I must take my hat off to the marketing team behind this Project Superstar. This reality singing talent competition has become an icon in the local Chinese music scene this year. People sat up and took notice of superstar wannabes & fans evolved from all over. This event has revived Channel U but most importantly, the media and telcos must be laughing all the way to the bank. For one, I don't have a penchant for reality shows other than Amazing Race. I hated Singapore Idol, Amercian Idol, Extreme Makeover, etc. But this Project Superstar got my attention
(but not my $$ though). 60 cents per sms, woah... Perhaps I am past that teen-bopping stage. But still...
These are
just my 2 cents worth, having been entertained by the young handsome guys and pretty girls every Wed & Thurs night. I will shorten my list to the final 4 contestants where it really is quite an exciting fight.
- Handsome sunshine guy: Hong Junyang
- It's a pity he lost out at the very last round. He can sing and perform pretty well. He looked so sad when he lost; after all he was the hot favourite. The judges were okie but I think the audience votes at the last round were highly debatable. Did they vote for M2 instead for all his efforts in trying? What about HJY's efforts in trying? If standards were discounted cos of M2's handicap, how fair is it then even though both contestants are good? ( esp when Li Weisong said he could tell M2 was trying real hard to have some stage movement.)
Anyway, I heard he's 24, which is the same as me. And he's in NUS. Why didnt I see him when I was in NUS? Gosh, what an opportunity I missed out!
- Multi-transformation pretty lass: Kelly Poon
She's really pretty and her image can be transformed numerous ways, which is amazing. She's got good taste but perhaps her less than perfect performance for the last few stages were due to stress and lack of confidence. I am glad she is the female champion. She's got a lovely voice and she seems humble. When she gets high scores, she smiles even more radiantly and doesnt pretend to be shocked... And she's smart, she gives diplomatic answers when asked questions like how she would feel if she lost. I don't care if people says she knows how to act, diplomacy goes a long way.
I am satisfied she won! I don't know what to describe her and I don't want to put in unkind words. From her stage speeches, you can tell she cares alot about the criticisms about her online and on print. And she very much wanted to win, I just felt she was desperate to win. To prove people wrong. For one, she doesnt have very much of a dress sense. The judges said her clothes dont match the atmosphere of the songs. I totally agree.
Her singing was atrocious? in the beginning until the female judge said CSH just let all out ("power is nothing without control"). CSH has a rough sexy voice, I agree. I must say she has improved in the last few stages but if Kelly didn't buckle under all that pressure, would she be more prominent? I think not.
I am totally embarrassed that she's as old as me, 24 and the very fact she went to NUS. Cos the way she expressed her (fake) surprise when some judges gave her 9/10 was so obviously duhzz (fake). And sticking out your tongue on national television all the time is not a very dignified thing to do. Please don't act cute. I cringe each time the tongue comes out or when she exclaimed upon seeing her parting video, "eee! hah! so auntie!"
Worse was when she tried to explain why she chose "You are beautiful" this song. She meant to say that she will not be bogged down by all the horrid comments given to her. If she didnt care, why did she try to explain so much to the judges that she chose that song??! And she said she should take criticisms but why her vengence to try to prove her critics wrong? The funniest thing she said in her response to her fashion boo-boos was "Budget lah". Well, expensive clothes don't maketh a person. Even the female judge pointed that out. Goodness!!!
I think humility and sincerity and diplomacy are the key issues here. Look at HJY, Kelly, Kelvin and the rest of other (eliminated) contestants, they listened to the judges' comments sincerely and not let off some funny sound or exclamation or stick out their tongues or pretend to be very very surprised at high marks.
All in all, I guess life would be different if Kelly and Junyang proceeded on to the next stage, at least in my life.
That's just my humble view. = )