Saturday, December 02, 2006

John Manley: Treatment of Ignatieff 'Inhumane'

It was quite obvious that it took an inordinate amount of time for the results of the final ballot at the Liberal convention to be announced on Saturday. Media speculation was that it had been dragged out to run into prime time: 6pm ET. Regardless of what the real reason was for the long wait, comments made by John Manley on CBC during that lull were just absolutely outrageous. As the split screen showed Dion and Ignatieff and with commentary by Peter Mansbridge and Keith Boag about how 'tough' it was for candidates at that point who eagerly awaiting the results, Manley chimed in with this:

Manley: Whatever reason they have for delaying the announcement of these results, I consider it to be inhumane treatment of Michael Ignatieff. That man's been standing there for 10 minutes with his face on the screen knowing the result...for what purpose? It's very unfair. Just on a human level, it's unfair.

(Mansbridge cuts in thinking it's time for the announcement, but it isn't...)

Mansbridge: I'm sure what it is... it's all about trying to hit a television time here, you know. It's all about that. Not on part of the television network, no, on the part of your party...

Manley: Well, it's aggravating, it's unfair, it's cruel and I don't like it. If they think it's going to win some election in the future, they're dreaming in Technicolour. They should move this on.

I have to say that my head damn near exploded when Manley complained about this supposed 'inhumane treatment' of Ignatieff. To say that about a man who believes in coercive interrogation ie. torture. That Manley would even suggest that making Ignatieff sit there (for whatever reason) was 'cruel' is just a sad, pathetic joke.

Just let me quote from that poor, mistreated politician who was just subjected to Manley's definition of 'inhumane treatment':

To defeat evil, we may have to traffic in evils: indefinite detention of suspects, coercive interrogations, targeted assassinations, even pre-emptive war.
- Michael Ignatieff

Take your overblown indignation and stuff it where the sun don't shine, Manley. With every fiber of my being, I am profoundly grateful that the Liberal party did not choose Michael Ignatieff to lead them and may he fade away quietly into the dustbin of has beens.

Reality vs Rumsfeld: A New Leaked Memo

A leaked Nov 6 memo by Rumsfeld, in which he considers changes to the Iraq strategy, has been published by the New York Times. No doubt, Rumsfeld supporters will find these two tidbits a bit disconcerting:

Another option calls for redeploying American troops from “vulnerable positions” in Baghdad and other cities to safer areas in Iraq or Kuwait, where they would act as a “quick reaction force.” That idea is similar to a plan suggested by Representative John P. Murtha, a Pennsylvania Democrat, a plan that the White House has soundly rebuffed.
[...]
Taking a leaf out of Mr. Hussein’s book, Mr. Rumsfeld seemed to see some merit in the former dictator’s practice of paying Iraqi leaders. “Provide money to key political and religious leaders (as Saddam Hussein did), to get them to help us get through this difficult period,” one option reads.

Right-wingers, of course, will hold those up as justifiable reasons for Rumsfeld's firing, despite the fact that at least the first option has already leaked out now as a recommendation from the Iraq Study Group. To admit Murtha was right is like blasphemy to that bunch.

Additionally, Rumsfeld finally admitted that his approach had been wrong:

“In my view it is time for a major adjustment,” wrote Mr. Rumsfeld, who has been a symbol of a dogged stay-the-course policy. “Clearly, what U.S. forces are currently doing in Iraq is not working well enough or fast enough.”

Nor did Mr. Rumsfeld seem confident that the administration would readily develop an effective alternative.

That lack of confidence in anyone but himself being capable to fix the situation though is just another expression of his arrogance, as is this:

To limit the political fallout from shifting course he suggested the administration consider a campaign to lower public expectations.

