If you're my friend on Facebook, you probably already know, I spent last week in jury duty. I got the notice and thought and thought and thought about reasons that would be legitimate enough to get me out of it.
I sleep every day until at least 10 am?
Studies show: courtrooms are bad for babies?
Unfortunately, all I could do was sign thing and send it in. A few weeks later, low and behold, a little yellow postcard just for me! Complete with juror and reporting number.
There were no trials the first day and so I was instructed to call back the next day. But my luck ran out on Tuesday, when I had to report to the courthouse at 9 am. (9 am? that's soooo early...!) I got there a bit early and sat in what I remember to be the same room I sat in for traffic school--that's another story, and not as interesting. After everyone was assembled, we got to watch the most epic movie about jury duty. That is, the music made it sound that way. Imagine a theme similar to "Indiana Jones" playing as you watch a mailman walk up to a house and put a jury summons in the box. Truly an epic event, if I say so myself. The patriotic march music played through the whole thing while people described being worried about missing work and wondering if they'll get picked for the jury.
Seriously, best. movie. ever.
Then after lots of waiting--which is what jury duty really is, lots of waiting-- we went upstairs to the courtrooms escorted by our bailiff and then lined up in order. They asked a bunch of questions, including if we knew anyone associated with or involved in the case, or if we knew anyone else in the jury. Then we each had to tell our answers to the some questions:
How long we've lived in Salt Lake County.
What we do for a living.
If we're attending school.
If we're married or single.
What our spouse does (if married).
and then the judge added on what we typically read.
I have no idea how the attorneys decide, but they take the list and pass it back and forth crossing off the ones they don't want. The top 8 names that are not crossed off are the ones chosen to be on the jury. (I was #11, I counted. And then cursed. Them aren't good odds I'm not getting picked.) Sure enough, the jurors picked included little 'ol Ms. Green.
The trial started immediately with opening arguments, then lunch, then witnesses. The case was a civil trial (which I thought made it harder). The short version is this:
Mr. Sauceda and his friend Mr. Delgato decide to go into business with Mr. Capellini. That business being prepaid phone cards, prepaid cell phones, prepaid debit cards, and public phones. (the kind that are so popular with the latin community for calling long distance.) Mr. Sauceda had been selling these kinds of things for a while in Utah, and Mr. Capellini had been doing it a lot in Texas. They come up with a contract and get things started, then Delgato backs out. Mr. Sauceda then takes over Delgato's part of the contract and pays his part. Later on Mr. Capellini says he needs more money and more money and more money and stupid Sauceda keeps giving it to him. In the meantime there's some interaction and involvement with Mr. Capellini's wife and son. Mr. Sauceda is suing Mr. Capellini's wife and son for fraud and damages from that fraud. Mr. Capellini is dead. (lame!)
After evidence and testimony was given for 2 1/2 days, we went back to deliberate. The first thing you're supposed to do is pick a Jury Foreman. They sign the verdict and let the bailiff know you've reached a verdict and all that. I stopped by the bathroom on my way in the jury room and when I arrived inside the other jurors said they'd voted, and I was the foreman. "last one in! ha ha..." I laughed, and then there was an awkward pause. I said, "really?" and they were all like, "sure!" and so I was the Jury Foreman. I took that also to be that I could try to keep everyone on track and call for votes when necessary. The deliberation was probably the best part. It was one of the only times that we as a jury actually talked to each other. Our bailiff kept commenting on how quiet a jury we were. Sometimes it was awkward how silent it was in that jury room.
We finally sited Mrs. Rodriguez (Wife of Capellini) with fraud and awarded damages to Mr. Sauceda. But we didn't feel there was enough evidence to fully sentence fraud to Mr. Perez (son of Capellini). It was really hard because I felt bad for Mr. Sauceda. He was obviously swindled, and I wanted him to have some compensation. It was hard to keep that separate and look at only the evidence. I wanted him to have money so bad, but I just couldn't justify where the money would come from (not Mr. Capellini himself). And it's also hard because so much of the evidence that was to show that Rodriquez and Perez were involved in the business of fraud were also things that family members would just be doing for each other. Cashing checks, delivering equipment... all things that could have just been your dad/spouse saying hey--do this for me. And the wording of the verdict said that they had to have "
knowingly participated in a fraudulent activity."
I decided next time I hope it's a homicide. Then it's just did they or didn't they kill them. Guilty, not guilty. The end.
Overall it was a good experience, and I learned a lot from it.
I didn't know how much the bailiff does. He was our escort and host, and he opened and closed the session, and ran a lot of the court. That is, the stuff the judge didn't do. Ours was awesome, he knew all our names by the end of the first day.
It was fun meeting the other jurors and getting to know them over the case. One of our jurors was a retired clerk for the court. She worked for a different judge, but knew almost everyone we passed in the hallway. She was a good resource for us other jurors because she knew how stuff worked. She could even predict what was going on in the courtroom when we were dismissed. Sometimes the jury leaves so they only hear certain things. Those things seemed to usually be stuff that had to be hashed out between the attorneys. That way we didn't get distracted from the actual case and the evidence presented.
Though the time off was not the way I'd like to spend my time off of work, it was still a pretty valuable use of my time. And I'd say now that jury duty isn't that bad. It was a good experience.