Many of you know that Josh and I have been
wrestling over whether to homeschool our kids. With Rye having turned 5 back in
the spring, this was the year we had to make a real decision and take steps in our
chosen direction.
First, some background. Josh grew up
homeschooling from 5th through 9th grades. He went to a private Christian
school before that, and public high school (where we met) after that. His older
brothers went to a combination of private school and public school. His younger
sister almost completely homeschooled.
I went to private Catholic school from 1st
through 5th grade, when my family lived in Baltimore City, mostly because it
was safe and the most affordable
private school (I was not being raised Catholic but my father was, and he and
his four siblings had attended the same school). After my parents moved us to
rural Harford County, I went to good old North Harford Middle School and North
Harford High School. I saw no “problems” with public school, merely that it was
mostly a waste of time. Homework was busywork and easy, so why not just do it
and get it over with? And as for tests and things like AP classes, my theory
was to study just enough to get the low A/high B. I was all about return on
investment. A 90 and a 100 all turn out the same on a transcript. Besides, I
liked reading books, and writing, and had jobs in high school, so it’s not like
I was sitting around and smoking pot and playing video games. I actually did have better things to be doing with
my time.
After we married and had discussions about hypothetical children, Josh told me he would like us to homeschool our
children. I agreed—I was feeling pretty burnt out on daily newspaper journalism
and liked the idea of staying home, plus I thought the majority of the school
day was a big waste of time, and I pictured our kids would be little geniuses
who just wanted to read books too. Self-learners, really. Heck, the most
important thing I could teach them was how to cook dinner, and then I’d really have it easy.
And as for the whole stereotype that
homeschool kids are weird, as a reporter who covered lots of kid stories I had
met a decent number of homeschooled children, including many through the 4-H
program. They didn’t seem weird at all—they seemed smart, and enjoyed talking
with adults and looked you in the eye like an equal. Sometimes they had
passionate interests, which some people might perceive as weird, but I’ll take
a passionate kid over one that just answers every question with an “I don’t
know” or “fine.”
Fast-forward a few years into actually
becoming parents. I gave up my fulltime job and was freelancing 2 articles a
week in the beginning, sometimes more. Then Rye’s nap schedule became less
predictable, and I got a new boss who I wasn’t getting along with, and by the
time I was pregnant with Knox, I decided the low pay wasn’t worth the
frustration and stress so I cut back to just writing my weekly food column.
Around this time, Rye became more challenging as well. I still don’t know if it
was that a switch was flipped when Knox was born, or if it would have happened
anyway as his little personality continued to emerge and evolve, but suddenly
Rye and I were butting heads over the stupidest things. He would do it to Josh
too, though Josh, in his ability to work outside of the home, frequently got to
walk away from a situation before it got out of control. I don’t have that
luxury. And you may wonder why a parent would even bother wasting time arguing
with a preschooler, but if you just ignore their bizarre assertions (this one
isn’t real because I’m having a hard time coming up with one on the spot but
let’s say “it never rains on Thursdays,”), they think they’re always right and
have a false understanding of the world. I know Rye isn’t the only preschooler
to act like this (the YouTube series “Convos with my 2-year-old” comes to mind),
but I’d say 75 percent of the day’s conversations were these nonsense
arguments, and the other 25 percent were him asking the same questions over and
over again, like “what’s your favorite road sign?”
By the time Rye was turning 4, I was
pretty sure I’d rather work full-time cleaning toilets than homeschool him. Josh
kept ignoring my declarations of “there’s no way in hell I’m going to
homeschool,” instead talking about how much he was going to grow up by the time
we actually had to make a decision. Except I realized in December of his
4-year-old preschool year that all private schools do their open houses and
start enrollment in January. Shit. We had to make up our minds.
My one glimmer of hope for homeschooling
was Christiana Homeschool Academy, right here in Westminster, which one set of
friends had sent their oldest daughter to for preschool and kindergarten. This
is not a homeschool group or a traditional homeschool co-op, where parents take
turns leading weekly one or two sessions on a particular school subject or just
have playdates at the park or reserve programs at the nature center together.