“Announce that whatever new approach the U.S. decides on, the U.S. is doing so on a trial basis,” he wrote. “This will give us the ability to readjust and move to another course, if necessary, and therefore not ‘lose.’ ”

“Recast the U.S. military mission and the U.S. goals (how we talk about them) — go minimalist,” he added. Mr. Rumsfeld’s memo suggests frustration with the pace of turning over responsibility to the Iraqi authorities; in fact, the memo calls for examination of ideas that roughly parallel troop withdrawal proposals presented by some of the White House’s sharpest Democratic critics.

And this:

The memo’s discussion of possible troop reduction options offers a counterpoint to Mr. Rumsfeld’s frequent public suggestions that discussions about force levels are driven by requests from American military commanders.

Instead, the memo puts on the table several ideas for troop redeployments or withdrawals that appear to conflict with recent public pronouncements from commanders in Iraq emphasizing the need to maintain troop levels.

So, his attempt to save his own butt when he must have known there was a change in his future coming down the line was a mixed bag of father still knows best and mea culpa (sort of) and it was, of course, too little much too late.

The memo once again shows just how much sole control Rumsfeld had in managing the war to the point where he would ignore his own commanders' pleas while trying to reassure the public, just like Bush, that the real military leaders on the ground were in charge. That Rumsfeld still thought that Americans had to or could be manipulated via the press in order to try to get them to believe that their military is actually winning in Iraq shows just how out of touch he was with the crushing reality in his country. The election showed that even Rumsfeld's propaganda couldn't save him on that front. Truth always wins out in the end. That's a lesson he never learned.

And the new Liberal party leader is...

Stephane Dion!!!



Total ballots cast: 4625
Spoiled ballots: 20
Total valid ballots: 4605
Total needed to win: 2304

Dion 54.7% 2521
Ignatieff 45.3% 2084

I had predicted Dion 58% Ignatieff 42% about an hour ago and have been hoping that either Dion or Rae would win all along. I'm grateful that the Liberals rejected Ignatieff and his right-wing beliefs since I have opposed his candidacy since day one.

Congratulations, Mr Dion.

Onward and upward from here.

Sidebar: A liitle blast from the past...

Layton's NDP convention speech from September, 2006: "[Dion is] distinct from his principal opponents in being a committed Canadian and a man of principle and conviction. And therefore almost certain not to be elected leader of the Liberal party."

Liberal Leadership Race: Third Ballot Results

And the winner is...

Total ballots cast: 4823
Spoiled ballots: 6
Total valid ballots: 4817
Needed to win: 2410

Dion 37.0% 1782
Ignatieff 34.5% 1660
Rae 28.5% 1375

Rae is off the ballot...he released his delegates and says he will now stay neutral.

I'm predicting a win for Dion.

Liberal Leadership Race: Second Ballot Results

Here they are:

Ignatieff 31.6% 1481
Rae 24.1% 1132
Dion 20.8% 974
Kennedy 18.8% 884
Dryden 4.7% 219

Now the interesting alliances form as they go through a third ballot.

Volpe went with Rae last nite. Earlier today Martha Hall Findlay, who was done after the first ballot, went over to Dion's team while Brison bowed out and went with Rae.

Dryden has now joined Bob Rae's team. Looks like Rae has the momentum...

Newsflash! At the very last minute Gerard Kennedy made his way over to the Dion camp and almost didn't end up there because he was being crushed by the media that surrounded him. He is now off the third ballot.

Don't forget: you can join me in the IRC chat which is going on til the bitter end...

irc.oftc.net
#canada

Friday, December 01, 2006

Liberal Leadership Race: First Ballot Results

Here they are:

Ignatieff 29.3%
Rae 20.3%
Dion 17.8%
Kennedy 17.7%
Dryden 4.9%
Brison 4.0%
Volpe 3.2%
Hall Findlay 2.7%

You can view the official results here on the Liberals website.

Handy list of Liberal ex officio delegates at wiki.

CTV has more including some news about the alliances forming along with this tidbit: 'There are rumours the Ignatieff camp will unveil a heavyweight endorsement on Saturday.'

Hmmm...Bush?

