I have known my share of self proclaimed perfectionists, and much as I liked some of them, I would always, eventually, lose patience. When I found this on the incomparable
Whiskey River, I think I understand better why.
"Someday, sometime, you will be sitting somewhere. A berm overlooking a pond in Vermont. The lip of the Grand Canyon at sunset. A seat on the subway. And something bad will have happened: You will have lost someone you loved, or failed at something at which you badly wanted to succeed. And sitting there, you will fall into the center of yourself. You will look for some core to sustain you. And if you have been perfect all your life and have managed to meet all the expectations of your family, your friends, your community, your society, chances are excellent that there will be a black hole where that core ought to be. I don't want anyone I know to take that terrible chance. And the only way to avoid it is to listen to that small voice inside you that tells you to make mischief, to have fun, to be contrarian, to go another way. George Eliot wrote, 'It is never too late to be what you might have been.' It is never too early, either."
- Anna Quindlen
Being Perfect
I had my first big failure in 4th grade. The 4th and 5th grades were combined in a three track system, I was in the top one with mostly 5th graders, which worked well in every subject, except math. I'd never memorized my times tables, and had no clue how to approach the homework. I ignored it. Maybe I figured I'd miraculously understand in the next class? This seemed to make sense at age 9.
Reality caught me up, slammed me down, and pinned me to my failure. I was put with the middling mix of 4th and 5th graders, including the worst bullies - who were glad to see me fall. And had to face my mother's wrath, as she drilled the times tables into my head for the next year. She never really understood, since she could just see them in her head. I could barely differentiate a 3 from a 5 from an 8, at least not reliably. I got it down sufficiently, and much as I wanted to disappear, I survived. Never got good at math, but by high school, usually kept a high B, with an occasional A-.
Paperwork to this day, comes first. Get it done, get it done right, check it again. So I can sleep at night. Never let that kind of task lay undone too long. Not for fun, but peace of mind.
The more important lesson, not entirely grasped at the time, was that 'done sufficiently' beats 'holding back waiting for perfection.' Perfect is impossible, the work needs to be done.
That sense of myself that included laziness and blind spots and inadequacies, still spins. I'm uncomfortable with generosity, when it comes to food or money spent. I hated over-icing cupcakes brought to school events, I wanted whatever was left in the bowl for myself, not kids I didn't much like. I helped another kid drop rocks on his baby brother, until my mother intervened in a fury. I was small myself, but that shame composted my empathy. Out with D downtown many years ago, a young woman inert on the sidewalk. I barely glanced, and would have walked on, if D had not gone right to her, nudged me to be better. That kindness is in me, but it's my second thought, not my first.
So, perhaps the other way to avoid the emptiness, is to peer into one's failures, and be comfortable in one's own flaws. Not proud of them, nor ashamed of them, simply aware, with a plan for how to cope when they cause a collapse, with a sense of humor and responsibility.
Because worse than the perfectionists, perhaps the flip side of the coin, are the people who shrug and say, "Oh, well that was a learning experience, we all make mistakes" but then never take it in hard enough to hurt enough to actually learn the lesson and change.
Shruggers and perfectionists both seem a little too afraid to look at a job and say "Well, this is going to leave a mark!" and go ahead and jump in anyway. I hesitate, certainly, but then plunge my hands in, trying not to scream too loudly. That is what I see in perfectionists that is a reflexion of my own fears, that reluctance to be brave, the urge to let it slide.
Like that time in Basic, when my dogtags inexplicably slipped from my neck while I was on the toilet. Oh, I considered flushing them down, but I knew where that path led. Took a deep breath, and grabbed them out, washed them off, and (ha) soldiered on. I've done worse jobs since, although usually with gloves.
Maybe it's largely a matter of practice, learning how to fall.