About Me

My photo
On the planet since 1973. Living in sin with M since 1997 and honestly since 2002. Failing at baby-making since 2005. And whining about it here since 2008. Come on in and sit a spell. This train wreck never seems to end.

Friday, August 14, 2009

really letting go

It all seemed silly really.

I never saw 2 lines. I never had a due date. I was never pregnant.

The logical part of my head had trouble categorizing this as a loss in any traditional sense. Maybe if there was a sympathy card about the loss of one’s embryos who never implanted, the rest of the world (including myself) might be ready to recognize it too. I mean because if Hallmark doesn't make a card for it, it doesn't actually exist right??

I felt so awkward for even thinking about doing anything to say good bye to 11 embryos that never fully existed, but our new therapist suggested we write them a letter and figure out a way we were comfortable with saying good bye.

Right. Easy enough.

We had 2 weeks in between appointments and my emotions ran the gamut about writing that letter. In her office I thought it sounded like a great idea. A couple days later I was debating the usefulness of it. A week into it and I was adamantly refusing to participate (all within my own head anyway).

Finally, I wrote it over my lunch hour at work a couple days before we were to return (because nothing says good bye like a letter written under pressure over a bagel sandwich, right?) It was where I had to do it so I wouldn't over think every word and analyze what I should/shouldn't say. It was the only way I could get it done and have it be directly from my heart without all the extra chatter from my head.

It was an excuse to avoid all the emotions I was feeling...

Marveled that I had done it at all, I folded up the letter and threw it in my purse.

Now what to do with it... Crap.

When my dad died, people flooded my childhood home. They brought food and flowers, gave hugs, shared their stories or thoughts about him, and listened while we shared ours. They cried with us, laughed with us, took care of things we couldn't, and helped us grieve while we said good bye. They told us how sorry they were for our loss.

His death was the end of my life with a father and I got there was no chance of him coming back. The dreams I had of him escorting me down the aisle at my wedding, of placing my child in his arms for the first time, of simply having an adult-adult relationship with him were over.

We had a viewing, funeral, and burial. Our overwhelming feelings were comforted through these familiar traditions, community support, and incredible memories. We were not ready, but together we faced our loss as we were forced to say good bye.

After 4 years of infertility, countless doctors, surgeries, medical procedures, and nearly seventy grand in uninsured medical expenses, M and I were facing another type of loss. The biological children we longed for and had fought so hard to have would never be. This time we were making the decision to say good bye.

Nobody showed up with casseroles or thoughtful words with hugs or condolences. Nobody stopped by to share our grief, wipe our tears, or listen to us share our thoughts. There were no traditional ceremonies to follow, no road map of sorts to help us pave our way, yet we had to figure out a way to say good bye to our weren't-meant-to-be children.

We I decided to tie our letters to helium filled balloons and let them go. It seemed simple enough, but when I walked into Par.ty City my thoughts were suddenly jumbled with what to get.

Would 2 be enough to take our letters up? What colors? Doesn't every one of our embryos deserve their own balloon? Is M going to think I've lost my mind if I buy 11 balloons? Why are there so damn many children's balloons?

It was finally my turn and I blurted that I needed 11 without much thought: 4 blue, 4 pink, 3 white. Done.

As they were being filled I noticed a woman (who was buying balloons for her 16 year old daughter's birthday) glance and smile. Oh no. I knew what she was thinking and couldn't possibly let her ask the question. Why had I not analyzed this one some more? Pink and blue? Really? Stupid. I wandered to the nearest aisle and found myself in a sea of baby shower party favors.

Fuck. And there they were. The tears I had been avoiding all throughout this part of the process had found me. I could feel the burn in my chest and the pressure building in my throat. I had no control at this point and just let the tears roll while I stared at plastic pacifiers and tiny stuffed duckies.

