
Alright Nashville.
One of my biggest regrets in choosing to move was the timing. As many of you may have heard, there is a very important election happening in Nashville on January 22... and I am very upset that I will not be able to vote in this election. Come voting time 2 interesting Bills will be voted on. The first is the infamous "English Only Bill" the second is an amendment that, if passed, would allow for ratification of our Charter at any regularly scheduled general election and by special election once per calendar year.. as opposed to the current regulation that only allows for ratification by vote every 2 years.
I strongly, STRONGLY urge you to vote NO on BOTH of the proposed amendments.
The first is a bit more obvious, and I will address that with others' remarks below... but the second, this, "ratification" business is equally as important. Do you know how much money is wasted on these special elections? That's your tax money folks. I understand that our charters are "living documents" but that doesn't mean we need to go around amending them constantly. This proposed ratification bill just makes it easier for the charter to be changed (we're already allowed to have votes to make adjustments every 2 years... we don't need to be voting more often than that!), costing us hundreds of thousands of dollars in elections alone. Republicans? Ron Paulians? Do you hear me on this? Vote no!
Now on to English only...
Let's chat about immigrants. I won't go into the fact that it's largely immigrants who work the below blue collar, low-paying labor jobs that most americans refuse to work while using unemployment and government welfare services... I know we have an illegal immigrant problem, but is passing English only going to solve or even alleviate any of that? No.
Currently, immigrants are required to demonstrate English proficiency before they become U.S. citizens, but there are some exceptions for people over 50 or people who have been in the U.S. over 20 years. Furthermore, not everyone who lives in the U.S. is required to (or even allowed to) become a U.S. citizen. Green card holders, also called “permanent residents,” fit into this category - as do tourists, business vistors, international students, and others.
Those who aspire to be U.S. citizens go through a long and arduous citizenship process, even while they are living in Nashville. Immigrants still have to interact with local government agencies even while they are learning English but before they are conversant or fluent, and it varies from individual to individual. When refugees come to Tennessee from Sudan, they don’t learn English in a refugee camp in Chad. They learn English once they get here.
And that's just one reason why this proposed bill is ridiculous.
Today in a full-page ad in the Tennessean, numerous Nashville University Presidents issued a statement rejecting the proposed "English Only" amendment. And I am proud to say that the statement was actually Bob Fishers (Belmont's President, and Tennessean of the year for 2008) idea. Woohoo!!!! I'm surprised and THRILLED!
Below is their statement.... (and it's awesome, so read it)
In just a few short days, county residents will go to the polls to decide the fate of the "English-only" amendment that has been proposed for our Metro Charter.
This is not the first time that this proposal has been before the democratic processes in our county. A previous attempt to enact this legislation was halted by the courageous veto of former Mayor Bill Purcell. We have also seen current Mayor Karl Dean stand firm in his opposition. Both of these leaders saw the passage of this legislation not only as unnecessary but as damaging to Nashville.
It is especially important that the higher education community in Nashville be heard on this issue. It is the obligation of institutions of higher education to help their communities think critically about important issues of public policy, especially when the policies have a deep and lasting impact on these communities.
The proposed amendment appears to arise out of a concern about the large number of undocumented immigrants who have moved to Nashville in recent years. While illegal immigration is a legitimate concern that needs thoughtful consideration and action, the proposed amendment does nothing to address this significant issue. Rather, it represents a "shotgun" approach that will have numerous unintended consequences that are largely unrelated to the problems associated with the presence of undocumented people.
Currently, Metro government provides services to its diverse immigrant populations and international visitors in several different languages. These services are provided to facilitate the transition of individuals and families from being "immigrants" to becoming citizens. Refusing to provide translation assistance to visitors, recently arrived immigrants and other English learners who need it is, in essence, refusing to offer the services at all. Is it appropriate to refuse services to those in need just because some are here illegally?
Is it appropriate to deny diverse immigrant populations culturally competent, compassionate health care? If passed, city health-care providers would be prevented from communicating with their patient in the patient's language — a situation that would have dire effects.
Is it appropriate to hinder opportunities for the Nashville community to engage in intellectual dialogue in pursuit of academic excellence? Each year many international students and teachers come to our campuses to enrich our academic mission, participate in our vibrant Nashville community, and contribute to our local economy.
The "English-only" amendment will not force illegal immigrants to leave, nor will it stop the influx of additional undocumented immigrants from coming to Nashville. Instead, it will add unnecessary layers to the natural barriers, which already exist to create challenges for immigrant families who desire to become healthy, productive and contributing citizens of the nation and the Nashville community.
The challenges facing immigrants will go from being "difficult to overcome" to being "impossible to overcome."
These services provided by Metro, which facilitate the transition of individuals and families from being "immigrants" to becoming citizens, also help ensure that our city continues to recruit businesses and attract tourists from around the world.
Metro Nashville is a key player in the global economy. The continued health of Nashville is dependent on the city's ability to attract businesses and tourists from all over the world. The decision of Nissan to relocate its U.S. headquarters to Metro Nashville is but one of the latest examples of international businesses relocating to Middle Tennessee. The proposed charter amendment will negatively impact these efforts by presenting our community as unwelcoming to internationals and backward in its thinking.
Our leaders' efforts to recruit businesses internationally create an environment that is attractive to immigrants, many of whom are not yet able to speak English. A multilingual population is the logical consequence of our efforts to become the business relocation site of choice in the United States. Middle Tennesseans cannot expect to have a thriving, or even stable, economy without an environment that is welcoming and accommodating of the needs of business and those individuals that businesses bring with them.
The concerted efforts of individuals, business leaders, community volunteers and our elected leaders of Metropolitan Nashville and Davidson County have created a city and a region that is healthy in its diversity, its economy and the opportunities it affords its residents.
The irony of the city known as the "Athens of the South" becoming the first major metropolitan community in America to pass "English only" is a distressing prospect. As academic leaders, we are concerned about the impact — literal and symbolic — on our mission of teaching, learning, curing, and discovering.
A statement by Nashville that we are "English" only — this "blunt" instrument — would undermine our important work and adversely affect this city known for learning and discovery.
Sister Mary Peter Muehlenkamp, O.P.
president, Aquinas CollegeRobert C. Fisher
president, Belmont UniversityHazel R. O'Leary
president, Fisk UniversityL. Randolph Lowry
president, Lipscomb UniversityWayne J. Riley
president and chief executive officer, Meharry Medical CollegeMelvin N. Johnson
president, Tennessee State UniversityDan Boone
president, Trevecca UniversityNicholas S. Zeppos
chancellor, Vanderbilt UniversityForrest Harris
president, American Baptist College
Please Vote. And Vote NO.
Early voting
January 2-17
(Some voters qualify for mail-in ballots)
Election Day
January 22
for more info please visit: www.nashvilleforallofus.org
** side note on our "friend" and English-only mastermind councilman Eric Crafton: apparently some people will do anything to be remembered... how sad. Please don't forget that the only reason Eric Crafton is in office is because no one ever runs against him... even his own alma mater is against his brilliant idea.

