Write Your Own Caption

Volpe to Join Rae's Camp

According to the CPAC pundits and canada.com, Joe Volpe is going to join Bob Rae's camp this evening.

If you'd like to check out my play-by-play action as the speeches are being delivered, check out this post which also has info so you can join in on the live IRC chat which has been quite fun!

Update: Scott Brison (on CPAC) said he'll also be joining another candidate's run tonite but declared that he won't decide who he'll support until later this evening.

Liberal Leadership Convention: Live Chat/Speech Coverage

Via Scott at Progressive Bloggers, you're all welcome to join the live IRC chat at irc.oftc.net, channel #canada. If you use Firefox and have never tried using IRC before, just download Chatzilla, open it, type /server irc.oftc.net in the box and then /join #canada. There are also many other IRC clients available such as mIRC. Just find one, download it and come and join us. Scott is on the scene and is providing the inside scoop.

The candidates speeches are about to get underway as I write this. After one helluva long campaign, the race is finally getting exciting. I'll add updates as things move along.

My impressions of the candidates' speeches:

First up was Martha Hall Findlay: Great speech! Had her hair under control and she looked very prime-ministerial. Quote: 'We need brains, heart and guts and I have all three' (channeling the Wizard of Oz?). She also said that if she was elected as the leader of the party 'Stephen Harper wouldn't know what hit him'. Look for her as a possible future leader of the Liberal party because, unfortunately, she doesn't have the numbers to win this time. She's got the right (or left in this case) stuff. I forgot to add that she chose Bill & Hillary's choice of music: Fleetwood Mac's 'Don't Stop Thinking About Tomorrow'. Good choice!

Well, you can't exactly call Scott Brison Mr Excitement. That's not his style. His speech mainly focused on civil rights, social progress and the charter at the outset. Quote: 'Legacy is the child of purpose'. (I'll have to meditate on that one.) In the middle of his speech however, a sudden video montage appeared unexpectedly focusing on the environment which was quite the apocalyptic piece. (He should probably leave Al Gore to handle that issue.) Quote: 'If you believe that global warming is real, you're already ahead of Stephen Harper'. Brison then used the rest of his time to talk about environmental policy which is now, of course, the number one concern for Canadians.

Joe Volpe strode up to the podium to the tune of 'Life is a Highway' (no doubt paid for by child contributors) which played while a very long video was shown that had pics of Volpe with reps from every possible minority group he could find (not unlike Stephen Colbert's 'black friend' photo ops). Volpe then tried to give an empassioned speech beginning with his arrival to Canada as an immigrant but it took him a while to get to any actual issues and, even then, the rest of it was quite philosophical and emotional - in a Joe Volpe Mushy ™ kind of way. Face it: Joe loves himself and, as usual, his hair was almost perfectly coiffed. Too much "I, I, I and my, my, my'. Quote: 'Today, we're talking about leadership' (although he wasn't, really). He ended his speechifying with a 'Long live the Liberal party and long live Canada' moment where he damn near broke the podium because he pounded his fist on it so damn hard. Next...

Who doesn't like uncle Ken Dryden? Dryden's opening video highlighted his hockey career (of course). Quote: 'Like an army on ice we marched down south and returned every spring the conquerors.' He then went on to talk about some battle during the 1800s (?) and moved onto the 'Festival du Beouf' (?), another festival out in the west and morphed into an experience he had at a safe injection site in Vancouver. (The connection there escapes me). Standing in front of a 'Canada is Big" banner, I suppose he was trying to wax poetic on that but it was quite disjointed. Ken isn't a policy wonk, however. He's a philosophical teddy bear and, really, who doesn't love Ken? During the last bit of speech, he found that trademark Dryden Passion™ and the crowd roared (aided by one of those annoying hockey-type air horns). Quote: 'I'm not sure these Conservatives even like Canada'. (Amen). He then continued to pillory the Conservatives very effectively while talking about the differences between this crop of neocon-like Cons, the former PC party and liberal philosophy. Quote: 'This is a country, not an ideology'. This was probably one of the best speeches I've ever seen him give which he ended with 'I want my Canada back!' as his time ran out and the music began to play. Bravo, Ken!

