- Photo:
- The Silence of the Lambs
- Orion Pictures
Cinema has long been fascinated with the human mind, offering a wide range of films that delve into its complexities. When discussing the best movies about psychology, this list spans psychological thrillers, dramas, horror, and more. These films captivate audiences by exploring themes of mental illness, psychological manipulation, and the intricate workings of the human psyche.
Take The Silence of the Lambs, for instance. This psychological horror-thriller delves deep into the minds of both a brilliant FBI trainee and a manipulative genius, resulting in a chilling narrative that lingers long after the credits roll. Another classic is One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, a gripping drama that offers a poignant look at the mental health care system and the struggles of those confined within it. Both films offer profound insights into psychology through their unforgettable characters and compelling storylines.
Now it's your turn to weigh in. Which movies involving psychology have left the most significant impact on you? We've compiled a list of these thought-provoking films, and we need your votes to determine which ones truly stand out. Cast your vote to help us highlight the most compelling cinematic explorations of the human mind. Your input will ensure that the best in psychological cinema gets the recognition it deserves.
- Photo:
The Breakdown: Rookie FBI agent Clarice Starling is given probably the worst assignment ever: stopping a heinous serial killer nicknamed Buffalo Bill. In order to do that, she has to interview an even more heinous serial killer named Hannibal “The Cannibal” Lecter, who’s also Buffalo Bill’s ex-psychiatrist. This turns into a game of cat-and-mouse in which it’s never quite clear who’s manipulating whom. Clarice does nab Buffalo Bill, but Lecter escapes anyway.
Why It’s Worth Watching: It’s just the third movie in cinematic history that scored all five of the major Academy Awards, 27 years after One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest achieved the same feat. What’s perhaps most impressive is that this is actually the second film adaptation of a Thomas Harris novel about his signature character, after the 1986 Michael Mann entry Manhunter. Silence of the Lambs sidestepped that baggage, elevating the source material to deliver an all-time classic.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: A great thriller, and a great psychological thriller in particular, keeps the audience in suspense until the final frame. On one level, Silence of the Lambs is an expertly crafted hunt for a serial killer. But the element of an even greater evil in Hannibal Lecter adds an element of danger to such a degree that the audience never feels safe. You never know quite how much Hannibal knows. Did he groom his former patient Jame Gumb to become Buffalo Bill? Was it all a contingency plan to help spring him from prison? The film raised questions that still remain unanswered.
- Actors: Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins, Scott Glenn, Ted Levine, Anthony Heald
- Released: 1991
- Directed by: Jonathan Demme
psychological deep dive?- 1Anthony Hopkins133 Votes
- 2Jodie Foster100 Votes
- 3Scott Glenn55 Votes
- 4Ted Levine50 Votes
- Photo:
The Breakdown: In 1954, US Marshal Teddy Daniels and his partner travel to an insane asylum in Boston Harbor, ostensibly to locate a missing patient, but really so that Teddy can locate and get revenge against Andrew Laddis, an arsonist who killed his wife in a fire. Soon, the asylum and its inmates seem to be working against Teddy, but not all is as it seems.
Why It’s Worth Watching: This is the fourth entry in the highly successful Martin Scorsese-Leonardo DiCaprio pairing, which began with 2002’s Gangs of New York and most recently (as of 2024) Killers of the Flower Moon. While it might not be considered among either of their greatest works, it still earned nearly $300 million.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: Shutter Island is a fun take on the classic trope, “What if the main character was the villain all along?” It’s not particularly interested in a realistic portrayal of mental illness, or grief for that matter. But it does use those elements to create a fun thriller, even if it doesn’t really hold up to multiple viewings.
- Actors: Leonardo DiCaprio, Mark Ruffalo, Ben Kingsley, Max von Sydow, Michelle Williams
- Released: 2010
- Directed by: Martin Scorsese
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: A biographical look at the life of John Nash, a mid-20th century American mathematician who suffered from paranoid schizophrenia. While high-level mathematical concepts like cryptography are relatively simple for Nash, more mundane situations like dating are not. Eventually, Nash is confronted with the possibility that his high-stakes lifestyle involving Soviet espionage is largely the product of his affliction, and that most of his “colleagues” are figments of his imagination. From then on, Nash’s greatest challenge is overcoming his own hallucinations.