This was run like a private school, but at a serious fraction of the cost, and uses
paid parents and outsiders as tutors, and the best part, the kids go for two
whole days a week (8:30 to 3:30). For elementary school, parents teach their
kids reading and math on their own, and all other subjects are covered on the
in-school days. What other classes are there? Um, how about science, history,
art, music, grammar and LATIN! Even in preschool they start learning Latin. And
the kids wear uniforms, which make it feel even more official. From the
outside, it was kind of hard to understand how it worked, but I was clinging onto
it as my lifeline, our compromise to homeschooling.
The first week in January, we went to an open
house where we were one of five sets of parents, and we got a real feel for the
school. And I was way more impressed than I had expected! The school teaches a “classical
education,” which divides children’s stages of learning into grammar, dialectic
and rhetoric. Basically this means that in the first stage you teach your kids
to memorize stuff and don’t worry about whether they understand; in the second
stage the kids try out those ideas and prove they understand them; and finally
they use that information to form their own thoughts and ideas. At Christiana,
they also learn the history of the world, taking 4 years to make it through all
parts of the world, repeating the cycle 3 times and going deeper each time. I
really like that, because my public school education was so American-centric.
And we are such a young country.
And the staff that we met just had the
perfect vibe about them. Considering this is kind of like a private school, I
was afraid it was going to feel stuffy, and that the staff would be braggy, and
the parents snobbish. But the vibe we got from everyone was that they want to
promote individuality in learning, and that they take teaching very seriously,
but there’s no need to brag about their school or try to convince us to come
there. There was an unspoken “here’s what we have to offer, does that fit in
with how you are raising your child?” We left with the registration packet in
hand, and personally, I was a little concerned that there are only 12 slots per
grade and would we be able to get Rye in? The school has a preschool and I
would assume all of them would be going to kindergarten (that is, if they hadn’t
failed Latin), and I wanted to make sure we got one of those 12 spots.
In March, we started the registration
process and put down the deposit. But because of Rye’s doctor’s appointments
that were leading us toward the diagnosis of his osteoid osteoma, we had to put
off the formal interview twice. When Rye and I finally sat down with the
headmaster (that makes sounds like a boarding school!), Rye did quite well and
I felt at ease. And then the headmaster looked over our family background and
noticed that I had been a professional writer for 11 years. Was there a reason
why I wasn’t interested in being a tutor (teacher) at the school? After all,
tutors get paid and they even offer onsite childcare for younger siblings for a
whopping $1 per hour. I kind of brushed it off, saying that with a 2-year-old
who still naps midday and needs to wait another year before preschool, it just
didn’t seem like it would work for our family. But then he pointed out that
just because you tutor a class doesn’t mean you have to tutor all day. You can
take on one class or as many classes as you are interested in doing. “And in
fact, I happen to know that the 9th grade writing position will be
open next year, and that only meets once a week.” Suddenly I felt all tingly
inside. I told him I would think about it and let him know if I had
reconsidered my stance on tutoring for this school year.
The more I thought about it the more it
seemed like a great idea. I’ve been getting a bit restless with the
stay-at-home mom routine, speaking only to people aged 6 and under. I had been
hoping a pharmacy position would come open for Josh so he would stop floating
and have a set schedule, thus allowing me to get a one-day a week job (yeah,
this isn’t about rebooting my career or making money, just buying me some
freedom and an opportunity to interact with adults). But Josh doesn’t want to
stop floating, and it seemed really unlikely that I could get a one-day a week
job anyway. Working one hour a week—that
sounded pretty amazing! And while the tutor position doesn’t pay too much, it
would cover about 2/3 of Rye’s tuition. I was pretty intimidated by the teaching aspect of the job, but I was
assured that you are handed a binder of the last year’s tutor’s lesson plans
and materials, and while it’s not quite a script, you are not operating in the
dark either. Within a week, I emailed the headmaster that we were officially
accepting Rye’s acceptance into the school, and that I was interested in being
the 9th grade writing teacher. He responded that he would pass the
news onto the department chair and that tutor assignments would be made in the
first week of June.