Next up: Stephane Dion. Bolstered by a very noisy bunch of supporters, Dion got on stage (sans a video montage) and dug right into his speech. He started out by ripping Harper apart, calling Harper a 'control freak' and saying that Harper is so Bush-like that Bush should be getting royalties. (heh) His command of English was good (for those concerned about that issue), he was predicatbly passionate as he went on to speak about Canada's role in the world, focusing on 'the junction between the economy and the environment'. Quote: 'Yes, my fellow Liberals: the world needs Canada and, under my leadership, Canada will not fail the world.' Quote: 'The NDP do not understand the market economy and the Conservatives do not understand social justice'. Dion was also played off the stage by the music signalling that he'd gone overtime (not unlike the scene at the Academy Awards each year) but he gave a good, focused speech.

Gerard Kennedy's quick little video montage began with a swipe at how the pundits sometimes get things wrong with references to Trudeau and John A MacDonald. Justin Trudeau then introduced Kennedy whose theme music was 'Right Here, Right Now' (by Jesus Jones). He's chopped a considerable amount of his hair the past couple on months! Quote: 'I fought the 1999 election against the same bunch of neoconservatives that we now face in Ottawa'. Kennedy gave a very forceful, well-written speech that successfully covered virtually every policy issue of importance. Quote: 'I would be proud to be the first Liberal leader born and raised in western Canada' (he has a lot of support out here in Alberta). He spoke of his time working at a food bank out here and addressed poverty issues (more than the other candidates so far). Overall, it was a very solid, prime-ministerial sounding speech as well. Good job. I couldn't hear his French, so I can't judge if it's improved or not. One bright spot: he didn't get cut off at the end by the music.

Enter Bob Rae whose performance started off with a very muted type of video featuring endorsements from MPs and people who support him, along with a quick trip down memory lane - probably the best-produced video so far. Unlike the other candidates, Rae chose not to stand in front of a podium giving his speech a more 'heart to heart' feel. When he began speaking he referenced two quotes from 'the rabbi' about being there for everyone, not just himself (which may be viewed by some as pandering to the Jewish community). His speech was quite personal as he detailed his involvement in the restructuring of the Red Cross after the tainted blood scandal, his meeting with former PM Martin and 9/11 victims families and his work on the Air India file. Rae came across as being quite humbled by the opportunity to run for the leadership position and the confessional style of his speech addressed where he thinks he fits in the Liberal party. Quote: 'It's not about me. It's about us and it's about the country'. The vision he spoke about for Canada had to do with Canada's place in the world, focused on conflict resolution, along with addressing Canada's social problems, economic stability, the environment and referenced a strong future for Quebec. Rae's a very talented speaker who gave his speech without referring to notes or a teleprompter. Good job!


Michael Ignatieff had a video presentation that one IRC chatter said was almost as long as a feature film and may well be up for a Genie next year. He then left himself with about 10 minutes for speechifying and could it have been any more sleep-inducing?? It was one of the most boring speeches of the nite (next to Brison's) without any really memorable moments although he did say 'Let's win some seats in Alberta'. (Good luck with that!) His philospher king, weary, John Kerry-like style of speaking very slowly while trying to impart his so-called enormous wisdom on the crowd was a bit too laid back for such an energy-charged crowd (besides his die-hard supporters who chanted 'tous ensemble' and 'Canada' along with him at the designated times). Overall, definitely not the best speech of the nite. I expected more.

The Poor Person's Guide to Gift Giving

I wrote this post back in 2004 when I was still participating at Daily Kos as a response to a woman who was quite depressed about being poor at Christmas time while having a young son whom she wanted to provide at least some gifts for. Having faced that situation as a poor single parent when I raised my daughter, I felt I ought to share some creative ideas with her and anyone else out there who might need some help, hope and practical solutions.