Why It’s Worth Watching: A Beautiful Mind gives a compelling look at an historical figure who was previously unknown to most audiences, using Nash’s mental illness as a unique angle to explore his story. It also won four Academy Awards, including best director for Ron Howard and best picture.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: A Beautiful Mind utilizes Nash’s condition to present a story that’s far different than most biopics. Just like Nash himself, the audience is left in the dark about the reality of the world around him until well into the story. When Nash’s concept of reality is fundamentally altered, the audience similarly has to question everything they thought they knew.
- Actors: Russell Crowe, Ed Harris, Jennifer Connelly, Paul Bettany, Adam Goldberg
- Released: 2001
- Directed by: Ron Howard
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: The 1975 drama based on the novel by Ken Kesey follows R.P. McMurphy, a longtime criminal who convinces the state of Oregon to commit him to a mental institution, thinking he’ll have an easier time there than in jail. Soon, he comes to sympathize with the inmates, whom he believes are victims of the system and not insane. But when he tries to help them rebel and pursue happiness, it leads to deadly consequences.
Why It’s Worth Watching: One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest was just the second film to win the Academy Awards for best picture, best actor, best actress, best director, and best screenplay. While Jack Nicholson’s star-making performance cemented him as one of the best actors of all time, Louise Fletcher as Nurse Ratched is one of the most terrifying movie villains of all time.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest asks an age-old question about mental illness: are supposedly mentally ill people really ill, or is it the way society treats them. While it might offer a dated depiction of mental illness by suggesting that it’s just something that can be inflicted on an otherwise healthy person, it still raises questions that are thought-provoking today. On top of that, McMurphy is a complicated character. Does he “help” his fellow inmates because he has their well-being in mind, or are they just weapons in his lifelong war against the system?
- Actors: Jack Nicholson, Louise Fletcher, Brad Dourif, William Redfield, Michael Berryman
- Released: 1975
- Directed by: Milos Forman
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: A biographical drama based on Suzanna Kaysen’s 1993 memoir, about her time being institutionalized at a mental hospital in 1967. As young Susannah bonds with her fellow inmates, she’s diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. This forces her to make a choice: accept treatment, or rebel, as her new friend Lisa urges her to.
Why It’s Worth Watching: Angelina Jolie earned the 1999 academy award for best supporting actress for her performance as Lisa. But hers is just one of many strong performances in a film that presents mental illness not as a plot device but as a fact of life.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: Girl, Interrupted doesn’t use mental illness as a justification for cinematic spectacle. Yet in the end, mental illness does play a similar role by making the audience question what’s true and what’s not. In this case, each of the characters has to grapple with the fact that their mental illness may or may not alter their personalities, which may or may not make them culpable for their behavior. There are no clear answers. In this case, mental illness is just as messy as it is in real life.
- Actors: Winona Ryder, Angelina Jolie, Clea Duvall, Brittany Murphy, Elisabeth Moss
- Released: 1999
- Directed by: James Mangold
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: In 1996, a virus wipes out most of humanity. In 2035, a convict named James Cole is sent back in time to investigate the origins of the virus, which is believed to be the handiwork of a militant eco-terrorist organization, the Army of the 12 Monkeys. However, everything is not quite as it seems, and the film’s events force Coke to consider whether he might just be insane. In the end, he uncovers a conspiracy of a far higher order, but is powerless to stop it.
Why It’s Worth Watching: It’s a Terry Gilliam movie, which means thought-provoking surrealism with a hefty dash of humor. It also boasts a winning cast including Bruce Willis, Brad Pitt, Madeleine Stowe, and Christopher Plummer. 12 Monkeys is considered a classic in both the sci-fi and psychological thriller genres, enough to warrant a TV remake on SyFy.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: Here we have a movie that blends two mind-bending subjects, time travel and mental illness. Time travel is already a thorny topic in fiction because it invites all sorts of questions about cause and effect. Adding mental illness to the equation only further complicates things. It’s the kind of movie that needs multiple viewings to be fully appreciate.