When the balloons were done I practically ran out the door, tears still freely flowing. I hated the stares and little grins that I saw and wanted to tell everyone that I was not about to give my husband some good news, that these were not hormonal happy tears, that this was not at all what they thought it was. "These are all dead ones!!" I wanted to scream to the very pregnant woman holding hands with her husband behind me in line or to the sweet older couple who held the door as I took all the balloons back inside after 2 popped from the hot summer day - yes, really.

Finally, it was done.

When M got home, we drove to a secluded area in the Angel.es Nation.al Forest and said good bye to the babies who would have shared our genes – dark haired, blue eyed little cuties dotted with my freckles and cursed with M's crooked toes. There weren't any memories or stories to be had, but they held a lifetime of hopes and dreams.

We read our letters. We laughed. We cried. We tied them to the balloons and held one another as we let them go – our balloons, our letters, our babies, our dream of pregnancy and shared genetic parenthood, our life that was not meant to be.
Suddenly it wasn't all so silly...

79 comments:

Lisa said...

It never was silly.

RB said...

My therapist also had me write letters to the children that would never be. I thought, "Oh, please." But after I did it and had my own personal ceremony for them and for Bruce, the hurt began to heal. The scar will always be there, but the wound won't be. I think the way you said your goodbyes was perfect, absolutely perfect. It was never silly.

Here for you always...

danbnan said...

I'm sitting here in a puddle of tears...grieving this loss is so incredibly hard, yet so important. I have my two little miracles, but letting go of knowing they would be a little of me and a little of DH was hands down the most difficult decision of our lives. It sucked...and still does. No way around it and to this day, it creeps up when we least expect it and just plain hurts. What you and M did was beautiful...and yes, sometimes grief IS in fact beautiful...because of what it allows us to feel, say, and be for ourselves and for one another. Thinking of you always my dear...((((hugs))))

Claudia said...

Oh, B. I wish I knew what to say.

To you.

To me.

To all of us who have had to let go of that dream.

Shelby said...

Brenda, this is a beautiful post that left me in tears. As others have said, this was never silly. Those children existed as much in your heart as they would have here on earth--the only difference was that others could not see them. It is unfortunate that the world will not acknowledge this as the loss it is, but that is only due to ignorance, not because it deserves any less recognition.

I am so sorry you've had to say goodbye, but I am hoping that this will only lend to your healing. Take care, friend.

'Murgdan' said...

Not silly. Beautiful...perfect. Needless to say this post made me cry, because I think it was such a fitting way to say goodbye. And you are right, nobody recognizes that kind of loss. You were right to recognize it.

Thinking of you. Thank you for all your wonderful comments. You always make me smile.

DAVs said...

Oh Brenda.
My heart is hurting for you.

I wish I was there to bring you a casserole, to hug you, to talk about your loss because it is SO REAL--it is more real than anyone who hasn't gone through it can ever, ever understand.

Your tribute is beautiful.

Sue said...

I'm sitting here crying from your post. I really have no words. Its good that you cried...but I wish some of us could have brought the casseroles - and our shoulders to cry on - we get it. We are there with you. It doesn't seem like it since we are all so far away, but we are there.

Suzanne said...

Crap, you made me cry. That is one of the sweetest, most beautiful gestures I think I've ever heard.

Jill M. said...

As always, so well written. You really know how to pull your audience into your emotions. Yeah, I cried, again.

I wish I could have attended your memorial service, brought a dish and a hug. I wish there was a Hallmark card for this type of circumstance. Maybe you're onto something?

You know when someone goes through a tragedy, sometimes they end up going around giving public talks, educating people on things like drunk driving, etc. There is something about it that gives them healing. You would make a great speaker educating people on infertility. I know you could completely pull them into the realities of the deep pain associated with it. Have you ever considered something like this?

Hugs my friend.

Rebecca Frech said...

I read somewhere that there was nothing more painful than the loss of a "remembered future." I think it's true.

I'm so sorry for the pain you have gone through and the pain you are in now. You are both in my prayers this morning.

