Just some notes, since I've been both places.
Of course, I am constrained by the fact that I've only been in NTU one semester (as opposed to 6 in NUS) and my review of NTU is very limited by where I've been -- communication school and the canteens and libraries nearest to my building. I don't like to walk.
So... the comparison:
#1. EXAMS VIA COMPUTERS I'm taking 2 exam papers in NTU on computer! Meaning I type, not write, my essays. Because my instructors are sick of deciphering illegible handwriting penned by students' hands that move too slow for their brains, like mine! Also, I have sweaty palms. I'm excited about this. I'm sure I can think better if I can read what I've written too haha
#2 TOILETSThere are too many dubious around-the-corner toilets in NTU that I'm not even sure the cleaners know about. Those with sanitary bins chocked to the top with ahem and vomit in the sinks. Do they even get cleaned? I really don't know! But they're poorly ventilated and humid, glow a dim ominous orange at night, and smell. Somewhat like NUS' pre-renovation loos.
#3 FOOD. I can't comment much actually because I'm not a experimenter. I always eat Chinese. No Indian, Malay, Western, Korean or Japanese for me. Also, I've only been to two canteens: A and B (haha yeaaaaa I couldn't find C and I'm so OCD I can't go to D unless I find C. Kidding!) I think food-wise, they're evenly matched. Both have Macs and Subway. NTU also has Sakae Sushi, Old Chang Kee and my favouritest of all, MR BEAN. Soya ice-cream! My only complaint is that the communication school is so faroff from any canteen that anyone too weak from hunger can only either make do with lunch from a vending machine or die crawling to a canteen.
#4 LIBRARIESThe most annoying thing about NTU is that it has more power sockets than seats. So people who don't need sockets will be sitting right next to an empty one mugging when I neeeeeeeeed that socket but can't chase them away because there's no seat elsewhere. And the three holes right there taunt me so, and it takes all the living strength in me to... walk... away... longing backward gaze and all. I would never find myself in that situation in NUS. There's always places to sit but never a powerpoint. On that note, yes, NUS libraries do sit a lot more people. Even NTU's biggest library is hard pressed for space. In NUS I never had to share a table with 3 others. More like I'd always occupy a table for 4 by myself.
#5 CNM vs. WKW
WKW = Wee Kim Wee by the way. I get asked to compare the two so much by my NTU classmates that I don't even feel like talking about it anymore. So for the last time (today being last day of school):
I guess it is to be expected that a comms school would be better a comms
programme, but the difference in the quality of instructors and lessons still surprises me. Granted, not all my NTU instructors are excellent. This one in particular who teaches International Affairs Reporting (oh yes, more interesting modules here too FOR SURE), is so idealistic and abstract in her teaching content that I unfortunately take away nothing valuable from her lessons, WHICH BY THE WAY ALSO START AT 9AM. Early morning lessons need to justify themselves by being worth it.
I think the major difference is this: NTU professors are more practitioners rather than academics. My
other International Affairs Reporting instructor is --get this!-- a Reuters foreign correspondent! My Biz & Economics Journalism professor still is, as his module title suggests, a biz & economics journalist. My 'Production Management for TV & Cinema' instructor has MADE FILMS, albeit budget and independent, but duuuuuuuuude, let's not argue about the specifics.
I think you can't teach something until you've practised it. CNM lecturers read a textbook, or
several textbooks, write a thesis, and get knighted a professor. They've never designed a piece of interactive media, or chased and written stories for a press, or actually designed a game or published their own magazine in the big, bad, harsh, cruel and unforgiving world outside. Everything they've learned, they learned in an armchair. No wonder they're not as interesting as NTU instructors.
That said, I take into account that CNM has less manpower (and probably funds too) to really organize its syllabus into something cohesive and comprehensive, so it probably just gotta grab whatever comes along. You offered legal advice on intellectual property law for a while? OK, come here and teach something, anything! And you wrote for The Straits Times for a year, you said? Alright, you're in. The media writing class is all yours!
And now I'm off on a tangent with my personal grouses, so I'm just gonna give you my last thoughts and
leave.
Going on this exchange, albeit local, has taught me that
- I can get used to any place given time.
- Starting to socialize from scratch in a sea of strangers isn't fun to me, but I don't mind it.
- I like studying for interest, not grades. It's easier to breathe.
- I'm not very sentimental. No photographs and exchanging phone numbers and bear hugs on my last day of school. Feels vaguely like I'm just passing through NTU for a while and am leaving no traces behind.
Yea, and that's it. Goodbye.