But I didn’t hear back from him during the
first week of June. Or the second week. Or the third. Somewhere in there I
emailed again to see if the class had been assigned to someone else, and he
said no, but that the department chair had some concerns that I was new to the
school and writing is kind of one of the harder areas to step into in the high
school years and catch up with the system the school uses to teach writing (Institute
for Excellence in Writing). But he said that considering my background, and the
fact that I would only be tutoring one child at home—and a kindergartener at
that—he thought I could handle it and he would restate my interest to the
department chair.
Again, nothing. Until July 11, suddenly I
got an email asking if I was still interested, and if so, could I attend the
new tutor training on July 18? I had given up hope on the opportunity, and had
that nervous excited feeling all over again. I quickly emailed back that I was
still interested, but that 1) I would have to miss the new tutor training
because that was Knox’s birthday and we had a birthday outing planned for that
day, and 2) I would have to miss the first day of school because we’ll be on
vacation. (P.S.—don’t tell Rye he’s missing the first day of school. I think
his structured personality wouldn’t like that, and there’s really no reason he
needs to worry about missing the first day of kindergarten in a school with one
kindergarten teacher and 12 kids in the class.) The headmaster responded that
those situations weren’t ideal, but totally workable. Oh, and the class is at
2:30 on Wednesdays (perfect because school gets out at 3:30, so no extra trips
back and forth) and has just 6 kids. I don’t think those specifics could have
been any better. As scary as it was to accept the position, I truly feel like
it was God’s plan.
So guys, I’m going to be a teacher! I
never wanted to be a teacher, even when I was excited about homeschooling, but
I still feel like this is a great opportunity. I like that it’s 9th
graders—the most humble of high school students. It’s just about writing, not
literature. This is the point in the school where they transition away from
strict grammar memorization and exercises (confession: I never was taught how
to diagram a sentence!) and their homework is more writing exercises, like
writing opening and concluding paragraphs on an essay they never actually write
the meat of. (And that I never have to read and grade the meat of either!) I
met with last year’s tutor and got her lesson plan book from her, and while I
fear I’m going to feel like a substitute teacher the whole year, the headmaster
assured me that feeling fades away after the first month or two.
I went to the general tutor “training” in
August but it wasn’t so much of a training as it was a time to meet the other
tutors and get some pep talks. The general vibe I got from the other tutors is
that they take this very seriously. Which makes me feel great as a parent. And incredibly stressed as a new tutor. And
I get an email from them almost every day, which is fine, I don’t mind emails,
but even being a parent in this school feels like a big commitment, which is
kind of what my friend who had sent her daughter to the school said too. Oh,
and parents who aren’t tutors have to either volunteer 1 or 2 whole days a
month (a lot considering there are only 8 or 9 school days a month) in the
school, doing office work and other staff type of work since they have a very
minimal staff for the school. But as a tutor, I’ll get out of that. Though I do
have to commit to one other special duty, and I quickly signed up to be the person
who coordinates and orders either pizza or Chick-Fil-A for lunch once a month.
It’s still a 3-hour commitment, but only once a month, and it’s the kind of
thing that you do and forget about until the next day comes up. And everyone
loves the bringer of special food!
This has gone on way too long, so I’m
going to wrap it up here and just say in the next few weeks, my life is going
to change drastically. I don’t think
I would have been the kind of parent who cries as they drop their
kindergartener off on his first day of school (if anything, I’m more the “let’s
have a round of mimosas!” kind of mom), but honestly, I’m more nervous about my first day of school than his.
Thankfully our first days are two days apart, so he can have his special first day
on the Monday and I will have my special first day on that Wednesday.
Oh, and here’s a preview to Rye’s first
day of school outfit, as he was trying on his UNIFORM! Never mind the barefoot
Huck Finn look. He has to wear black leather shoes and he hates them, and I’ve
never made him wear dress shoes in his life, and so he’s super over-reacting
about them. Or maybe in the grand scheme we should all react in this way when
we’re forced to wear uncomfortable clothes that don’t allow us to express
ourselves, but more on that later.
Check back next week as I write about the
specifics of preparing to go back out into the working world again!