The low-down on (almost) all the eyeliners I've tried before reaching the perfect smudge-free liner for my single eyelids.
Before we begin, some background to help you understand why finding THE eyeliner that works took so long. I have the best combination of factors for eyeliner to smudge:
- Single eyelids or what some call monolids. The problem here is that single eyelids are hooded which means that the place where you draw your eyeliner will rub against another piece of skin each time you blink. This gives your lids more opportunity to rub on the eyeliner.
- I have slightly oily lids. Thank goodness they are not super oily.
- I live in a very humid country!
I will start off with the eyeliners that have changed my life then tell you about all the other ones to avoid trying.
1. Marc Jacobs Magic Marc'er
![]() |
| Marc Jacobs Magic Marc'er, available at Sephora outlets |
This one is THE BEST liner ever. With an eye primer it will not move AT ALL and will last from morning 8am till I'm done with work and dinners at 11pm. It's also extremely easy to use if you have a fear of liquid liners and is black as black can be. Really lovely!
The only thing I don't like about it is the price and the fact that it dries up in about 4-5 months. I guess good things come at a price and it may also have dried up so quickly because I loved it so much I used it every single day.
Would I buy this again? AH BO DEN (Singlish for 'OF COURSE with a million exclamation marks')! I just use it sparingly so I won't burn a hole in my pocket :)
2. Stila Stay All Day liquid liner and Smudge Stick Waterproof eyeliner
![]() |
| Stila Stay All Day liquid liner and Smudge Stick Waterproof eye liner, available at Sephora outlets and online on Zalora.sg |
I don't know what took me so long to discover these. Perhaps I felt that asian brands would fit asian climate better or something. These are seriously almost as amazing and cost less and can be used for longer. I use the liquid liner to line my eyes and the pencil one to fill in the gaps on the lash line. Both stay really long with eye primer. And not to mention the number of colours these things come in!
3. NARS Smudge Proof Shadow Base
I used to wonder if eye primers were a myth cos I tried 2 variations of the widely raved about Urban Decay primer potion and both didn't work. I must say that I haven't tried a ton of primers but I happened to chance upon an online review by someone who also found the Urban Decay primer pointless and was raving about the NARS one. Now NARS is pretty expensive so I recommend saving up some credit card points and converting them to vouchers to try this one out. I don't think you'll be disappointed though!
![]() |
| NARS Smudge Proof Shadow Base vs Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion, NARS is available at TANGS Orchard and Robinsons @ Heeren, Urban Decay is available at Sephora |
Things I tried that didn't work
A lot of these are supposed to be the top waterproof/smudge proof liners in the market.
I'm going to try to remember them all...
- MAC Fluid Line
- MAC Penultimate eyeliner
- Bobbi Brown Long-wear eye pencil (supposedly the same formula as the gel pot)
- YSL Effet Faux Cils Creme D'Eyeliner
- K-Palette liquid liner
- Clio liquid liner
- Eyeko Skinny Liquid eyeliner
- Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on eye pencil
- Wet N Wild Mega Eyes Creme Eyeliner
I think there's more but these are all I can remember from the last 5 years :) If you wanna ask about any eyeliner in particular just leave a comment and I'll try my best to get back.
If you're still in the hunt for THE eyeliner. Hang in there! You will get there somehow! hahahha

























