I couldn't possibly venture out to take pictures today. We have a
daytime temperature of zero degrees, yes, 0 degrees Fahrenheit today, plus windchill factor down to -25F.
I know
Lene can walk three miles in this weather, but not me!
If Saturdays aren’t good for skies, then they are good for book reviews. Finally, yes, finally, the long awaited order from Borders.com cum Amazon arrived. I placed it on December 29th, and it arrived on January 18th. Talk about same day shipping!!!!
Before I launch into the shipping fiasco, here is a review of the books and the condition in which they arrived. They’re scrumptious, aren’t they?

Stitchionary One has a lovely cover design, and I am a sucker for green, so that’s probably why I was interested in the knit ~ purl stitchionary. I was mainly interested in the Barbara Walker Treasuries, but they are $30 (U.S. $) each, and the Vogue books were on sale online, 30% off. So I figured I could wait a bit more for the Walkers. I’ve put off buying them for over 11 years now anyway.
Volume One (knit ~ purl) though, isn’t what it’s cracked up to be. Sure, there are almost 200 pages of lovely patterns, but come on, we’ve seen these patterns, herringbone, basketweave, moss stitch, seed stitch, etc. Nothing, and I mean NOTHING, new.
Now here is the another issue, check out the wasted space:

Mind you, not every page is wasting space, but enough pages are, so why not give us some more patterns and swatches? Wasn’t that the goal of this set, to sort of update the Walker books in color and more legible font and in high gloss large format? Or did someone just get tired of swatching?
If you are going to waste space, then why not move the image over a bit and spread things out? Why jam image and text onto one side of the page?
As if this isn’t enough, there aren’t any charts. WHAT? No charts?
No, no charts. Just a bunch of text. And some of the text directions are about one page long for one repeat. COME ON!!!!! Is this 1972? Remember McCalls and Women’s Day knitting directions? Laughable. More accurately, cryable.
Volume Three (colorwork) is marginally better. Granted someone figured out we need/want charts, and some interesting designs are included, but some are so simplistic, and others so UGLY, that I have to shake my head and shudder.
See what I mean:

Okay, sorry to offend those who may like colorized cables, but I am not one who does.
What might be important to know is the books aren't carried in the bookstores around here, so it was practically buyer beware ~ sight unseen and all that. Before seeing these books, I had already decided that it was likely nothing could beat Alice Starmore’s Aran Knitting and HT cable books, and I have several, so I opted not to bother with Volume Two (cables). I feel completely vindicated by that call! I can just imagine the patterns: 2 st cable, 3 st cable, 4 st cable, 5 st cable, 6 st cable, and a few other every day, regular old cable stitches.
Alright, I’m still not finished. Look at the condition the books are in:

It’s hard to see in the photo, but the corner above is actually split down to the cardboard guts of the cover. How long do you think this will remain intact pulling it on and off the bookshelf or, heaven forbid, if I put it in a knitting tote?
The other:

This after waiting over three weeks for these books to arrive!!!!
Stick with the original Vogue Knitting:

(Mine was published in 1999 and cost $35 U.S.) This book is superb! It not only contains a stitchionary with charts and better swatches:

but it also contains superb chapters on issues such as basic techniques, understanding knitting instructions (how-to read charts, how-to understand symbols, how-to reconcile written directions with charts, etc.), how-to correct errors, blocking, assembling, and finishing, care for knit garments, designing, and a whole slew of other very useful info:

Now granted when I bought this book I worked at a bookstore, and when it was unpacked from the day's shipment of books, I carefully covered it with BrodArt to protect the dust jacket, and didn't bother putting it on the shelf because I bought it lickety-split that day. But books that are shipped to the stores are shipped in boxes 1' high x 2' wide x 3' long, so the boxes do contain several books and bunches of Styrofoam peanuts, and the boxes do travel some distance, even though in those days the shipping warehouse was within 50 miles of our store. (I worked at the second Borders Books Shop to open. The first Borders Books is in Ann Arbor.) Sometimes better care is taken of books that are shipped to stores ~ that's all I'm saying.