Está a terminar um período de discussão pública sobre documentos produzidos pelas denominadas medicinas complementares e alternativas no sítio da Direcção Geral da Saúde, com vista a uma futura regulação. É um bom momento para recomendar algumas leituras, nomeadamente o recentíssimo
Suckers - How Alternative Medicine Makes Fools of Us All
Rose Shapiro
Harvill Secker, Fevereiro de 2008
disponível através da Amazon para quem quiser. 258 páginas e algumas centenas de referências bibliográficas documentando o que é escrito.
Transcrevo os primeiros parágrafos do capítulo 10 - The healthy sceptic
There are two definitions of the word 'sucker' I had in mind when I thought about the title of this book. Sucker: one who lives at the expense of others, and sucker: a gullible or easily deceived person. The growth of alternative medicine in the modern era has depended on the existence of both kinds of sucker.
And when I suggest that alternative medicine makes fools of us all, I am thinking about not only those who practise alternative medicine and those who use it, but also those of us who simply let it carry on unchallenged. There is a pervasive tolerance of complementary and alternative medicine which allows it to flourish. I believe this indulgent laissez faire approach is no longer acceptable and needs to change. The growth of CAM [complementary and alternative medicine] matters - it trades in false hope, it is bad for our health, it threatens our intellectual culture, it wastes public money and it undermines some of our most important and valued institutions. Those who promote it and the junk science that all too often accompanies it, are, to quote Raymond Tallis, 'enemies of mankind's best hope for a better future. In short, enemies of mankind'."
A luta contra o obscurantismo, a superstição, a crendice, a ignorância e a vigarice continuam.
(Com um agradecimento ao Jansenista por ter chamado a atenção para este livro).
Suckers - How Alternative Medicine Makes Fools of Us All
Rose Shapiro
Harvill Secker, Fevereiro de 2008
disponível através da Amazon para quem quiser. 258 páginas e algumas centenas de referências bibliográficas documentando o que é escrito.
Transcrevo os primeiros parágrafos do capítulo 10 - The healthy sceptic
There are two definitions of the word 'sucker' I had in mind when I thought about the title of this book. Sucker: one who lives at the expense of others, and sucker: a gullible or easily deceived person. The growth of alternative medicine in the modern era has depended on the existence of both kinds of sucker.
And when I suggest that alternative medicine makes fools of us all, I am thinking about not only those who practise alternative medicine and those who use it, but also those of us who simply let it carry on unchallenged. There is a pervasive tolerance of complementary and alternative medicine which allows it to flourish. I believe this indulgent laissez faire approach is no longer acceptable and needs to change. The growth of CAM [complementary and alternative medicine] matters - it trades in false hope, it is bad for our health, it threatens our intellectual culture, it wastes public money and it undermines some of our most important and valued institutions. Those who promote it and the junk science that all too often accompanies it, are, to quote Raymond Tallis, 'enemies of mankind's best hope for a better future. In short, enemies of mankind'."
A luta contra o obscurantismo, a superstição, a crendice, a ignorância e a vigarice continuam.
(Com um agradecimento ao Jansenista por ter chamado a atenção para este livro).