| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WrestlePro Alaska: Back With a Bang
Oct 1st 2022 | Bobby Bishop & Bryson Axl & CPA | def. | Ben Dossman & Buff Bagwell & Gunnar | 6-person tag | |
GCW Joey Janela's Spring Break 6 Part 2
Apr 1st 2022 | A. J. Gray, Mance Warner, Matthew Justice | def. | 1 Called Manders, Alec Price, Big Vin, Billie Starkz, Blake Christian, Brandon Kirk, Buff Bagwell, Charlie Tiger, Cole Radrick, Damian Drake, Dante Leon, Deranged, Edith Surreal, Ellis Taylor, George Gatton, Grim Reefer, Guy Steele, Hoodfoot, Hunter Freeman, Jack Cartwheel, Jai Vidal, Janai Kai, Jazzy Yang, Jimmy Lloyd, Jimmy Wang Yang, Joey Janela, Josh Barnett, Ju Dizz, Judas Judd Cassidy, Juicy Finau, Kamikaze, Kevin Blackwood, Kevin Matthews, Levi Everett, Lord Adrean, LuFisto, Matt Vandagriff, Maven, Nasty Leroy, Nate Webb, Nick Wayne, Parrow, Rhett Titus, Sam Stackhouse, Sandra Moone, Sean Ross Sapp, Shazza McKenzie, Slade, The Dark Sheik, The Invisible Man, Yoya | Clusterfuck Battle Royal | |
Glory Pro Unsanctioned
Oct 19th 2018 | Buff Bagwell & Scott Norton & Sean Waltman | def. | Danny Adams & Kevin Lee Davidson & Mike Outlaw | 6-person tag | |
WCPBTW The First Capital End of Summer Extravaganza
Aug 18th 2017 | Buff Bagwell | def. | The Sheik Of Syria | Loser Waves the Winner's Flag | |
 wXw Superstars of Wrestling 2017
May 13th 2017 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Jaxon Stone | | |
Legends of Wrestling Augusta Show
Mar 25th 2017 | Buff Bagwell & Johnny Swinger | def. | Deimos & Raffi Rex | | |
WCPBTW Holiday Havoc - Night Of the Stinger
Dec 2nd 2016 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Cody Hawk | | |
WCPBTW The Gathering: Night Of The Living Legends
Aug 12th 2016 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Shane Douglas | | |
WCPBTW The Gathering: Night Of The Living Legends
Aug 12th 2016 | Buff Bagwell | draw (DCO) | Shane Douglas | grudge match | |
PWS Super Card 2014
Jun 7th 2014 | Craig Steele | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2014 - Day 2
May 24th 2014 | Ethan Page | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2014 - Day 1
May 23rd 2014 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Jock Samson | | |
Heroes & Legends III
Mar 22nd 2014 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Troy Miller | | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2013
Nov 30th 2013 | Caprice Coleman & Cedric Alexander | def. | Harlem Bravado & Lance Bravado, Ricky Morton & Robert Gibson, Mosh & Thrasher, George South & Manny Fernandez, Buff Bagwell & Rick Steiner, Meng & The Barbarian, Ax & Smash | tag team turmoil | |
PWS Return to Rahway
Sep 20th 2013 | Colt Cabana | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
DREAMWAVE Retaliation 2013
May 4th 2013 | Matt Cage | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
JCW Pontiac Show (December '09)
Dec 19th 2009 | The Weedman | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
PMG Ultimate Clash of Legends
Apr 27th 2007 | Brian Christopher | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
World Wrestling Legends 6:05 - The Reunion
Mar 5th 2006 | Scott Steiner | def. (pin) | Buff Bagwell | | |
GLCW Blizzard Brawl
Dec 9th 2005 | Diamond Dallas Page | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
NWA TNA Weekly PPV #44
May 7th 2003 | Glenn Gilberti | def. (pin) | Brian Lawler, Buff Bagwell, D-Lo Brown, James Storm, Justin Credible, Kid Kash, Konnan, Mike Awesome, Perry Saturn, Rick Steiner, Ron Killings, Sabu, Sonny Siaki, Traci Brooks | "Anarchy In The Asylum" Battle Royale | |
