A middle-age woman with h/o hypertension was found down by her husband. Medics found her apneic and pulseless, began CPR, and she was found to be in asystole. With ventilations and epinephrine, she regained a pulse. She was never seen to be in ventricular fibrillation and was never defibrillated. She was hypotensive in the ED and her bedside echo showed a normal RV and LV. BP gradually rose. She was completely comatose (GCS = 3) and pupils were midposition and fixed. Later in the case there was some respiratory effort but no improvement in pupils or any other aspect of the neurologic exam. Two prehospital 12-lead ECGs looked similar to this ED ECG:
|
This shows diffuse ST depression (I, II, III, aVL, aVF, V3-V6) with reciprocal ST elevation in lead aVR. |
This ECG is diagnostic of diffuse subendocardial ischemia.
To quote an email from Francis Fesmire, a great expert on Emergency Cardiac Care: "The new 2013 STEMI guidelines moved away from defining STEMI
as "ST elevation >= 1 mm in two leads or new or presumably new
LBBB" as in previous guidelines and just use the term STEMI with a general
definition of the concept of identifying STEMI on ECG (page e379, under section
2.1). Note that they finally have laid
to rest the “new or presumably new LBBB” as a criteria for STEMI. Also note that they allow ST depression c/w
posterior MI to be a STEMI equivalent.
Finally, they also allow one to consider elevation in aVR to be a STEMI
equivalent providing that it is associated with multilead ST depression...."
In other words, this ECG, in the right clinical scenario, qualifies for a STEMI-equivalent and is an indication for activating the cath lab.
I am not in complete agreement with the recommendation for aVR, because:
1) diffuse subendocardial ischemia is more likely to have non-ACS causes than traditional STEMI ECGs [they are frequently caused by stress cardiomyopathy (usually due to small vessel vasocontriction due to catecholamines) and also by demand ischemia] and
2) when due to ACS, STE in aVR is very infrequently due to coronary occlusion (there is a mistaken belief that ST elevation in aVR with diffuse ST depression is associated with left main occlusion and this is not true!). Rather it is due to coronary insufficiency due to a tight left main or 3-vessel disease with inadequate coronary flow.
Patient course
We did not activate the cath lab, but discussed with cardiology the possible non-urgent need for an angiogram within a few hours.
Because the patient had asystole, was resuscitated without difficulty, and had no neurologic function, suspected a cerebral hemorrhage was suspected as the etiology of the arrest, specifically subarachnoid hemorrhage. She went for a head CT and had a severe subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) due to ruptured aneurysm. Unfortunately, but not surprisingly, the patient died a neurologic death.
What is the utility of a head CT in cardiac arrest?
We studied this and published the abstract below in 2010. We found intracranial hemorrhage in 2% of non-traumatic cardiac arrest patients, and in 4 others the presence of cerebral edema changed management. Those who had STEMI and underwent CT had a prolonged door to balloon time compared to those without a head CT.
Kurkciyan et al. in Vienna found that 27 of 765 (4%) of out of hospital cardiac arrests (OHCA) were due to SAH. In 25 (93%), the initial rhythm was asystole or PEA. Of these, ischemic ST depression was found in 52%. What they do not tell us is the percent of OHCA that were in PEA/Asystole; then we could calculate the percent of OHCA with asystole/PEA which were SAH. If they had a comparable percent to our data (56%), then 428 of 765 had PEA/Asystole and 27/428 (6%) had SAH. So still a small percent of PEA/Asystole presents as SAH. In 23 of 27 cases, the diagnosis was suspected on clinical grounds; 39% had a prodromal headache. Only 1 of 27 survived, after 45 days in the hospital, with a cerebral performance category of 2; this patient had ventricular fibrillation. No patient with PEA/Asystole survived. I believe that the most likely etiology of arrest is brain stem compression, apnea, hypoxia, then asystole, and that it is ventilation, along with chest compressions, that leads to successful cardiac resuscitation.
SAH with cardiac arrest is nearly universally fatal, especially if there is PEA/Asystole. The combination of sudden increased intracranial pressure with loss of spontaneous circulation results in near total loss of cerebral perfusion. The blood pressure produced by chest compressions is inadequate to perfuse the brain when ICP is high.
