
The Amazing Spider-Man: The Ultimate Newspaper Comics Collection Volume 2 (1979-1981), by Stan Lee and John Romita (with Larry Leiber)No month stated, 2015 IDW Publishing
I was happy to discover this big hardcover collection of vintage
Spider-Man newspaper strips. I enjoyed it a lot more than I thought I would, perhaps because it was so refreshing after the decade-plus of too cool (and, lately,
too woke) Marvel Studios franchise, which has
zero in the way of the geeky charm of the actual comics that inspired the movies.
Perhaps that sentence didn’t make sense. If not, I don’t care. What I mean to say is, I was a comic geek when being a comic geek wasn’t cool. Indeed, I remember the days when you had to hide the fact that you read comic books from others, especially girls, lest you be ridiculed as a loser of the lowest order. It’s hard to believe, folks, but once upon a time you couldn’t buy about a zillion comic character t-shirts at Wal-Mart, or see people wearing comic character t-shirts at the office. There was a time when the average teenaged girl (the pretty ones, at least) had no idea what Spider-Man’s secret identity was, and for that matter they couldn’t have cared less.
All those days are gone, and likely forgotten, and no doubt have been gone and forgotten for quite a while. I remember being in Miami in 2007 for a vacation or something, and we went to the mall, and at the bookstore I was floored to see a bunch of teenaged girls sitting there reading comic books. And they weren’t ugly girls either. (Not that I was checking them out, honestly I wasn’t: I’m just noting for clarity.) It was literally one of those times where I looked up at the sky and shook my head: “Thanks again, God.”
This was before the Marvel Studio franchise even got rolling, and of course now we live in a world where these characters are more popular than ever…but, then, it’s the movie versions people now know. It’s debatable how well these fans of today know the actual original comic versions of the characters. It’s debatable that any of these modern fans know the geeky charm of Silver Age comic books, when the world of Marvel was a secret one that losers and geeks and nerds would escape to and dream about how they, too, could be just like Spider-Man or the Hulk or whoever.
But then, there’s an entire generation that thinks Mary Jane Watson is a flat-chested, curly-haired, overly sarcastic girl of indeterminite race (and, perhaps, gender). They have no idea that Mary Jane Watson is supposed to fucking look like this:
That’s another thing I liked so much about this book: it was also refreshing to see such unbridled and wonderful “toxic masculinity” in a product that was produced for the masses. It’s also hard to recall that there was a time when popular fiction and comics and movies were produced with a straight male audience in mind, and the male gaze was not subverted, but was catered to. Yes, it does seem like a million years ago, doesn’t it?
Speaking of “a helluva long time ago,” I guess I mainly got into comics due to my childhood obsession with Spider-Man. I was such a Spider-Man fan that I even had a themed party, for my fifth birthday:

This party was likely on my actual fifth birthday – October 6, 1979 – as according to Google, October 6 was on a Saturday in 1979. But anyway, that’s obviously me standing in front of the Spider-Man cake in the first photo; I have no recollection of the names of any of the other kids at the party, save for the blonde-haired girl I smugly have my arm around in the second photo. (Don’t hate the player, hate the game!) Her name was Julie Bowen (not the actress!), and her mom was also a teacher, and in the years before we started school Julie and I were both watched by an old couple named Mr. and Mrs. Crohn (who, so far as I am aware, did not have Crohn’s Disease!). Julie moved away when we were in the Fourth Grade, I seem to recall…I also recall seeing Happy Gilmore in the theater in 1996, and when the name “Julie Bowen” came up in the credits I was like, “Could it be?” It wasn’t that Julie Bowen, of course, but the movie was great! In fact my brother (the older kid who is so unhappily holding my Spider-Man birthday cake in the above photo) liked that movie so much he’d rent the video every week or something at Blockbuster. Not sure why he didn’t just buy a copy.