- Actors: Bruce Willis, Madeleine Stowe, Brad Pitt, Christopher Plummer, Jon Seda
- Released: 1995
- Directed by: Terry Gilliam
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: Three teenagers are taken hostage by a man named Kevin, who has 23 different personalities. While Kevin goes about his daily life trying to get treatment for his affliction, the teens attempt to survive by appealing to his different personalities for help. Everything comes to a head when he manifests a cannibalistic 24th personality, The Beast.
Why It’s Worth Watching: It really depends on your love for director M. Night Shyamalan. While this film does include a classic Shyamalanian twist, it’s not nearly as contrived as some of his others. James McAvoy’s performance as Kevin and many of his alter egos certainly merits checking out, too.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: This film doesn’t quite keep you guessing like others. The entire time, it’s clear who’s the villain and who’s the victim, even if the villain looks and acts differently in nearly every scene. While other films use dissociative identity disorder to subvert reality, this one uses it to present a villain who’s unpredictable.
- Actors: James McAvoy, Anya Taylor-Joy, Betty Buckley, Haley Lu Richardson, Jessica Sula
- Released: 2016
- Directed by: M. Night Shyamalan
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: In a world where it’s possible to infiltrate people’s dreams to subconsciously alter people’s minds, Dom Cobb has a problem. He’s a gifted dream cracker, but he’s haunted by the death of his wife and the loss of his children. His latest mission requires him to conduct corporate espionage by tampering with the mind of the heir to a multi-national corporation, but along the way he must overcome his demons.
Why It’s Worth Watching: Cristopher Nolan's movies have earned more than $5 billion globally for a reason, and this is widely considered to be his masterpiece. It also features an all-star cast.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: At its core, Inception is a simple heist movie. But the specifics make it one of the most complexly plotted movies of the 21st century. For most of the film, Nolan juggles four different timelines, including waking reality and three levels of consciousness, plus flashbacks and alternate mental realities, too. By the end, it’s unclear whether Cobb returns to the real world or not.
- Actors: Leonardo DiCaprio, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Elliot Page, Tom Hardy, Ken Watanabe
- Released: 2010
- Directed by: Christopher Nolan
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: Natalie Portman stars as Nina, an up and coming New York ballerina who’s cast in the coveted lead role of Swan Lake, which is actually two roles in one — the innocent Odette and the seductive Odile. Nina is perfect for the former, but struggles with the latter. When the much Odile-like Lily is cast as her understudy, Nina becomes convinced that Lily is trying to replace her.
Why It’s Worth Watching: It’s a Darren Aronofsky film, which means you’re getting an unsettling, mind-bending story with striking visuals and rich themes. For those who like their movies to be literary, Aronofsky was inspired by Dostoyevsky’s The Double when writing the script.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: Here’s another film that uses hallucination, some of which is chemically induced, to mess with your perception of reality. At various points, Nina isn’t quite sure if Lily is a real person or a figment of her imagination. The entire film hinges on the concept of the “doppelgänger.”
- Actors: Natalie Portman, Mila Kunis, Vincent Cassel, Barbara Hershey, Winona Ryder
- Released: 2010
- Directed by: Darren Aronofsky
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: Jim Carrey and Kate Winslet star as Joel and Clementine, a recently broken up couple who both decide to undergo a procedure to remove each other from their memories and thus avoid grief. It’s told mostly from Joel’s perspective and follows him as he realizes that he doesn’t want to erase his happier memories of Clementine and that he still wants to be with her.
Why It’s Worth Watching: It’s directed by Michel Gondry with a script by Charlie Kaufman. Both filmmakers are known for creating absorbing worlds with arresting visuals, often based on the human mind. Plus, it functions as a love story in reverse, but as with any love story the audience has to root for the main characters, and who doesn’t love Winslet and Carrey?
How Does This Mess With Your Head: Eternal Sunshine isn’t particularly hard to follow. It doesn’t revel in overly complicated plots twists. But it does do what great science fiction does, which is present a premise that makes you rethink your values. If such technology as Lacuna’s did exist, would you use it? And how could you create that technology without abusing it?
