| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 IWTV SVW SuplexMania: The Block Party
Apr 6th 2024 | Dave McCall (c) & Nate Carter (c) | def. | Mike Walker & Vinny Talotta | | BSP Tri-State Tag Team Titles
|
CZW Don't Blink
Mar 9th 2024 | Mike Walker & Vinny Talotta | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW 25th Anniversary
Feb 4th 2024 | Athan Promise & Juni Underwood & Miles Penn & Ryan Ryzz | def. | Dave McCall & Mike Walker & Nate Carter & Vinny Talotta | 8-person tag | |
CZW Limelight 23
Dec 17th 2023 | Athan Promise & Juni Underwood | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Live At The Battleship
Nov 19th 2023 | Athan Promise & Juni Underwood & Miles Penn | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter & Vinny Talotta | 6-person tag | |
CZW Limelight 19
Aug 6th 2023 | Brandon Watts & Randy Summers | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | Last Man Standing (tag) | |
CZW Limelight 18
Jul 1st 2023 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Josh Fuller & Mikey Banker | | |
CZW Limelight 17
Jun 4th 2023 | Sage Chantz & Tommy Rant | def. (DQ) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Best of the Best 19
May 20th 2023 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | E.N. Bush & Matt Quay | | |
CZW Limelight 16
May 7th 2023 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Brandon Watts & Randy Summers | | |
CZW Limelight 15
Apr 2nd 2023 | Brandon Watts & Randy Summers & Sage Chantz & Tommy Rant | def. | Dave McCall & Kris Bishop & Nate Carter | handicap tag | |
CZW Live!
Mar 19th 2023 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Micah Cortez & Seth Cortez | | |
CZW Limelight 14
Mar 5th 2023 | Boom Harden & Desean Pratt | def. | Brandon Watts & Randy Summers, Dave McCall & Nate Carter, Mike Walker & Vinny Talotta | ladder (4-way tag) | CZW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
CZW Scouting Combine 2023 - Day 2
Jan 15th 2023 | Dave McCall & Kris Bishop & Nate Carter | def. | Aleksy Lev & Nick Stevens & Tom Marciano | 6-person tag | |
CZW Live! The Arrival
Dec 18th 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Mike Walker & Vinny Talotta | | |
CZW Limelight 12
Dec 4th 2022 | Dave McCall & Mike Walker & Nate Wallace & Vinny Talotta | def. | Boom Harden & Brandon Watts & Desean Pratt & Randy Summers | 8-person tag | |
SHP Colby Corino's Painted Black
Nov 3rd 2022 | Lance Lude & Rob Killjoy | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Limelight 10
Oct 2nd 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Sage Chantz & Tommy Rant | | |
CZW Live!
Sep 25th 2022 | Brandon Watts & Eran Ashe & Randy Summers | def. | Dave McCall & Griffin McCoy & Nate Carter | 6-person tag | |
ECWA Tag Team Super 8 Tournament 2022
Sep 17th 2022 | Jay Lyon & Midas Black | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Limelight 9
Sep 4th 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Eran Ashe & Griffin McCoy | | |
CZW Live At The Oval
Aug 20th 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Boom Harden & Desean Pratt | | |
CZW Limelight 8
Aug 7th 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Rich Swann & Willie Mack | | |
CZW Live!
Jul 24th 2022 | Boom Harden & Desean Pratt | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter, Griffin McCoy & Matt Quay, Isaiah Wolf & Marcus Marquee | four-way tag | |
CZW Unscripted
Jun 19th 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Jhonny Santos & Sebastian Cage | | |
CZW Limelight 6
Jun 5th 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Jaden Valo & Michael Mistretta | | |
CZW Tensions Rising
May 22nd 2022 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Isaiah Wolf & Marcus Marquee | lumberjack (tag) | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 18
May 5th 2022 | Dustin Waller & Ichiban & Kylon King | def. | Channing Thomas & Dave McCall & Nate Carter | 6-person tag | |
CZW Limelight 5
May 1st 2022 | Isaiah Wolf & Marcus Marquee & Tyree Taylor | def. | Dave McCall & Grim & Nate Carter | 6-person tag | |
HOG Tribulations
Apr 15th 2022 | Jay Lyon & Midas Black | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Limelight 3
Mar 6th 2022 | J. P. Grayson & Tommy Grayson | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW 23
Feb 27th 2022 | Dave McCall & Kris Bishop & Nate Carter | def. (DQ) | Isaiah Wolf & Marcus Marquee & Tyree Taylor | 6-person tag | |
CZW Limelight
Jan 2nd 2022 | J. P. Grayson & Tommy Grayson | def. | Isaiah Wolf & Marcus Marquee, Kris Bishop & Nate Carter | three-way tag | |
CZW The Fight Within
Dec 19th 2021 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Eli Knight & Malik Bosede | | |
HOG Born Again
Nov 12th 2021 | Chris Seaton & Smoothe Blackmon | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Season 3 Episode 4
Oct 28th 2021 | Eel O'Neal & Jordan Blade | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Renaissance Of Tradition
Oct 24th 2021 | Dave McCall & Kris Bishop & Nate Carter | def. | Isaiah Wolf & Marcus Marquee & Tyree Taylor | 6-person tag | |
Beyond The Signature Series #1
Feb 25th 2021 | PB Smooth & Tre Lamar | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
GCW Fight Forever: For The Culture
Jan 29th 2021 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Faye Jackson & Willow Nightingale | | |
Beyond Shangri-La Magistral
Sep 20th 2020 | Brandon Watts & Randy Summers | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Saturday Night Special
Mar 21st 2020 | Bear Boulder & Bear Bronson | def. (DQ) | Dave McCall (c) & Nate Carter (c) | | CZW Tag Team Titles
|
CZW 21st Anniversary
Feb 8th 2020 | Dave McCall (c) & Nate Carter (c) | def. | Adrian Alanis & Liam Gray | | CZW Tag Team Titles
|
Beyond Please Come Back 2020
Jan 25th 2020 | Bear Boulder & Bear Bronson | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Cage of Death XXI
Dec 14th 2019 | Dave McCall (c) & Nate Carter (c) | def. | Bear Boulder & Bear Bronson | | CZW Tag Team Titles
|
CZW To Hell And Back
Oct 26th 2019 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Anthony Gangone (c) & Homicide | | CZW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
CZW Down with the Sickness 2019
Sep 13th 2019 | Anthony Gangone (c) & Matt Tremont | def. | Dave McCall (c) & Nate Carter (c) | | CZW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
CZW Dojo Wars 229
Sep 4th 2019 | Kee Min | def. (DQ) | Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars SuperShow 23
Aug 23rd 2019 | Kris Bishop | def. | Nate Carter | | |
CZW/wXw CZW vs. wXw
Aug 10th 2019 | Alexander James & Jurn Simmons | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Lyle C. Williams Memorial Show
Jul 12th 2019 | Dave McCall (c) & Nate Carter (c) | def. | Jimmy Lloyd & Matt Tremont | CZW Rules (tag) | CZW Tag Team Titles
|
Nate Carter