Taking upon the overwhelming challenge thrown down by
Sarah, I have compiled a draft list of Dave Matthews Band greatest hits. This is overwhelming as Micheal evidenced with his
40 song selection. I did attempt to limit my choices to at least a 2-disc collection (not including length on some tracks), but ultimately that didn’t work out.
Picking your favorite DMB tunes is easy enough if provoked, however selecting the best version of each song (it will be live unless in rare circumstances) is like picking your favorite child (an experience I don’t plan on having to worry about for a long time), its impossible.
In selecting songs for greatest hits, I avoided songs with guest artists other than the usual suspects (Tim Reynolds, Butch Taylor, the lovely ladies). For example, the “Warehouse” performance at Golden Gate Park with Carlos Santana is omitted. Also, I have to exclude great covers such as “Long Black Veil”, “Redemption Song”, and even considered excluding “All Along The Watchtower”. However, if Jimi Hendrix can put it on his greatest hits collection, why not Dave & Co. I would like to point out that I would not debate too much against varying choices because they are all so darn good.
[Choices were made with only the following albums…all studio albums except Remember Two Things. Does not include Listener Supported, LIVE Trax Richmond, or LIVE Trax Meadow Brook, nor Weekend At The Rocks, which I just received recently. I sill need time to get through it.]
THE LIST…(in no particular order)
JTR – Live At Folsom Field (Great song from The Lillywhite Sessions)
So Right – Live At Folsom Field
Everyday (#36) – Live At Folsom Field (Great mix of 2 great songs, I never get tired of this performance)
Best of What’s Around – Live At Red Rocks 8.15.95 (a little bit quicker tempo, however Golden Gate is a close 2nd)
Joy Ride – Live From Golden Gate Park (I purchased this show for this song.)
Ants Marching – Live At Folsom Field
What Would You Say – Under The Table And Dreaming (the one that “started” it all)
Don’t Burn The Pig – The Gorge (disc 3)
Grey Street – The Gorge (disc 2)
Bartender – Live At Folsom Field
Tripping Billies - LIVE Centrum Centre Worchester
Recently – Live At Red Rocks 8.15.95 (first version I heard…also having memories of being in a car trip with my parents & sister in high school and having to explain to my mom what “smoke a bowl” meant.)
Two Step – The Gorge (disc 4)
Crash Into Me – Live At Folsom Field (has to be on a Greatest Hits collection due to its popularity amongst non-Dave fans)
#41 – LIVE Centrum Centre Worchester
So Much To Say > Too Much - Live in Chicago At The United Center
Jimi Thing – Live in Chicago At United Center (Golden Gate version includes Buffalo Springfield song, so I took that into consideration.)
Warehouse – The Gorge (disc 3)
Lie In Our Graves – Live From Golden Gate Park
Don’t Drink The Water – Live In Chicago At The United Center
The Stone – The Gorge (disc 3)
Pantala Naga Pampa > Rapunzel - LIVE Centrum Centre Worchester (love the “YEAH!!” Listen you’ll hear it).
Busted Stuff – The Lillywhite Sessions
Crush – The Central Park Concert
True Reflections – Warehouse Vol. 5 (I am not member so thanks to
Michael for this one.)
All Along The Watchtower – Live At Folsom Field
Dancing Nancies – Live At Red Rocks 8.15.95
I really could select one performance of each song in their catalog and still be incomplete. Grace Is Gone, Say Goodbye, Dream Girl, Hello Again, Lover Lay Down are just a few songs I left out. Thanks to Sarah for getting me reacquainted with DMB. Now where is
her list?