Well anyhoo, I go into this belabored backstory so as to set the scenery that I was a rabid Spider-Man fan as a kid…and, sometime around the late ‘70s, maybe in this same year of 1979, we took a family vacation to Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. This is where practically the entire East Coast vacationed in the ‘70s. When we were down there, my dad got the local newspaper…and I was shaken to my core to discover that there was a Spider-Man comic strip!
There was no such strip in the newspaper back home. And yet, this one and only encounter with the newspaper version of Spider-Man made enough of an impression on me that I still recalled it, all these decades later…and, when I saw that some of these strips had been collected in hardcover, I dutifully ordered a copy from Interlibrary Loan. (Hey, it’s not like I’m going to shell out a couple hundred bucks for a copy! I mean, that’s hooker money!)
Collecting three years of strips, the book is certainly hefty, running to 315 pages. Stan “The Man” Lee handles all the writing, and does his usual fine job, and John Romita (back before he was “John Romita Sr.”) handles the artwork, which is great throughout. Toward the very end of the book, Romita steps out and Larry Leiber (aka Stan Lee’s younger brother) takes over, and truth be told his art is so similar to Romita’s that you might not even notice the change. That said, there’s certainly more sex appeal in Romita’s work – if he isn’t sexing up MJ or Carole (another of Peter Parker’s conquests in the book), he dutifully inserts some random sexy chick in a panel:




What’s cool about this newspaper strip is that it caters to the established Marvel mythos, but puts a bit more of a “mainstream” spin on it. As with the films of the 2000s, Spider-Man is the only superhero (at least in New York), he’s wanted by the cops, and the cast of villainous characters is much whittled down from the comic books. Peter Parker, in college in these strips, is no longer the nerd of the Lee-Ditko originals, and in fact does pretty well for himself with the ladies…perhaps the biggest change to accommodate the broader (and no doubt male-slanting) newspaper readership.
In fact, I was somewhat surprised that Lee and Romita often let us know, in no unsubtle terms, that Peter Parker has gotten laid:
I mean, “help me bone up?” Stan the Man! Sure, that’s what students said when they were trying to study (or at least they said it in the 1950s), but still…you don’t have to be a total sleazebag to assume there’s some serious hanky-panky occurring between those panels.
Granted, Peter Parker’s still the sad sack of the comics, where nothing works out perfectly for him, or he’s caught in some
Three’s Company-esque miscommunication, or whatever. But he’s a lot more sure of himself with the women…and, in the hands of John Romita, these women are
smoking. In fact, I kind of wanted to reach into the comics and punch Peter Parker, because he’s constantly
running away from these women, even when they’re in the process of giving themselves to him. Time and again in these collected strips, Carole or MJ will make an advancement on Peter, and he’ll either have to run off because he’s seen some crook in action, or he’s riddled with some soul-searching over if he wants to keep being Spider-Man or some other shit. As for the former, it’s kind of laughable – but again refreshing – how Peter is so quick to jump into the fray when he sees bankrobbers, or muggers, or whatever; yes, altogether refreshing to see someone so selflessly ensuring law and order in our postmodern era of “
fiery but mostly peaceful protests.”
But at the same time, even here I was constantly pulled out of the action…thinking of stuff I never would’ve thought of as a five year-old. Like, Peter Parker apparently wears his Spidey suit under his clothes…and he’s always in pants and a long-sleeved shirt and a coat…even in the stories that are set in the summer! I mean, with a Spidey suit beneath all that? The dude must be broiling. That enough would make me quit the whole super-hero game, which Peter attempts to do in a few stories collected here, with predictable results.
“Predictable” sums up many of the plots here…but you know what? That’s just fine. Stan Lee tells a story the way only Stan Lee can, that corny but earnest and altogether endearing style that is Stan Lee’s alone, and never once did I find any of it hackneyed. Okay, maybe the final story collected here tried my patience, where Peter Parker decides that Spider-Man himself will become a criminal, to finally get a taste of success…and predictably fails in the process. It’s a fine setup, but lamely delivered; Spidey steals a jewel, then tries to sell it to a diamond dealer (who turns out to be a gangster), and then Spidey has to figure out how to get the diamond back into the museum.