So, here it is, in slightly edited form.

Why 'Christmas'?

I grew up Catholic, so Christmas is the holiday I'm most familiar with this time of year. I gave up Christianity as a teen and I am now a convert to Buddhism. However, I'll share my perspective as a child, a mother, and a grandmother on the difficulties so many of us experience dealing with the capitalistic pressures this time of year because the celebration of Christmas is the driving force behind this annual December madness. My appeal is to all of you to help me make this Christmas special for those who could use a positive boost and great ideas about gifts for the kids in their lives.

Why is Christmas important to me?

My beautiful daughter was born December 3, 1977. On December 23, I developed a viral infection and an extremely high fever. I was delusional and was hospitalized. I had already given up Christianity by that time but I did still celebrate "Xmas" with my family. I missed my first Xmas with my daughter. It was heartbreaking. I vowed then, no matter what, that we would always spend Christmas day together and that it would never be about presents - it would be about family. And that's the way it has been.

She has grown up knowing that the only present I ever wanted was to be with her on that day and she knows the importance of that for herself as well. Four years ago, my daughter and I went through a very difficult time in our relationship. I am ill and have been for many years now, but she had a difficult time accepting it. (It doesn't help when you have misunderstood conditions like lupus and fibromyalgia). As a result, she had rejected me for a while and we spent a Christmas apart. We were finally able to overcome our differences and reunited. She shared with me that her Christmas day without me just wasn't the same. She felt very empty. I did too. That day had been meaningless for me that year. So, it's not about Christmas per se. It's about the two of us celebrating the fact that we can be together after nearly being torn apart forever by that virus that had overtaken me the year of her birth. That's why Christmas is our special day. And now that tradition includes her mate and my grandherbs - one of which is celebrating his first Xmas this year.

Meet my father: the alcoholic dentist... or why traditions are vital

What do you think about when you remember Christmas as a child? I can recall perhaps 3 presents. One was an orange teddy bear that I so badly wanted in 1967. I still have him. I can't tell you how incredibly happy I was to find him under that ugly ass, silver tin-foil, 60s trendy tree we had. I also remember Baby Magic - a doll that came with a magnet that made her arms move up and down. Beyond that, one of my brothers, Mike the hippie, used to buy me Beatles' 45s so he could listen to them too. So much for the importance of presents.

What I recall in far more vivid detail are the traditions.

Christmas went like this:

* hang around with family Christmas eve drinking egg nog and eating treats
* go to Midnight mass
* come home and pig out on buffet food
* go to bed around 5 am
* get up later and open presents
* play with stuff
* eat turkey dinner

My mother, who tried to be Martha Stewart even before Martha Stewart was Martha Stewart, put out a fabulous spread for our buffet. We always had tourtiere (we're French Canadian), mincemeat tarts, shortbread cookies, little fancy finger sandwiches, chocolates, wine, french bread, various cold cuts, more cookies, devilled eggs and on and on.

Now my father, the alcoholic dentist who disappeared when I was 12, spent most of his money on booze. So, our family of 6 kids had to grow up knowing what thrifty meant. We never asked for much and we never got much as far as presents went, but we knew our traditions and that's what we looked forward to. Christmas celebrations were predictable and that's what we counted on. That schedule and all that went with it were important. All parents know the importance of consistency (some of us learned that the hard way), so I encourage all of you to define and celebrate your own traditions. That's what today's kids will remember as adults.

On to the presents...

(I'm long-winded. Sue me.) Okay, now it's time for gift ideas. I raised my daughter as a single parent from the time she was 2 months old. Dealing with poverty became a condition I knew well. And now, being ill and unable to work, in the same financial boat, I rely on lessons learned from my younger days.