References
Mulder M. Scott NL. Bart BA. Sprenkle M. Bachour FA. Smith SW. Early Post-resuscitative Care
Of Adult, Non-traumatic Cardiopulmonary Arrests Is Rarely Affected By Routine
Head Computed Tomography Session VII: Best Original Resuscitation Science. Circulation 122:Abstract 101. Presented at American Heart Association. Chicago November 2010.
Background: The role of early
head CT in the management of non-traumatic out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary
arrests (NT-OHCA) is unclear.
Objectives: To evaluate the
diagnostic value of early head CT and its potential drawbacks in NT-OHCA.
Methods: Between June 2007 - July 2009 all NT-OHCA patients
aged >18, transported to our hospital, an urban, level one trauma teaching
hospital were included. Data collected included demographics, initial rhythm,
EKG, emergency department (ED) CT and outcomes. The study population was grouped into those who
did and did not have an early CT. The data was analyzed in relation to initial rhythm,
outcomes and changes or delay in treatment.
Results: In total 201 NT-OHCA were transported to our
ED during the study period; 125 (62%) were successfully resuscitated and
admitted to the hospital, of which 86 (69%) had CT. Initial rhythm in those
with CT was VT/VF in 33/86 (38%), PEA/asystole 48/86 (56%), and unspecified
5/86 (6%). Evidence of cerebral edema was found more commonly in patients with
PEA/asystole 20/48 (42%) vs. VT/VF 4/33 (12%), p=0.006. In-hospital mortality for patients with
cerebral edema was 20/20 (100%) in patients with PEA/asystole and 1/4 (25%) in
VT/VF, p=0.002. Fifty-five of 125 (41 VT/VF, 11 PEA/asystole and 3 unspecified)
resuscitated patients survived to discharge. CT detected intracranial
hemorrhages in 2/86 (2%) of patients. Significant changes in clinical
management as a direct result of head CT were uncommon; occurring in 5/86 (6%) resuscitated
NT-OHCA patients. Fourteen (16%) of the 86 patients who had CT also had
immediate cardiac catheterization for acute ischemic changes; 7 of which had
primary percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Door to balloon time (DBT) was
96 minutes for 7 patients with ST elevation myocardial infarctions (STEMI) who had
CT prior to PCI vs. 75 minutes for 11 patients who did not have CT, p=0.058.
Conclusions: Head CT is common
in NT-OHCA. Cerebral edema is more
common in patients presenting with an initial rhythm of PEA/asystole than in
VT/VF and is associated with higher mortality.
Management is rarely affected by routine use of early head CT. In those
who required urgent PCI, CT was associated with a (non-statistically
significant) 21 minute longer mean DBT.
Kurkciyan et al., abstract
Objective:
Spontaneous subarachnoid haemorrhage as a cause of out-of-hospital
cardiac arrest is poorly evaluated. We analyse disease-specific and
emergency care data in order to improve the recognition of subarachnoid
haemorrhage as a cause of cardiac arrest. Design: We searched a
registry of cardiac arrest patients admitted after primarily successful
resuscitation to an emergency department retrospectively and analysed
the records of subarachnoid haemorrhage patients for predictive
features. Results: Over 8.5 years, spontaneous subarachnoidal
haemorrhage was identified as the immediate cause in 27 (4%) of 765
out-of-hospital cardiac arrests. Of these 27 patients, 24 (89%)
presented with at least three or more of the following common features:
female gender (63%), age under 40 years (44%), lack of co-morbidity
(70%), headache prior to cardiac arrest (39%), asystole or pulseless
electric activity as the initial cardiac rhythm (93%), and no recovery
of brain stem reflexes (89%). In six patients (22%), an intraventricular
drain was placed, one of them (4%) survived to hospital discharge with a
favourable outcome. Conclusions: Subarachnoid haemorrhage
complicated by cardiac arrest is almost always fatal even when a
spontaneous circulation can be restored initially. This is due to the
severity of brain damage. Subarachnoid haemorrhage may present in young
patients without any previous medical history with cardiac arrest
masking the diagnosis initially.