have your cake and eat it ♥
So the recent discourse on one girl's comments "Singaporeans are weak? LOL" has sparked a flurry of outcry from a series of past and serving NSFs, NSmen and of course, not forgetting, selected women of the country.
I just finished reading a (fairly) long note by the OC of the NSF's sister platoon. To be honest, and hopefully fair, it is hard for a person who has not served to comment on the journey of NS. It is hard because first and foremost, the instinctive reaction is "you have not been through it, who are you to talk". It is hard because few girls can make a fair judgment as well, and even if they do, they fall under the judgment of the men who have served and more often than not, their opinions count for less.
Boys, men: you serve two years of your life for this country, it would be nice to have some gratitude in return. Yes, it would be nice to not be met with unappreciation. That is fair. But the reality is that there are things you do, and have to do, that don't give you the recognition you think you should get, be it here, in work, or in life. I'm not saying the men of our country beg for recognition. I'm saying it should be given, their service should be appreciated, but the reality of the situation is that often it isn't enough. But appreciation cannot be forced and the real test I guess, to me, probably is- can you live with that? That there is resilience, if you can do something that you might not want to do, you do it well, and not get recognition for it and be okay with it. Not a test for NSFs or NSmen, but a test for life. We don't always get what we want. Truth. Sometimes you just gotta live with what you can get.
Girls, women: Sure, that two years is met with a slightly higher starting pay. But face it, it doesn't happen in all sectors. Be fair. Few of you would want to serve two years if you had a choice. Its about two years of your life you will not get back. You're not in a really good position to speak about something you have not gone through, unless you can mellow it down and be partial about it. I think a lot more could be done when it comes to showing (yes, even if it has to come down to a matter of 'show') more appreciation.
But to the general public, it seems to be a simple situation. I doubt she meant what she said seriously. You know people shoot themselves in the foot every now and then. Is she representative of the general population? We don't really know. Benefit of the doubt then. From the previous generation, our army's training is different. With technology, the training has changed. Some could argue it has gone softer from previous days. Does that make Singaporeans weak?
What I do see however, is not an issue of whether our soldiers are weak, nor do we need people to step forth and defend them. The truth is that the definition of "guys" has changed. She is entitled to her view that Singaporeans are weak. And we probably are, in comparison to the previous generations. But "weak" is ultimately subjective.
What I do see however, is not an issue of whether our soldiers are weak, nor do we need people to step forth and defend them. The truth is that the definition of "guys" has changed. She is entitled to her view that Singaporeans are weak. And we probably are, in comparison to the previous generations. But "weak" is ultimately subjective.
That (in no disrepect to the OC or anyone), whoever comments never truly has a view of the entire population of NSFs/NSmen, or a view of all Singaporeans. It isn't fair to say Singaporeans who serve are weak, nor is it fair to say they are not based on what you have seen. There will always be extremes and we should not be blowing this entire thing up and judging both ends of the population based on one incident and one comment (that may, or may not have been intended). As much as there will always be haters, there will also always be those who appreciate.
At the end of this whole thing, I really do think everyone needs to take a step back. The ultimate disclaimer I will make is that this is in the end my personal view, and perhaps I'm not qualified either to take a stand like this. That, is for you to judge. But at the end of the day, what we do need to remember is that there is a time and place for words and war. She may have made an error in judgment when she chose to make that comment in light of the events. But now is not the time to condemn her for her mistakes, nor bring the population of Singapore into an uproar over which gender has it worse, or what should or should not be done.
What we need to remember is that accidents happen. It could happen any day, any time, to any one of us. It does not make things easier for the family or friends of the deceased that people pass hurtful comments that people respond to and take everyone away from the crux of the incident, that because of an accident, someone has passed.
It means that in this event, we take a moment to forget our differences in opinion, because everyone is entitled to it (and we should know the time and place to voice or not voice it out). I personally feel that the online war of the words, the public voicing of opinion - and yes, perhaps I have fallen into this trap- just isn't in the right time.
Forget the opinions that could surface regarding the comment. Forget your differences because they'll always be there. But remember a man who passed due to an unfortunate event. Remember his family and friends who are still here, and who bear his loss on their shoulders. Remember that whatever you say could possibly hurt the loved ones of a man they just lost. Would you leave the memory of a man who was willing to give his life for his loved ones tainted by the lasting echoes of disagreement and personal retort after retort? Your differences can wait.
Knowing when to draw a sword and defend your men, your honour, your pride and reputation - and knowing when to hold back- that is strength in itself too.
At the end of this whole thing, I really do think everyone needs to take a step back. The ultimate disclaimer I will make is that this is in the end my personal view, and perhaps I'm not qualified either to take a stand like this. That, is for you to judge. But at the end of the day, what we do need to remember is that there is a time and place for words and war. She may have made an error in judgment when she chose to make that comment in light of the events. But now is not the time to condemn her for her mistakes, nor bring the population of Singapore into an uproar over which gender has it worse, or what should or should not be done.
What we need to remember is that accidents happen. It could happen any day, any time, to any one of us. It does not make things easier for the family or friends of the deceased that people pass hurtful comments that people respond to and take everyone away from the crux of the incident, that because of an accident, someone has passed.
It means that in this event, we take a moment to forget our differences in opinion, because everyone is entitled to it (and we should know the time and place to voice or not voice it out). I personally feel that the online war of the words, the public voicing of opinion - and yes, perhaps I have fallen into this trap- just isn't in the right time.
Forget the opinions that could surface regarding the comment. Forget your differences because they'll always be there. But remember a man who passed due to an unfortunate event. Remember his family and friends who are still here, and who bear his loss on their shoulders. Remember that whatever you say could possibly hurt the loved ones of a man they just lost. Would you leave the memory of a man who was willing to give his life for his loved ones tainted by the lasting echoes of disagreement and personal retort after retort? Your differences can wait.
Knowing when to draw a sword and defend your men, your honour, your pride and reputation - and knowing when to hold back- that is strength in itself too.