B and D said...

Brenda- you have me in tears! What a beautiful tribute. Nothing about any of this (the situation, the range of emotions, the saying goodbye) was ever silly. I know that the hurt will never disappear but I hope that every little step closer to closure helps heal the wounds a little more.

I wish that I were close by so that you could have a live shoulder to lean on :) Thinking of you and sending hugs!!

Flying Monkeys said...

What a beautiful post. It never was silly and they were/are real. In my heart all the embryos that we lost are still my babies. In my weirdness I sometimes wonder if a redhead was in there or a daughter.
I'm sorry for you loss, I didn't bring casserole but I showed up here.
What a great tribute to your babies.

Ree said...

What a beautiful post Brenda, perfect goodbye.
My heart is sad for you today.

Just Another Mother said...

It took about five minutes before I could see through my tears enough to comment. This is really one of the most beautiful, heartbreaking posts I have ever read. You gave them all a touching goodbye.

Wendy said...

I wish I could hug you right now, B. Why are you so far away??? What a hard experience. You're right about how dealing with this kind of loss is so different - family and friends don't know what to say or how to act. Not a hallmark occasion, like you said.
I am all teared-up right now. The photo of your balloons - that was such a real and tangible way to see some of the loss you've experienced and the perfect way to say goodbye. I hope that doing this and continuing to work through it all helps you and M heal. Huge hugs. I'm here for you always.

Liz said...

Perfect tribute.

Anonymous said...

Even though we have never met, I think about you all the time. That was a beautiful tribute.

Deathstar said...

I found your through Wishing4One which I found through Stirrup Queens.... and when I read this post, I knew exactly what you meant and it really touched my heart. You're right. There are no society approved rituals to say goodbye to what might have beens, but you did something that I wish we had done. Once, I wrote a letter to a daughter I would never have. And I even talked to an empty chair trying to say goodbye to the dream that was her. The process of letting go is not even over with one, two or three gestures. The grief comes and goes. Every day we are reminded of what we lost, every single day.

Angie said...

I don't know what to say...sitting here with a stream of tears as my heart hurst for you....need to say, I am in awe of your strength and courage. You are so right, it is a loss - and it needs to be recognized as such. So proud of you for figuring out a way to say good-bye. Not silly at all. Know that we are here, even though it seems like so far away. (((hugs)))

bb said...

I am so sorry for all that you have lost. Your beautiful post brought tears to my eyes. I hope the act of writing these letters and letting them go will help your days and nights get easier. You are often in my thoughts and always in my prayers. {{hugs}}

Me said...

I'm crying for you B. Literally. Right now. I'm so fucking sorry.

Brenna said...

It's a beautiful thing. I'm so glad that you held a ceremony to recognize the loss of the children you held so close in your heart and in your dreams. We all recognize the reality of your loss and how very UNsilly it is to mourn something you tried for so long to realize.

Plant Girl said...

It is not silly, nor was it ever. Like the Monkey said, I'm sorry too, no casseroles to share, but I showed up to give my support.

Sometimes I think the emotional toll is much harder than the physical. I struggle immensely with allowing myself to face my emotions and work through them.

Sending you love and hugs.

lavendar said...

I'm in tears.......I feel your pain...We have one more shot and if this doesnt work......we have lost 13 embryos......WHY,WHY,WHY....will we ever know.....Just Know..... you are not alone my dear. We are here with you.

Meg. said...

Thank you so much for sharing this incredibly personal, poignant moment with us. As are all your other readers, I'm crying too.

When my Grandpa died (who I loved so much), my family had all the Grandchildren write a letter to him, which we then attached to balloons...and let them drift away in the breeze. It was beautiful. I'm so glad you did this for your children as well.

I am grieving with you. I acknowledge the breadth of your loss. It is real, and it is powerful.

shocks said...