 WWA Belfast Show (December '02)
Dec 8th 2002 | Lex Luger & Sting | def. | Buff Bagwell & Jeff Jarrett | | |
WWA Manchester Show (December '02)
Dec 7th 2002 | Lex Luger & Sting | def. | Buff Bagwell & Jeff Jarrett | | |
WWA The Retribution
Dec 6th 2002 | Buff Bagwell & Johnny Swinger | def. (pin) | Malice & Norman Smiley | | |
WWA Newcastle Show (December '02)
Dec 5th 2002 | Nathan Jones & Sting | def. | Buff Bagwell & Lex Luger | | |
WWA Brighton Show (December '02)
Dec 1st 2002 | Nathan Jones & Sting | def. | Buff Bagwell & Malice | | |
WWA London Show (November '02)
Nov 30th 2002 | Nathan Jones & Sting | def. | Buff Bagwell & Malice | | |
WWA Birmingham Show (November '02)
Nov 29th 2002 | Lex Luger & Sting | def. | Buff Bagwell & Malice | | |
 WWA Dublin Show (November '02)
Nov 28th 2002 | Lex Luger & Sting | def. | Buff Bagwell & Malice | | |
NWA TNA Weekly PPV #13
Sep 18th 2002 | Chris Harris & Brian Lee | def. | Ace Steel & CM Punk & B. G. James & Buff Bagwell & Brian Lawler & Disco Inferno & Derek Wylde & Jimmy Rave & James Storm & Joel Maximo & Jose Maximo & Jorge Estrada & Sonny Siaki & Kobain & Slash & Ron Harris & Scott Hall & Syxx-Pac | "Gauntlet For The Gold" (tag) | |
NWA TNA Weekly PPV #3
Jul 3rd 2002 | Bruce & Lenny Lane | def. (pin) | Apolo & Buff Bagwell | | |
NWA TNA Weekly PPV #1
Jun 19th 2002 | Ken Shamrock, Malice | def. | Apolo, Brian Christopher, Bruce, Buff Bagwell, Chris Harris, Del Rios, Devon Storm, Jeff Jarrett, K-Krush, Konnan, Lash LeRoux, Norman Smiley, Prince Justice, Rick Steiner, Scott Hall, Slash, Steve Corino, Vampire Warrior | "Gauntlet For The Gold" | |
 WWA The Eruption
Apr 13th 2002 | Brian Christopher & Ernest Miller | def. (pin) | Buff Bagwell & Stevie Ray | | |
WWA Perth Show (April '02)
Apr 10th 2002 | Buff Bagwell & Ernest Miller | def. | Disqo & Stevie Ray | | |
WWA Sydney Show (April '02)
Apr 7th 2002 | Buff Bagwell & Ernest Miller | def. (pin) | Disqo & Stevie Ray | | |
XWF Lubbock Show (Feb '02)
Feb 23rd 2002 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Johnny B. Badd | | |
XWF Amarillo Show (Feb '02)
Feb 22nd 2002 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Johnny B. Badd | | |
XWF Green Bay Show (Dec '01)
Dec 30th 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Curt Hennig, Vampiro | three-way | |
XWF Milwaukee Show (Dec '01)
Dec 29th 2001 | Johnny B. Badd & Vampiro | def. | Buff Bagwell & Curt Hennig | | |
XWF Hammond Show (Dec '01)
Dec 28th 2001 | Vampiro | def. | Buff Bagwell, Curt Hennig | three-way | |
WWA Cardiff Show (December '01)
Dec 11th 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Stevie Ray | | |
WWA Newcastle Show (December '01)
Dec 9th 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Stevie Ray | | |
WWA Glasgow Show (December '01)
Dec 8th 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Stevie Ray | | |
WWA Manchester Show (December '01)
Dec 5th 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Disqo | | |
WWA London Show (December '01)
Dec 3rd 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Disqo | | |
WWA Birmingham Show (December '01)
Dec 1st 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Stevie Ray | | |
WWA Dublin Show (November '01)
Nov 28th 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Stevie Ray | | |
WWA Belfast Show (November '01)
Nov 27th 2001 | Buff Bagwell | def. | Stevie Ray | | |
XWF TV Taping #9
Nov 14th 2001 | Vampiro | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
XWF TV Taping #4
Nov 13th 2001 | Curt Hennig | def. | Buff Bagwell | | |
Buff Bagwell