loss | Dunwich Horror |
| 13 | Me Carl | 4 | Shub-Niggurath | Loss | Curse of the Dark Pharoah |
| 14 | Me Carl James | 3 | Azathoth | Win | Dunwich Horror |
| 15 | Me James Carl | 3 | Abhoth | Loss | Dunwich Horror |
| 16 | Me James George Ami | 4 | Nyarlathotep | Loss | Curse of the Dark Pharoah |
| 17 | Me James Carl Ami | 4 | Cthulhu | Loss | Dunwich Horror |
| 18 | Me James | 4 | Nyarlathotep | Win | Curse of the Dark Pharoah |
| 19 | Me James George | 3 | Ithaqua | Win | None |
| 20 | Me James Ami | 3 | Glaaki | Win | Curse of the Dark Pharoah |
| 21 | Me James Ami Stephen Tracey | 5 | Chaugnar Faugn | Loss | All of them |
| 22 | Me James Ami Stephen Tracey | 5 | Nygotha | Loss* | All of them |
| 23 | Me Ami Stephen | 3 | Ghatanathoa | Win | Innsmouth Horror |
* Key of results
- Win - All gates closed or sealed and Ancient One prevented from awakening. Arkham returns to normal and investigators struggle with visions of twisted beings and eldritch places. Until next time...!
- Draw - Ancient One awakens to ravage the Earth but investigators force it back through dimensional gate. Arkham is all but destroyed and the investigators go insane, spending the rest of their lives incarcerated in high security mental asylums. The Earth is saved...until next time!
- Loss - Ancient One awakens and devours all investigators attempting to prevent it's arrival through dimensional gate. The Earth is ravaged and burned and nightmarish creatures from the depths of unknown, cold voids scurry across it's surface. The Ancient One reigns in triumph!
- Loss* - The King in Yellow enters it's final act and Arkham is destroyed in a riot of violence and madness! The Ancient One reigns in triumph!