Wow! I got goose bumps and teary-eyed reading this post! I'm so glad you were able to find a way to "let go". I can't imagine how you are feeling, but know that we are all here for you!!

Emily said...

Oh Brenda...What a beautiful and heartbreaking post. I bawled my way through it and then bawled some more as I read it to my Dh. I am so sorry for everything you have been through. Thinking of you and those 11 embies - me heart hurts. What a beautiful way to honor their existence. HUGS!

kayjay said...

I'm crying. What a beautiful tribute and it has such incredible, heart-felt, deep in your gut kind of true meaning. You took your therapist's suggestion and turned it into such a healing act for you and your DH. Just because Hallmark doesn't make a card for this doesn't mean that it isn't real. Hallmark is great, but sometimes I think they don't even know what to say in these situations. I would have brought you a casserole and a big box of kleenex with lotion.

Rebel With.A.Cause said...

Oh B.... That was one of the most beautiful things I have read in awhile.

While we do have Turtle, I can so feel the pain that you are feeling.

My heart is with you.

Wishing 4 One said...

Man. I just don't know what to say. Thanks for writing this beautiful, gorgeous post that made me cry today. Possibly THE most wonderful tribute to Infertility ever.

Illanare said...

I can only echo what others have written already. I'm so very sorry for your pain, and I think what you did was beautiful and not at any point even remotely silly.

My thoughts are with you.

Kristin said...

God how heartbreaking and beautiful at the same time. My thoughts and prayers are with you both.

asandersbonelli said...

I love that you did this! Each embryo is filled with the potential for what every infertile woman longs for more than anything, and it is fitting that you memorialize such a massive loss. I hope this brought you one step closer to healing.

P.S. I nominated you for an award.

Sweet said...

I found you through Wishing4one...glad I did. Saying good-bye in this way is beautiful...I am sorry for your loss, but your strength is remarkable.

becoming whole said...

Thank you so much for sharing this. Not silly, profound.

Beautiful post that touched the place in me that still hurts.

Billy said...

What a lovely way to say goodbye. So not silly, and as others said - never was.

Lisa said...

This beautiful post brought tears to my eyes. Tears I had to fight back because I was heading out to get my picture taken and I knew I'd lose it completely if I gave into the full feeling of this post.

What a touching ceremony for closure.

Every embryo counts. Every embryo counts.

Ashley said...

I love this post! I love you! And I love the honesty you hate to (sometimes) admit! You are soooo back, girl and I couldn't be more thrilled. Thank you for continuing to document your journey- real feelings and real hurts, even when you don't want know what decision to make.

Your goodbye was perfect and a humbling experience for me. It is so you and so honest. Thank you.

I'm here for you and still think of you more than you know. I just don't want to push you or take you to a place you don't want to go.

Love you, dear. Thank you again for this beautiful and raw post, and I am proud of you and hubs for going to counseling together.

battynurse said...

Not silly. This is truly a beautiful post.

AnotherDreamer said...

Not silly. Never.
So sorry you had to say goodbye.

This post was so beautiful. Thank you for sharing it.

S said...

Great post.

The loss of knowing your own, living child is very real, whether you were ever pregnant or not. Harder in some ways, because the world at large is less likely to acknowledge it as a loss. I hope that this tribute to that loss brings you some solace.

Anonymous said...

what a great post. of course, it hit my right between the eyes. i only made four embies (two cycles), but i loved them and i lost them within just a few days time.

there is no category for this kind of loss, no recognized precedence. sometimes, i feel like people don't even want to talk about failed cycles. its too scary to think that IVF can't fix everything.

what you did was really beautiful and i hope that it helps to start the healing for you.

many hugs.

Paula Keller said...

Oh Brenda... you have my heart.

I might be right there with you soon.

Many hugs.

Amaprincess said...

This is my first time reading your blog and I am completely crying!

Things are so unfair sometimes! Your strength to let go is inspiring! My hubby and I just began our journey ....I have all the same fears and emptiness as you....Your feelings are never silly!

