| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Extreme Rising Card Subject to Change
Dec 29th 2012 | Brian XL & Matt Tremont | def. (pin) | Alex Reynolds & John Silver, Azrieal & Bandido Jr. | dark
triple-threat tag | |
PWS Fight-Mare Before Christmas
Dec 7th 2012 | Jerry Lynn | def. | A. R. Fox, Christian York, Craven Varro, John Silver, Lance Anoa'i, Rich Swann, The Big O | 8-way elimination | |
PWS Bombshell Ladies of Wrestling Event #2
Dec 6th 2012 | John Silver | def. | Alicia | | |
CHIKARA Under the Hood
Dec 2nd 2012 | DeviANT & Jigsaw & Soldier Ant & The Shard | def. | AssailANT & Fire Ant & Green Ant & Mike Quackenbush | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA The Cibernetico Rises
Nov 18th 2012 | The Shard | def. | Fire Ant | | |
CHIKARA A Piece of the Action
Nov 11th 2012 | DeviANT & The Shard | def. | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | | |
CHIKARA Zelda the Great
Nov 10th 2012 | El Generico | def. | The Shard | | |
PWS The Show Must Go On
Nov 9th 2012 | Joe Hardway & Mo Sexton & The Big O | def. | Jobber Dustin & Jobber Justin & John Silver | 6-person tag | |
PWS House Party 5: Not Starring Kid N Play
Oct 12th 2012 | Devon Moore | def. | John Silver, Lance Anoa'i, Lucifer Darksyde, Rich Swann, The Dynamic Sensation | 6-Way | |
CHIKARA The Zodiac Crimes
Oct 7th 2012 | Fire Ant & Green Ant & Hallowicked & Mike Quackenbush & Ultramantis Black | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Kodama & Obariyon & The Shard | 10-person tag | |
CHIKARA Deep Freeze
Oct 6th 2012 | The Shard | def. | Gran Akuma | | |
CHIKARA The Ring of Wax
Aug 18th 2012 | 17 & The Shard | def. (DQ) | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | | |
CHIKARA Shoot a Crooked Arrow
Aug 17th 2012 | Eddie Kingston | def. | The Shard | | |
CHIKARA Live at First Energy Stadium: A Special Charity Event
Aug 12th 2012 | The Shard | def. | Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA Give 'Em the Axe
Jul 29th 2012 | The Mysterious And Handsome Stranger | def. (pin) | The Shard | | |
CHIKARA The Great Escape
Jul 28th 2012 | Sugar Dunkerton | def. | The Shard | | |
EVOLVE #16: Style Battle Finals
Jun 30th 2012 | Alex Reynolds & John Silver | def. | Cheech Hernandez & Mike Cruz | | |
EVOLVE #15: Gargano vs. Taylor
Jun 29th 2012 | Lince Dorado | def. | Alex Reynolds, Caleb Konley, Jake Manning, John Silver, Scott Reed | six-way | |
EVOLVE #14: Generico vs. del Sol
Jun 28th 2012 | John Silver | def. | Jake Manning | | |
CHIKARA Smack in the Middle
Jun 24th 2012 | Jigsaw | def. | The Shard | | |
 CHIKARA The Foggiest Nation
Jun 23rd 2012 | AssailANT & DeviANT & The Shard | def. | Green Ant & Mike Quackenbush & Soldier Ant | 6-person tag | |
WWE No Way Out '12
Jun 17th 2012 | Ryback | def. (pin) | Dan Delaney & Rob Grymes | handicap tag | |
CHIKARA Chikarasaurus Rex: How to Hatch a Dinosaur
Jun 2nd 2012 | Eddie Kingston & Green Ant & Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush & Soldier Ant | def. (sub) | 17 & AssailANT & CombatANT & DeviANT & The Shard | 10-person tag | |
CHIKARA Anniversario: The Ogg and I
May 20th 2012 | Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. (DQ) | 17 & The Shard | | |
CHIKARA Anniversario: A Horse of Another Color
May 19th 2012 | 17 & AssailANT & CombatANT & DeviANT & The Shard | def. (sub) | Dragonfly & Hallowicked & Icarus & Mister Zero & Ultramantis Black | 10-person tag | |
CHIKARA Hot Off the Griddle
Apr 28th 2012 | Fire Ant & Green Ant & Jigsaw & Soldier Ant | def. (sub) | AssailANT & CombatANT & DeviANT & The Shard | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA I'll Be a Mummy's Uncle
Apr 14th 2012 | 17 & AssailANT & CombatANT & The Shard | def. (pin) | Eddie Kingston & Fire Ant & Green Ant & Soldier Ant | 8-person tag | |
EVOLVE #11: Finlay vs. Callihan
Apr 13th 2012 | Alex Reynolds | def. | John Silver | | |
CHIKARA It's How You Play the Game
Mar 25th 2012 | 17 & The Shard | def. (pin) | Hallowicked & Ultramantis Black | | |
CHIKARA Green Ice
Mar 24th 2012 | 17 & The Shard | def. (sub) | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | | |
PWS Super Card 2012
Mar 9th 2012 | John Silver (c) & Pat Buck (c) | draw (NC) | The Barbarian & The Warlord | | PWS Tag Team Titles
|
EVOLVE #10: A Tribute to the Arena
Jan 14th 2012 | Caleb Konley & Scott Reed | def. | Alex Reynolds & John Silver | | |
John Silver during 2012