Here's how the two teams stack up...
Michigan Defense against OSU OffenseMichigan Pass Rushers vs. OSU O-Line and Troy SmithThis matchup is the key to the game. Whoever wins this, wins the game. There, I said it. The two main things to consider are:
1) Can OSU's offensive line contain the defensive ends? If so, then Troy Smith will be able to scramble east-west and tear Michigan's secondary apart. Woodley and Biggs need to play excellent contain on the outside and force Smith to be a pocket passer.
2) How much will Michigan need to blitz. If Michigan can manage to get pressure with just it's front four, game over. If OSU forces Michigan to blitz, then Smith can find the open man.
Advantage: OSU, barelyMichigan Front Seven vs. OSU O-Line and Antonio PittmanEveryone knows that it is almost impossible to run on Michigan's defense. If OSU can manage to run against Michigan, watch out. However, that won't happen. Michigan is too disciplined and too athletic up front to allow more than 75 yards to the OSU running backs. Dave Harris is a stellar linebacker who has amazing instincts. OSU will get its running game (for better or for worse) primarily from Smith.
Advantage: MichiganMichigan Secondary vs. OSU Receivers
This will be the biggest test for Michigan's secondary all year. This is really the first time since the Notre Dame game that Michigan has faced two good wide receievers at the same time. This is going to turn into a case of pick your poison for Michigan. The Wolverine defense can take away with either Ted Ginn or Anthony Gonzalez with Leon Hall. Who do you want to let free? Morgan Trent is going to need the game of his life if Michigan is to win this battle.
Advantage: OSU
Michigan Offense against OSU DefenseMichigan O-Line and Mike Hart vs. OSU Front Seven
This is the second key to the game. Michigan is 17-1 when Mike Hart rushes for 100 yards or more. Being able to run the ball does two things:
1) It keeps OSU's offense off the field, which is just as good a defense as Lamarr Woodley and co.
2) It wears down OSU's defense, tiring them out, and making them susceptible to the big play through the air.
Hart is finally fully healthy for a Michigan-OSU game, and he will be eager to right his record against the Bucks. Another member of the Michigan offense who is finally healthy for this game is Jake Long. Don't be surprised if Michigan runs more than half of their first few plays over the left side that Long anchors.
OSU LB Laurinaitis and DL Pitcock are fantastic players who have great football smarts, but they simply do not have enough help to shut down Michigan's power running game on their own.
Advantage: MichiganMichigan O-Line and Chad Henne vs. OSU Pass RushersGive Chad Henne time to throw, and he'll do a great job of managing the game. Henne has matured remarkably since his first OSU game. He will be looking to exorcise his demons and finally pull out a win against the Buckeyes. Michigan's O-Line matches up favorably against OSU's front four, due mainly to OSU's lack of stellar defensive ends. Long and Riley can hold the pocket all day for Henne, so OSU will have to blitz if they want pressure. It's a risk-reward situation for both teams. Michigan has the chance to exploit the blitz and blow the game up with a big pass play. OSU has the chance to harass Henne with their talented crew of linebackers on blitzes all day. One thing about Henne is that he is somewhat streaky. When he's comfortable in the pocket, there are few quarterbacks in college football who can pick apart a defense like he can. However, when he's not settled, and is being pressured consistently, he can look
really bad.
Advantage: Michigan, by a hair
Michigan Recievers vs. OSU Secondary
The #1 question here is: Is Mario Manningham 100%? If he is, then OSU is going to have their hands full with him stretching the field deep, Breaston running the short 10-yard patterns, and either Ecker or Arrington running routes across the middle against the OSU linebackers. OSU will need to blitz to get pressure on Henne, so Michigan receivers will often be up against single coverage. Henne and his receivers need to read the defense very well so that they can exploit these opportunities.
Advantage:
Michigan (if Manningham is 100%), otherwise EVENSpecial TeamsMichigan kick and punt coverage and Zoltan Mesko vs. Ted GinnGinn has a history of burning Michigan on special teams. While Michigan has not allowed much by the way of returns this year, Ginn is lightning in a bottle. Mesko needs to take a page out of old Harry Kipke's book and place his punts with absolute perfection.
Advantage: OSUSteve Breaston vs. OSU kick and punt coverage and A.J. TrapassoUntil last week Breaston had not broken loose in the return game. Was the Indiana game a return to true form or just a fluke? Michigan will need at least one big play from Breaston. It doesn't need to be a touchdown - a 50-yard kickoff return is just as huge, as it allows Michigan to either score, or control field position. Trapasso is an excellent punter who gets both good distance and placement. He rarely outkicks his coverage.
Advantage: EVENGarrett Rivas vs. Aaron Pettrey
Rivas is older, has more experience, has kicked more game winning field goals, and is the all-time leading scorer at Michigan. Case closed.
Advantage: Michigan
Coaching Lloyd Carr vs. Jim Tressel
Many people will give ol' sweater vest the edge here. I won't. This matchup is about as even as it gets.
Advantage: EVENRon English vs. Jim Bollman
Ron English scares the crap out of me. His defense is like an angry pack of bloodthirsty animals. He should be a candidate for the Frank Broyles Trophy. Bollman's offense is running like a Ferrari right now, but its more the talent on the field, and less of the coaching.
Advantage: English
Mike Debord vs. Jim HeacockSimilarities, similarities... Debord likes to run a conventional run-first offense that uses the ground game to set up the pass. He doesn't use shifting and other offensive gizmos to try to confuse the defense. No, he'll tell you what he plans on doing (run the ball) and he'll dare you to stop him.
In comparison, Heacock runs a conventional bend-don't-break defense that plays tough against the run and thrives on turnovers. He doesn't blitz as much as many other defensive coordinators across the country do.
Advantage: EVENIntangibles Questions to consider...How much of a factor will the home crowd be?
Will Michigan have the weight of 1-4 over the last 5 in their heads, or will they come out hungry for revenge?
Will OSU be prepared for what is a very different Michigan team from last year, or will their confidence get the best of them?
Advantage: EVENWrap upThis game will not disappoint. Don't be surprised if turns into a last-minute affair. Look for one of the Michigan receivers to catch a deep TD pass, for Hart to tack on a touchdown, and for another short touchdown, either by air or on the ground. On the OSU side, look for Gonzalez to score at least once, with Ginn scoring on either a reverse or a punt return, and a touchdown to one of OSU's tight ends in the red zone. With the score tied at 21 late in the fourth quarter, watch for the Garrett Rivas field goal for the go-ahead Michigan points. It will come down to the matchup of each team's strengths: Michigan defense vs. OSU offense. Defense wins championships.
Prediction: Michigan 24, OSU 21