Bluebird said...

Here with you, reading through the tears.

((Hugs))

..al said...

Am so happy that Wishing4One sent me your way. And so sad that it had to end like this.

Fuck. I hear whispers of AMA myself and it sends shivers down my spine.

When I was 21, I was closer to 25 than 30. Now when I am 31, I feel closer to 40 than 35. I feel like a race-hopper.

I am happy that there was some closure, of some sort that you could bring to your babies,and I so understand when you speak of the corollaries in the world's reaction to your dad's death and your decision to not pursue the path of pregnancy.

Take Care.

niobe said...

Your post and photo took my breath away.

Tara said...

It was never silly. My heart aches with you.

Much love, my friend.

Steph said...

That was wonderful, not silly at all. A very moving post B.

Chickenpig said...

This was a lovely post. I am so sorry for your loss, all of them. And I don't think the letters and balloons are silly at all.

I'm handing you a virtual casserole right now. No need to return the dish

Deanna said...

Take comfort in old shoes, but along a new path.

Kate said...

You write beautifully and helped me fully experience your emotions as you said goodbye. I'm so sorry that this happened. I wish I could bring by a casserole and share a hug for your grief. *hugs*

LFCA

ashley moon said...

I never imagined dealing with infertility would be this hard.

ashley moon said...

I am am beginning my first IVF cycle this month and I would not wish this on anyone.

Anonymous said...

here from lfca - this post is beautiful and has me sobbing. i am so sorry for the loss of your 11 precious embryos. thank you for sharing this with us and letting us remember with you.

Michele said...

I dont think it was silly at all. Those embryos were your babies. Completely and totally, even if they were tiny and never produced that BFP or grew into full term babies. They will always be your babies.

Thinking of you and those perfect little ones...

Clare said...

A beautiful way to say goodbye. This post had me in tears. Nothing silly about it at all. Profound and genuine.

Unknown said...

Wow... I, too, am in tears. I think that was beautiful for you to do and share with your DH - as much as my heart hurts for you - it is also filled with hope that you will find your peace. XOXOXOXO

Niki said...

Brenda, I read this post at my friend's house this weekend, but couldn't post a response. I was a mess after I read it and again today when I reread it. I feel you pain coming through your words and my heart aches for you. I can only imagine how difficult this loss if for you. You are grieving the loss of the babies that didn't implant and you are grieving the loss of a biological child. This is horribly difficult and you have every reason to be in mourning. Your tribute to your lost embryos and the biological babies of your dreams is beautiful and so touching. I think you will start moving forward in your grief journey now. Although the wound won't be forgotten, it will heal with time. I am hear to listen and walk with you through your grief. ((HUGS))

Cajun Cutie said...

The most beautiful post I have ever read. I wish you all the best in Life.

Aunt Becky said...

Never silly. Heartbreaking and awful. I'm so, so very sorry.

Sending you love, light and peace.

Momasita said...

What a beautiful ceremony. Everyone's right, it wasn't silly at all.

Lorraine said...

Please know that I, that so many of us, do know that this loss is significant and real and just as heartbreaking as the loss of any other of your family. The ideas about our families are always tied up in any grieving for whichever of them are no longer with us. What a beautiful way to honor that idea, that ideal, and mark the occasion of a loss that will always be a part of your lives.

With all my sympathies, of course.

Just Me. said...

I'm a mess now and crying big time. I'm so sorry. No, not silly. You're just a wonderful, beautiful, friend, wife, mother (yes, to me you'll always be a mum).

Big hugs, B.

ps You've always been there for me. I hope I can be there for you as well.

Chelle said...

I have never been so touched by a post. I cried the entire time I was reading. My heart goes out to you and M.

((HUGS))

Phoebe said...

