What if they were American?
We, American soccer fans, spend so much time wondering what our best athletes would play like if they stepped on the pitch. But, what if some of the greatest international footballing talents were, instead, born in the U.S. and were not exposed to the beautiful game? Would they still be pro athletes? Let's find out. Check out the first installment, the second, and the third.
Rafael van der Vaart, Arjen Robben, and Wesley Sneijder

These guys would all have gone to the same high school in Connecticut and be average white suburban dudes. Well, maybe not average. They'd all be sick athletes, at least on a high school/pickup level. And they'd play golf and tennis. None of them could make it in the traditional American pro sports, though. They're all too frail and/or too small and/or complete d-bags. They could probably compete as college baseball players or maybe D-3 ballers, but that's about as far as they would go. Maybe Wes Sneijder could play quarterback or wide receiver. He might be able to take a hit or two. All three seem pretty intelligent and well-adjusted, so I'm sure they all would've gone the college route and found jobs and by now they'd just drink beer and talk about the Yankees and get way too amped up for a pickup hoops game at the YMCA in Darien. And, of course, they'd all be "boys" but they'd passively-aggressively wanna kill each other and cheat on their girlfriends and wives with each other's girlfriedns and wives and argue about who is wearing the tighter jeans. But, at the end of the day, they're all supremely jealous of this guy...
Robin van Persie

At 6-2, their classmate Rob Van Percey has the size (and undoubtedly the skill) to make it in American pro sports. I see him as an enigmatic/borderline ace starting pitcher. With my baseball reference points stuck in the mid-90s, David Cone is kind of the comparison. A semi-sleazy dude with serious stuff who rolls off a 20-win season every now and then and maybe even a Cy Young, but he just can't really string it together on a long term basis. Later in his career, he has his perfect game and maybe around 34 or 35 he succumbs to the temptations of HGH and finally really becomes the perennial All-Star the scouts thought he could be. Either way, he'd be a legend in his white-ass CT town and Rafi, Wes, and Arnold would brag to whomever is listening about how they used to beat him up in 4th grade.
Gareth Bale

Right now, the 21-year-old Bale would the reigning Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback with an uncertain future in the NFL. At 6 feet and not exceptionally sturdy, he'd have trouble taking hits as a pro QB. I think he'd go in the 3rd or 4th round and get some PT as a punt returner, 3rd down receiver, or wildcat quarterback on occasion. With his lightning speed and shifty feet, he'd definitely be good for a few highlight reel plays each season. Maybe down the line he gets a shot when the starting QB goes down. Maybe he surprises everyone and goes on a nice little run.
Antonio Cassano

Much like I postulated about Schweinsteiger, Cassano would be lost without the beautiful game. He's pretty much lost as it is and he's playing for one of the biggest teams in the world and starting for the Italian national team. The American sporting landscape, though, wouldn't be so kind. He's average-sized at best. He has trouble keeping weight off. Maybe he could play running back in high school? D-3? He could definitely get to Athlete of the year status at his high school, but after those glory years I see him ending up as a tragic tattooed ne'er-do-well floating around with a glass of wine in one hand and an almond croissant in the other.
Mario Balotelli

Athletically, he could be an all-pro wide receiver or an all-star guard, but it doesn't seem like he likes to get hit. So, I'd have to go with perpetually disgruntled NBA phenom. Something like the mind of a 20-year-old Rasheed Wallace in Derrick Rose's body. Truly a frightening prospect for most everyone in the NBA. It's basically the same situation we're in now. Extremely rare talent with no way of knowing if he'll be an all-timer or an all-time bust.
Giuseppe Rossi

Well, now this is a little awkward. So, he'd have to be born in Italy to American parents and then move to the U.S. to fulfill his lifelong dream to play for the Yankess and work his way up from the Tampa Bay Rays farm system? This is giving me a headache. Moving on...
Robinho

Pretty much the same story as his teammate Cassano. Minus the tattoos and pastries. Rob Souza, as he'd be known in the States, is listed at 132 pounds. No joke. That's just not gonna cut it in any American sport. Add on his childish antics and a lack of a real work ethic and things wouldn't be too happy in the Souza household. If he was from Florida, he'd still be living at his mom's place playing X-box all day. All-county point guard in high school, though, of course.
Andy Carroll

This one's easy. After an all-state high school football career playing quarterback, linebacker, placekicker, and punter, he'd be in jail for assault playing on the same pickup basketball team as Joey Barton. And then he'd get sold to Christian Poulsen's and Luis Suarez's team for 400,000 carton of cigarettes.
Carlos Tevez

At 5-8, he's certainly on the small side, but homeslice is a goddamn battering ram who plays to exhaustion every time he's on the pitch. We've seen all-pro NFL running backs his size before. He'd also fit in perfectly with the running back corps; threatening to retire every offseason and whatnot. If the NFL doesn't work out and, assuming he'd be from Jersey, he could also carve out a nice little career as a scary temperamental reality TV star.
Rafael van der Vaart, Arjen Robben, and Wesley Sneijder