Other than that latter gaffe, the other stories here are all fun, and kept my attention more than I thought they would. To be honest, I thought I’d just peruse the book and return it to the library, but I read the whole thing! There is not much variety to the format of the strips, which I think works for it and against it at the same time. For it, because it essentially becomes the comics version of what fat people call “comfort food:” the Monday-Saturday strips run three panels each, and are black and white, and the Sunday strips are full color, and generally run six panels. Only occasionally does this change.
There’s also a lot of stalling. Forever in the 315 pages of this book we’ll have Peter Parker decide to do something…then a few pages later he’s recapping what he plans to do…a few pages after that he’s gonna do it, by God…and then a few pages after that he might get around to doing it. This does admittedly become wearisome after a while, but then I read the book over the course of a few days. I bet if you took your time with it, and read maybe an arc at a time, it might not be as egregious.
As for the story arcs, there are a bunch of them: Spidey framed by a lookalike Spider-Man (courtesy the Kingpin); the Loomis Love Cult (a Jim Jones commentary piece that seems to go on forever, but is probably the darkest story in the collection); the Prowler (a guy who wants to make a name for himself as a clawed supervillain but has a heart of gold): Kraven the Hunter (who inexplicably tries to fool people that Spider-Man is an alien so that he can fight Spidey on TV and beat him); the return of the Loomis cult (even more annoying without their boss); the return of the Kingpin (not as fun as the first time); and even a guy in a hat who wields a whip and tries to lean on Aunt May (and also hits on MJ).
Between all this we have soap opera stories where Peter Parker questions his sanity, or if he wants to still be Spider-Man, or if he should tell Carol Jennings that he’s Spider-Man because he loves her and wants to marry her(!), or if he should commit to MJ, or if he should go bad and reap the profits as a villain himself. Or even if he should go on a That’s Incredible! type show to make a thousand bucks.
I had forgotten how funny Stan Lee is. Throughout the book his tongue is firmly in cheek, but there’s none of the postmodern, too-hip sarcasm of today; you can tell Stan believes in his creation (as well he should), and he treats everything with respect. Peter Parker is so earnest that you have to respect him, even though he generally brings most of his problems on himself…sort of like fellow newspaper strip protagonist Charlie Brown, now that I think of it.
And speaking of topical references, the book is filled with it: the late ‘70s aren’t as exploited as I’d like, but all the guys wear open-collar shirts, have big hair, and the girls all wear revealing, cleavage-baring tops, and they go to a roller disco at times (though this isn’t brought much to life, either). John Romita takes a lot of relish in putting famous faces in the backgrounds of various panels, like this particular Sunday story, which among many others even features a cameo by my man Johnny Carson:

I like it that the Spider-Man newspaper strip lives in its own continuity; Stan Lee and John Romita did a great job bringing the geeky comics to a more widespread audience, playing up the melodrama a little more than in the comics, and toning down on the costumed super-battles. Otherwise everyone’s mostly the same: Spidey himself is a motor-mouth, either expositing what he’s doing as he does it or tossing one-liners at villains as he fights them – and again, Stan Lee’s humor shines here. MJ is a flirty bombshell, J. Jonah Jameson is a Spidey-obsessed villain (he clearly has Spidey Derangement Syndrome), and all the villains have unique personalities. Only Carole Jennings, the other bombshell in Peter’s life, is lame…personality-wise, at least. Romita is sure to draw her in such a jawdropping manner that you figure poor Peter Parker must be in a permanent lust-filled daze when he’s around her:

IDW has reprinted the Spider-Man newspaper comics through the ‘80s, and I think I might check them out sometime – particularly the first volume, as I’m hoping it would be even more ‘70s-tastic.