Charities

If you're poor, the first step is to admit it. No, really. Many people tend to think they're not that poor. 'Those charities serve people who are a lot more poor than I am, even though I have no money', you may think. Well, stop thinking that way. Charities exist to help people like you and me. Put your ego in the drawer and make some phone calls. Even if it's a week before Christmas, it's not too late. Do it for your child and yourself. You deserve help and that's what they're there for. As they say, check your local listings. Call now. One of my most memorable Christmases was when my daughter and I were sponsored by a car dealership as part of the local adopt-a-family campaign. We were overwhelmed by their gifts, huge amounts of food, a tree, lights, and decorations. I cried for a long time and she was overwhelmed by the generosity.

Practical ideas requiring no money

Use what you already have.

* coupon book: I made one for my daughter when she was around 8 or 9. It included coupons for days off chores, pizza (when I could afford it later), lots of hugs and kisses, etc. She loved it. No computer back then. I did it by hand.
* photo collage: I made one for my granddaughter a few years back. Cut old photos in fun shapes. Paste on some special paper. Write the kid's name on it and maybe add some pic captions. Voila! Instant tribute.
* scrapbook: Same as a photo collage idea but in book form
* collage: My daughter does this as a hobby year round. Cut out interesting pics from magazines and make a collage. Easy and very creative.
* write a book: No, I'm not kidding. By hand or with the aid of a computer and printer, along with free clipart, write a little story book for your child.
* easy bath beads: If you have epsom salts, just mix them up with food colouring, put them in a container, and there you go.
* play dough: I always made this as a child. Plenty of recipes online.
* puppets: Make a puppet show. Use old cardboard for the theater. Spice it up with colour. Make puppets from old material. Put on a show.
* "why I love you" book: Write about the most important things about your child, things you've done together, places you've gone, favourite pets etc.
* travel diary: I made one of these for my granddaughter when she went on a road trip. Write in sections for things seen ie. animals, people etc. Leave room so they can paste in mementos. Throw in some riddles and jokes. You get the idea.
* knit, sew or crochet something There are tons of ideas online that are quick and easy. Use your scraps.
* give a book: Project Gutenberg has free, downloadable books. Print one out and fancy it up with your own title page. (Just don't sell it!)
* be artistic: Draw, paint, doodle a picture for your child.
* comic book/strip: Create a comic strip with your child as one of the characters.
* joke book: There are so many joke sites online. Why not use them?
* jewel something: Use old, broken jewellery to spice up something like a boring picture frame.
* build something: Got boxes? Build a big castle or house. Paint it up.
* easy art: Download and print a pic you like and frame it.
* paper mache: Make a mask or a dish. The possibilities are endless.
* tea party: Set up a tea party with your fancy dishes on Christmas day.
* wrapping paper: Use the cartoon section of your newspaper. Brown bags and old material and pillowcases can be stamped with a potato cut with a design dipped in paint or even rubbed with ink from a pen. Old wallpaper works well too.
* tree: Check with your local tree lot to see if they have branches they're discarding. Make your own tree.
* decorations: Make a popcorn chain like we did in the old days. Cut out pics from old Christmas cards or online clipart, add string and hang. Challenge your kids to make the decorations.
* miscellaneous: join an online group like Freecycle. Last year I gave away some old coins to a mother who was putting together a collection for her son and I also got my tree through my local group. It's a great resource all year round.

Well, that's a start. Most importantly, give yourself as a gift. Do something out of character on Christmas day: dance, sing, have a pillow fight, be silly, make a snowman, stand on your head, run around outside, go out and enjoy the lights and decorations in the neighbourhood (my daughter still enjoys being the bad Xmas lights police). Be happy! Fake it if you have to. Be a kid again. Your kid will love you for it.

One Last Thing...

Teach your child to give. Let them experience the true joy and humility that comes with giving something to others. One year, I packed up old clothes and my daughter surrendered some old toys which we took to the Women's Shelter. That meant something to her (and me, of course). There's always someone in the world who is in need. Do what you can when you're able to and you'll always feel much better about yourself and your situation.

Feel free to share your ideas in the comments. You never know who you may help as a result.

Have a great holiday season! If I can do it, you can too.