- Actors: Jim Carrey, Kate Winslet, Kirsten Dunst, Mark Ruffalo, Elijah Wood
- Released: 2004
- Directed by: Michel Gondry
psychological deep dive?- 11
- Photo:
The Breakdown: Told in two parallel timelines, Identity tells the story of Malcom, a man who’s on trial for a mass murder at a desert motel. It also recounts the events of the murders. Eventually, it’s revealed that Malcom has dissociative identity disorder, meaning he has multiple personalities, and that one of them is the killer.
Why It’s Worth Watching: Identity was profitable, raising over $90 million off a $28 million budget. It’s the kind of movie that keeps you guessing until the end, and probably even beyond that. But, sometimes the line between “compelling” and “confusing” can be blurry.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: Dissociative Identity Disorder only afflicts about 1.5% of the world population (and not really in the way it’s portrayed in movies) but it’s become a popular movie trope. Having a main character with multiple personalities is both prime actor bait as well as a recipe to keep the audience on their toes. When done well, it’s an effective cinematic technique to upend expectations, which is what storytelling is all about.
- Actors: John Cusack, Ray Liotta, Amanda Peet, John Hawkes, Alfred Molina
- Released: 2003
- Directed by: James Mangold
psychological deep dive? - 12
- Photo:
The Breakdown: A man named Leonard Shelby suffers from a condition that makes him completely unable to create short-term memories, forcing him to leave handwritten notes for himself and tattoo important information onto his body. His goal? Find whoever killed his wife and caused his situation.
Why It’s Worth Watching: Director Christopher Nolan is widely considered the master of psychological thrillers, although he’s had plenty of success in other genres like superhero movies and war films. Memento was his breakthrough film. If you like Nolan at his most Nolanian, you shouldn’t miss this one.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: For starters, Memento is told partly in reverse chronological order, which is usually a mindscrew to the average moviegoer. But more broadly, Nolan skillfully upends and subverts nearly every piece of information given to the audience. Without spoiling too much, Leonard gets justice but ends up becoming a monster himself.
- Actors: Guy Pearce, Carrie-Anne Moss, Joe Pantoliano, Mark Boone, Stephen Tobolowsky
- Released: 2000
- Directed by: Christopher Nolan
psychological deep dive?- 1Carrie-Anne Moss9 Votes
- 2Joe Pantoliano7 Votes
- 3Guy Pearce9 Votes
- 4Stephen Tobolowsky9 Votes
- 13
- Photo:
The Breakdown: Facing an internal affairs investigation, LAPD detective Will Dormer is sent to Alaska along with his partner to investigate the murder of a 17-year-old. After Dormer appears to mistakenly shoot and kill his partner, Hap Eckhart, who was supposedly set to testify against him, he must race to solve the murder and prevent the killer from killing again before he himself is brought to justice. Making matters worse, the endless Arctic daylight leaves him unable to sleep for days, making his entire experience of the events unreliable.
Why It’s Worth Watching: First, you have the Christopher Nolan factor. While this isn’t his most mind-bending movie, it still plays with perception and reality in a way that Nolan fans will find satisfying. Beyond that, it features satisfyingly restrained performances from Al Pacino and Robin Williams.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: The movie never quite presents a clear version of events and keeps the audience off-balance. Did Dormer murder his partner, or did Finch set him up? Is Dormer’s sleep-deprived version of events reliable at all? Even if you believe Dormer is innocent, it’s hard to stomach how he handles the investigation.
- Actors: Al Pacino, Robin Williams, Hilary Swank, Maura Tierney, Martin Donovan
- Released: 2002
- Directed by: Christopher Nolan
psychological deep dive? - Photo:
The Breakdown: Lockhart, a young executive at a New York financial services firm is sent to Switzerland to retrieve the CEO, Robert Pembroke, who is believed to have gone insane and is confined at a “wellness center.” After a car crash, he becomes a patient himself, but his treatment turns out to be a nightmare. Turns out, the head of the facility, Dr. Volmer, is a centuries-old baron who’s obsessed with producing a pure-blooded heir, convinced that fathering a child with his only daughter Hannah is the only way to do it, and determined to overcome any obstacle including Hannah’s infertility.
