The far-right-wing congressional Republicans came very close to shutting down the government again in September. It was averted only on the last day of the fiscal year by John Boehner and a minority of Republicans joining with House Democrats to pass a continuing resolution to fund the federal government until December 11th. That resolution did not include the defunding of Planned Parenthood (which was the issue that the far-right was willing to shut the government down over).
But Boehner knew that doing that would cost him his speakership, so he resigned before doing it. Now the Republicans are fighting among themselves over who the new speaker should be -- with the supposed favorite, Kevin McCarthy, withdrawing from consideration. That means it is likely that the new Speaker (whoever he or she might be) will probably be even farther to the right than Boehner was (which is a scary thought).
It also means we are likely to see the defunding of Planned Parenthood once again included in the proposed House budget on December 11th -- and this time there won't be a Speaker willing to give up his job to stop a government shutdown. And that makes it more likely than not that the government will be shut down in December.
The issue is a silly one. The Republicans want to defund Planned Parenthood -- supposedly to prevent government money being spent to fund abortions. The crazy part is that there is already a law preventing government money being spent for that purpose -- and the Republicans know it, because they are the ones that passed that law. That means they are just playing a political game to please their evangelical/teabagger voter base -- and they are willing to let a huge number of women go without the health care they get from Planned Parenthood to play that electoral game.
Unfortunately for the GOP, while defunding Planned Parenthood may play well with many in their base, it doesn't go over so well with the general public. Most Americans don't want the government shut down over this issue. And as the chart above shows (from a
Rasmussen Poll done on September 30th and October 1st of a random national sample of 1,000 likely voters, with a 3 point margin of error), a majority of Americans still have a favorable opinion of Planned Parenthood -- meaning a shutdown of the government over this issue could cost them in the next election.
They are trying to change the public's opinion. We already know they are telling scurrilous lies about Planned Parenthood, but they are going further. They are also spreading stories about the founder of that organization -- Margaret Sanger (pictured). The most odious of these stories is that Sanger was a racist. This was even claimed by GOP presidential candidate Ben Carson recently.
Of course this is not true. Here is what Politifact (by the
Concord Monitor) has to say about Carson's (and the GOP's) claim:
Answering a question at RiverWoods Retirement Community, Carson said that "Planned Parenthood, as you know, was founded by Margaret Sanger. . . . Margaret Sanger was a eugenicist. She believed that people like me should be eliminated, or kept under control."
At a press conference later, he specified what he meant by "people like me." He said he was "talking about the black race."
Claims like this have been examined by PolitiFact before. Back in March, New Hampshire Rep. William O’Brien claimed Sanger was an "an active participant in the Ku Klux Klan." That claim was rated false.
And in 2011, businessman and GOP presidential candidate Herman Cain said Planned Parenthood’s early mission was to "help kill black babies before they came into the world." That statement was rated Pants on Fire.
Carson’s statement pulls on the same threads.
Sanger was indeed a believer in eugenics, but the basic concept that humanity could be improved by selective breeding was an article of faith for many in the years before World War II. Winston Churchill, Herbert Hoover, Theodore Roosevelt, George Bernard Shaw and H. G. Wells all supported the movement. African-American leader W. E. B. Du Bois backed many of its principles as well.
Although the eugenics movement included some who had racist ideas, wanting to create some sort of master race, "only a minority of eugenicists" ever believed this, according to Ruth Engs, professor emerita at the Indiana University School of Public Health and an expert in the movement.
At the time that Sanger was active, Engs wrote, "the purpose of eugenics was to improve the human race by having people be more healthy through exercise, recreation in parks, marriage to someone free from sexually transmitted diseases, well-baby clinics, immunizations, clean food and water, proper nutrition, non-smoking and drinking."
It’s a far cry to equate eugenics with advocating the elimination of black people.
For Sanger, her ideas were a matter a public health. As late as 1957, she put her views this way in an interview with Mike Wallace: "I think the greatest sin in the world is bringing children into the world -- that have disease from their parents, that have no chance in the world to be a human being practically. Delinquents, prisoners, all sorts of things just marked when they're born. That to me is the greatest sin -- that people can -- can commit."
Sanger was indeed a birth control activist, which means that she wanted women to be able to avoid unwanted pregnancies. She worked for women of all classes and races to have that choice, which she believed to be a right.
Quoted in an article about the false accusation that Sanger supported the Ku Klux Klan (she merely addressed a women’s auxiliary and later compared them to children because of their mental simplicity), Jean H. Baker, author of Margaret Sanger: A Life of Passion, said Sanger actually opposed prejudice.
Sanger "was far ahead of her times in terms of opposing racial segregation," wrote Baker, a history professor at Goucher College, in an email. She worked closely with black leaders to open birth control clinics in Harlem and elsewhere."
Even authors who treat Sanger critically don’t believe she held negative views about African-Americans. Edwin Black wrote a comprehensive history of the eugenics movement, War Against the Weak, and is no fan of the activist’s beliefs. Ultimately, though, he writes, "Sanger was no racist. Nor was she anti-Semitic."
It’s also worth noting that Sanger died in 1966, six years before the Supreme Court established a nationwide right to abortion services in Roe v. Wade.
Those who point a finger at Sanger as a racist often cite a particular statement in claiming she harbored ill will toward black people. In a Dec. 10, 1939, letter, she wrote that "We don’t want word to go out that we want to exterminate the Negro population and the minister is the man who can straighten out that idea if it ever occurs."
But PolitFact Georgia debunked those who would read the statement as something sinister.
"Sanger’s correspondence shows this sentence advocates for black doctors and ministers to play leadership roles in the Negro Project to avoid misunderstandings. Lynchings and Jim Crow laws gave blacks good reason to be wary of attempts to limit the number of children they bore. In Harlem, she hired a black doctor and social worker to quell those fears," the article says.
She attracted an impressive roster of supporters, including DuBois; Mary McLeod Bethune, founder of National Council of Negro Women; and the pastor of the Abyssinian Baptist Church. Eleanor Roosevelt also backed the effort.
"For Sanger to launch a genocidal plot behind their backs and leave no true evidence in her numerous writings would require powers just shy of witchcraft," the PolitiFact piece notes.
Finally, in 1966 Planned Parenthood gave its Margaret Sanger award to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. The civil rights leader accepted, and sent his wife, Coretta, to accept. The speech he wrote for the occasion stated that ""There is a striking kinship between our movement and Margaret Sanger's early efforts."
Sanger was still alive at that point, and her history and statements were well known (she had published an autobiography in 1938 and was never shy about sharing her opinions). If she had, in fact, been a supporter of eliminating black people, it’s doubtful King would have accepted that award.
Our ruling
Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson said that birth control activist Margaret Sanger "believed that people like me should be eliminated." He later clarified that he meant African-Americans. While Sanger indeed supported the eugenics movement, substantial evidence shows that she was not racist and in fact worked closely with black leaders and health care professionals.
Carson’s statement bears no relation to historical reality. We rate the claim False.