These guys would all have gone to the same high school in Connecticut and be average white suburban dudes. Well, maybe not average. They'd all be sick athletes, at least on a high school/pickup level. And they'd play golf and tennis. None of them could make it in the traditional American pro sports, though. They're all too frail and/or too small and/or complete d-bags. They could probably compete as college baseball players or maybe D-3 ballers, but that's about as far as they would go. Maybe Wes Sneijder could play quarterback or wide receiver. He might be able to take a hit or two. All three seem pretty intelligent and well-adjusted, so I'm sure they all would've gone the college route and found jobs and by now they'd just drink beer and talk about the Yankees and get way too amped up for a pickup hoops game at the YMCA in Darien. And, of course, they'd all be "boys" but they'd passively-aggressively wanna kill each other and cheat on their girlfriends and wives with each other's girlfriedns and wives and argue about who is wearing the tighter jeans. But, at the end of the day, they're all supremely jealous of this guy...
Robin van Persie

At 6-2, their classmate Rob Van Percey has the size (and undoubtedly the skill) to make it in American pro sports. I see him as an enigmatic/borderline ace starting pitcher. With my baseball reference points stuck in the mid-90s, David Cone is kind of the comparison. A semi-sleazy dude with serious stuff who rolls off a 20-win season every now and then and maybe even a Cy Young, but he just can't really string it together on a long term basis. Later in his career, he has his perfect game and maybe around 34 or 35 he succumbs to the temptations of HGH and finally really becomes the perennial All-Star the scouts thought he could be. Either way, he'd be a legend in his white-ass CT town and Rafi, Wes, and Arnold would brag to whomever is listening about how they used to beat him up in 4th grade.
Gareth Bale

Right now, the 21-year-old Bale would the reigning Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback with an uncertain future in the NFL. At 6 feet and not exceptionally sturdy, he'd have trouble taking hits as a pro QB. I think he'd go in the 3rd or 4th round and get some PT as a punt returner, 3rd down receiver, or wildcat quarterback on occasion. With his lightning speed and shifty feet, he'd definitely be good for a few highlight reel plays each season. Maybe down the line he gets a shot when the starting QB goes down. Maybe he surprises everyone and goes on a nice little run.
Antonio Cassano

Much like I postulated about Schweinsteiger, Cassano would be lost without the beautiful game. He's pretty much lost as it is and he's playing for one of the biggest teams in the world and starting for the Italian national team. The American sporting landscape, though, wouldn't be so kind. He's average-sized at best. He has trouble keeping weight off. Maybe he could play running back in high school? D-3? He could definitely get to Athlete of the year status at his high school, but after those glory years I see him ending up as a tragic tattooed ne'er-do-well floating around with a glass of wine in one hand and an almond croissant in the other.
Mario Balotelli

Athletically, he could be an all-pro wide receiver or an all-star guard, but it doesn't seem like he likes to get hit. So, I'd have to go with perpetually disgruntled NBA phenom. Something like the mind of a 20-year-old Rasheed Wallace in Derrick Rose's body. Truly a frightening prospect for most everyone in the NBA. It's basically the same situation we're in now. Extremely rare talent with no way of knowing if he'll be an all-timer or an all-time bust.
Giuseppe Rossi

Well, now this is a little awkward. So, he'd have to be born in Italy to American parents and then move to the U.S. to fulfill his lifelong dream to play for the Yankess and work his way up from the Tampa Bay Rays farm system? This is giving me a headache. Moving on...
Robinho

Pretty much the same story as his teammate Cassano. Minus the tattoos and pastries. Rob Souza, as he'd be known in the States, is listed at 132 pounds. No joke. That's just not gonna cut it in any American sport. Add on his childish antics and a lack of a real work ethic and things wouldn't be too happy in the Souza household. If he was from Florida, he'd still be living at his mom's place playing X-box all day. All-county point guard in high school, though, of course.
Andy Carroll

This one's easy. After an all-state high school football career playing quarterback, linebacker, placekicker, and punter, he'd be in jail for assault playing on the same pickup basketball team as Joey Barton. And then he'd get sold to Christian Poulsen's and Luis Suarez's team for 400,000 carton of cigarettes.
Carlos Tevez

At 5-8, he's certainly on the small side, but homeslice is a goddamn battering ram who plays to exhaustion every time he's on the pitch. We've seen all-pro NFL running backs his size before. He'd also fit in perfectly with the running back corps; threatening to retire every offseason and whatnot. If the NFL doesn't work out and, assuming he'd be from Jersey, he could also carve out a nice little career as a scary temperamental reality TV star.