Why It’s Worth Watching: This is the kind of psychological horror/thriller movie that’s made for aficionados. Director Gore Verbinski cited numerous sources of inspiration, including the 1924 Thomas Mann novel The Magic Mountain.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: The Cure for Wellness is built on a sturdy horror setup: what if someone’s medical caregiver was actually their greatest threat? We’re all conditioned to trust medical professionals, but The Cure for Wellness subverts this by putting Lockhart in the care of a literal monster. Volmer designs Lockhart’s “treatment” specifically to addle his mind, and, like Lockhart, the audience is never quite sure what’s real and what’s not.
- Actors: Dane DeHaan, Jason Isaacs, Mia Goth, Celia Imrie, Adrian Schiller
- Released: 2016
- Directed by: Gore Verbinski
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: Psychologist David Calloway relocates to Upstate New York with his young daughter, Emily, after the apparent suicide of his wife, Alison. After the move, Emily begins believing in an imaginary friend, “Charlie,” just as violent things start happening. David eventually discovers that he has dissociative identity disorder and has been Charlie all along, forcing Emily into a battle of survival.
Why It’s Worth Watching: While Hide and Seek only impressed 12% of critics, per Rotten Tomatoes, it did much better with audiences, 50% of whom liked it. Hide and Seek also made $123 million at the box office. Plus, Robert DeNiro elevates pretty much any movie he’s in.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: Many films about psychology deal with mental illness, especially the varieties that warp a person’s perception of reality. Hide and Seek spends its first half setting you up to believe that it’s a traditional “spooky kid” horror movie, only to flip the script and make Dad the villain.
- Actors: Robert De Niro, Dakota Fanning, Famke Janssen, Elisabeth Shue, Amy Irving
- Released: 2005
- Directed by: John Polson
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: Nick Nolte plays Tom Wingo, a married high school football coach who travels to New York City to help his suicidal twin sister Savannah. This takes the form of a series of therapy sessions with Dr. Lowenstein. In their sessions, Tom uncovers a history of repressed childhood trauma while also falling for Lowenstein.
Why It’s Worth Watching: It’s a best picture nominee and a cultural touchstone, being frequently parodied and referenced in TV shows and movies. On top of that it’s a compelling drama and one of only three films directed by Streisand, the other two being Yentl and The Mirror Has Two Faces.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: The Prince of Tides deals with some heavy psychological topics like childhood trauma and dissociative identity disorder. Rather than use these situations for shock value, however, it presents a much more realistic and grounded version of them. But this doesn’t make the story any less impactful.
- Actors: Nick Nolte, Barbra Streisand, Blythe Danner, Kate Nelligan, Jeroen Krabbé
- Released: 1991
- Directed by: Barbra Streisand
psychological deep dive?- Photo:
The Breakdown: The Master is Paul Thomas Anderson’s take on cults, in particular a not-so-veiled depiction of Scientology. Freddie Quell is a disaffected World War II veteran who finds his way into the fold of Lancaster Dodd, an L. Ron Hubbard-esque religious leader. As Freddie gains more responsibility in “the Cause,” he’s forced to confront whether it’s legitimate or just a scam, and whether his life has any meaning outside the Cause.
Why It’s Worth Watching: The trifecta of Joaquin Phoenix, Philip Seymour Hoffman, and Amy Adams deliver riveting performances that convincingly portray how people fall under the sway of pseudo-religions. It’s also classic Paul Thomas Anderson fare, combining a grandiose story from the dark side of American history with a hefty dose of humor.
How Does This Mess With Your Head: In this film, the audience is made to sympathize with Freddy from the very beginning, as reprehensible as he might be. This means sitting with Freddy as Lancaster slowly but surely indoctrinates him into the religion. This takes the form of a series of interrogations meant to pry out the truth of Freddy’s personalities, but in reality are just meant to break his will. It’s a disturbing portrayal of manipulation and acquiescence that’s too often seen in real life.
- Actors: Joaquin Phoenix, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Amy Adams, Laura Dern, Jesse Plemons
- Released: 2012
- Directed by: Paul Thomas Anderson
psychological deep dive?