I remember the period of grief I went through after our FET didn't work. I said, "how do you grieve the death of someone who never existed?!" While it was confusing in one sense, it did feel like a death to me. I'm glad you found a way to say good bye to your embryos. It's not easy not having any kind of social or cultural outlet for this kind of grief. I get it.

Lin said...

Beautiful...definitely not silly! (((HUGS)))

Serenity said...

Here from the Blog roundup. This post is gorgeous. And made me cry for my 9 embryos which also never fully existed.

Not silly in the slightest.

xxx

Meghan said...

Never, never silly. And while you're right that the rest of the world doesn't get it, you created your own ceremony and we are your viewing, crying with you and understanding, even if we haven't been down quite the same road. You've expressed yourself beautifully--I wish there was more we could all do, but a hug will have to do, and remembering your beautiful babies.

loribeth said...

Here from Stirrup Queens Friday Roundup. This was a gorgeous post, just gorgeous. I love that you invented your own ritual for a situation that has none. Sending you love & hugs.

luna said...

this is so sad and beautiful at the same time. letting go of that dream is so very hard, the losses are so very real. I'm glad you found a meaningful ritual to acknowledge the significance of this.

though I recently adopted a baby girl, I am also still facing saying good bye to the last of our embryos, and I haven't been able to write about it yet. this post helped me deal with my own thoughts on this. thanks for sharing it, and to mel for pointing me here.

Alexicographer said...

Here from SQ.

This is such a beautiful post. I sat this week watching a cousin of mine who wanted but does not and is no longer seeking to have children (I know only this, nothing more ... not what routes she pursued, for how long, or at what cost ... only that she wanted, hoped, and no longer does hope) play with a small child and felt so sad. I don't know enough of her journey or where she is now to direct her here, but I hope I'll remember to point others to this post if I run into people who are where you are.

nh said...

Such a wonderful, heart-filled post.
I agree that grieving the loss of embryo's is so hard, but you seem to have found a way of marking it that stops my breath and makes my heart ache for the beauty.

Katherine said...

I am so very sorry.
You are right, there really needs to be a card for losing your embryos. It's needs so much more recognition.
I'm sitting here crying for your loss, for my loss, for so many losses of deserving couples.

I love the balloon idea. What a special way to say good-bye.

We bought a pretty photo frame for our lost little embies, their photo sits on the shelf next to our wedding photo.
Our good-bye was on Mother's Day, we went through half a gallon of soap bubbles. (Didn't intend it to be the good-bye, but it turned in to one.)

I am so sorry for your final loss, having to stop and give up the idea of genetic children. I am so sorry.

Fran said...

You had me in tears. It was not silly it was the right thing to do. Saying goodbye is never easy no matter to what you are saying goodbye too. Now you can look at your future and you can move on. I wanted to thank you somuch for stopping by my blog, I really appreciated your support in this difficult time for us. Love, Fran

Kami said...

I'm here via Luna's blog who found you from the roundup.

This is such a sad and sweet post. Thank you for sharing.

Lisa said...

What a beautiful tribute to all your embryos. You struggled and lost, and for that, I am deeply deeply sorry. You gained courage and strength, but you had to let go of a dream, of a life you wanted and will never have. I admire you for your courage. I admire you for sharing your feelings, your journey, for sharing your heart. It's not easy to wear your heart on your sleeve, day after day, year after year, and fall flat. I'm so sorry your story ended this way. And I'm sorry for all the losses, all the heartache, all the years, and all the embryos that never made it.

I don't know where you will go from here. But I hope and pray that you will somehow find the love, happiness, and peace you deserve. And yes, even one day, hope.

You are simply amazing.

Don't ever forget it.

Prabha said...

Stumbled on your blog after it was a recommendation on reader and read this post and the one on your dad. Your words echo my thoughts. I lost my dad 3 years ago after a month in the hospital and your experience mirrors mine. This post reflects exactly how I feel/felt when we decided to give up and move on to adoption. You write amazingly well. I have been crying after reading this.