[If it seems like I'm on a recipe-themed kick, it's because I am. Feeding people is basically my life.]
I have long joked that if making bread were a requirement for anything (being a good wife, membership in the Relief Society, true provident living), I was out of luck. In my life, I have made a lot of cookies, pies, cakes, muffins, waffles, pancakes, cornbread, even a few tortillas and taco shells.
My husband loves me anyway. Which is a big deal, since he grew up on homemade bread...fresh ground, whole grain, hand-kneaded homemade bread. But for the decade-and-a-half that we have been married, he has had to find other sources for homemade bread.
Friday morning, I decided to change all that. It was time. Mark has been pampering me so well for so long. I finally had the courage to choke down all my insecurities and excuses, suppress my involuntary shuddering, and make bread. I used this recipe (Faye, you're amazing! And so is your bread!):
"The Best Homemade Bread Ever"
Faye Walker
4 cups warm water
1 1/3 cup sugar OR 1 cup honey
3 tablespoon yeast
1 tablespoon salt
1/2 cup oil
12 cups flour
Combine water, yeast and sugar/honey. Let rise. Add remaining ingredients. Mix in mixer for 12 minutes (by hand, you're on your own!). Cover and let rise until double. Punch down. Let rise til double again. Shape into rolls or loaves in oiled pans. Makes 3-4 large loaves. Let rise til 1 inch above top of pan. Bake at 375 for sugar, 350 for honey for 25-30 minutes. Butter tops. Cool on rack.
This is word-for-word how Faye gave it to me about seven years ago (yes, I've been trying to psyche myself into this for that long). I followed the recipe compulsively. And even though I do NOT have a mixer and had to do it by hand (on my own), even though the recipe did NOT say how long to let the yeast rise, even though the recipe did NOT answer the all the horrid, doubt-plagued questions that kept coming to my mind, the bread was perfect.
I was elated. My first EVER attempt to make bread was a success! I actually drove to Mark's office with a still-warm loaf of bread, a cutting knife, and honey butter on a tray. He was so rewarding. He took the tray around the whole office, bragging and sharing. All four loaves were gobbled down record time.
Of course, Saturday afternoon, I was ready to try again. This time, I was all daring and brave, and put in some milled flax seed (have to get in that Omega 3 fatty stuff, right?) and some wheat bran (yes, I'm a weeny and I am using store-bought, enriched white flour). And the bread STILL turned out. It was just a bit heavier, but not in a bad way. Mark even took half a loaf for the Young Men to use as the Sacrament bread.
I wasn't sure how to feel about that:
(1) Oh no! My family has been lying to spare my feelings, but now REAL people are going to taste my bread and tell the truth!
(2) Hooray, my bread is good enough to be used for Sacrament bread! I'm a success! Is it appropriate to brag about it?
(3) Hey, bring that back here! I made that, WITHOUT a mixer, and it took a lot of work, and I'm not in a hurry to give it away, darn it!
(4) Well, guess it's time to make more bread! Is bread-making a Sabbath activity? We sure are burning through our flour supply...
Monday, the bread was all gone. (Except for the crumbs EVERYWHERE. Now that I think about it, I do remember there being a lot of bread crumbs in my mother-in-law's kitchen. All the time. But I digress.) I'm starting to feel a little bit of the "give us this day our daily bread" thing. Of course, I needed to make more bread. Not that we didn't have bread in the house, mostly because my family was rarely this rewarding about something I make, but partly so I could strut around in my new-found capacity.
But, Monday I had my hands full of errands and toddlers and a nursling and a bunch of other stuff. So, I delegated it to Hyrum.
Hyrum is a good cook. He can follow a recipe just fine. He can even improvise with decent success. I pointed him toward Faye's recipe, and put my mind at ease about the bread.
The bread failed. Badly. Mark and Hyrum and I have gone over the recipe and the process and tried to figure out what happened. It can't be just that it was Hyrum and not me. Whatever it was, I had four loaves of shame on my counter. Some braver souls doused it with honey and gnawed away at it. Half of one loaf was decent. The rest of it sat there like lumps of sadness, getting drier and staler with each passing day.
I couldn't bring myself to put it in the compost, or (Heaven forbid!) throw it away. Today, I vowed to salvage the bread, along with my shredded carb-infested self esteem. I pulled out the breakfast casserole recipe (from my Early Morning Seminary days) and used up a good portion the failed loaves. We ate it for dinner tonight. Everyone gobbled, no one complained, bread was used and not wasted:
Breakfast Sausage and Egg Casserole
1 pound sausage (crumbled, cooked & drained)
6 eggs, slightly beaten
2 cups milk
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon dry mustard
2 slices bread, crumbled
1 cup grated cheese
3 tablespoons onions (optional)
Mix all ingredients together. Pour into buttered (8x11 or 9x13 works well) casserole dish. Refrigerate overnight. Bake uncovered at 350 degrees for 45-60 minutes, depending on pan size. Serves 8.
It was while I was assembling said casserole that an idea popped into my head: bread pudding.
I have never even eaten bread pudding, much less made it. But it sounded like a good idea. Hyrum Googled "bread pudding" and we used the first recipe he found. It's from an old Amish cookbook, apparently. It was super-easy, and it was super-amazing. I was a little giggly about it, because it made me feel like Beatrix Potter or Anne of Green Gables to be making bread pudding. Something just feels nostalgic and authentic about just saying it, not to mention making it.
Oh goodness, it was delicious. After everyone licked (not exaggerating) their plates clean, Hyrum wanted to know if we had enough failed bread left to make it again tomorrow. Someone voiced the opinion that we should fail bread on purpose just so we could make bread pudding.
Personally, I don't think my confidence or my domestic sense of worth could withstand failing bread on purpose. It could barely handle doing it on accident, even when it wasn't actually me that did it. Anyway, the casserole was a success, the pudding was a ranting, raving success. I feel like I am somehow more bona fide than I used to be, making bread from scratch and by hand and all that (you long-time bread-making friends of mine, you may gloat, but do not let me see you doing it, please).
And tomorrow I am making bread.