Perfect Cupcake Frosting
by ourbestbites.com
I will do the conversions for you to make it easier. I usually make the last one.
For filling 24 cupcakes only or frosting big tops on 12 cupcakes:
3 T all purpose flour
1/2 c. milk (whole milk is best but I have used skim and been fine)
1/2 c. real quality butter (***Land O Lakes always works best for me)
1/2 c. granulated (not powdered) sugar
1 t. vanilla, or any other flavoring you want
For frosting big tops on 24 cupcakes:
6 T. flour (1/4 c. + 2 T.)
1 c. milk
1 c. butter (2 sticks)
1 c. sugar
2 t. vanilla
For frosting big tops on 24 cupcakes PLUS filling each one with frosting:
9 T. flour (1/2 c + 1 T.)
1 1/2 c. milk
1 1/2 c. butter (3 sticks)
1 1/2 c. sugar
1 T. vanilla (sometimes I do 2 1/2 t vanilla + 1/2 t. almond extract)
Put your flour and milk in a sauce pan - I use a large flatish one that has more surface area to heat up. It makes this step go super quick. Whisk together before turning on heat. Then turn heat about to medium. Whisk continuously and it will start to thicken. This is crucial that you cook the flour enough! I keep slowly whisking (scraping the pan) until it is the consistency of nice smooth thick vanilla pudding. Then let it cool to room temp. (I let it rest on a cool burner for a few minutes then stick it in the fridge, because who wants to wait!) It needs to be cooled completely or it will kill the butter.
While it is cooling, beat the butter and sugar in a mixer with the whisk attachement, scraping sides if needed, for about 2-3 minutes until it is well combined and fluffy. Then it usually sits there until the flour/milk mixture is cooled.
Add the flour mixture to the butter mixture, along with your vanilla. Here is the magic - beat on the highest speed you can without stuff flying out--- for like 8 minutes. It is long, but oh so worth it. After 8 minutes, the goopy mess you started with turns into velvety fluffy frosting. Stir in food coloring if you wish.
*** Important tips:
1) For some reason this frosting only works with high quality butter. NOT even Costco butter. It stays lumpy and weird. I always use Land o Lakes. Good butter is totally worth the extra dollar anyway.
2) If you beat if for 8 min and it still looks strange, try to go a minute or two longer and on a higher speed if you can. This takes a little patience!
3) Store at room temperature in a sealed container. It may separate in fridge. (I did it once and it was fine though.) Can be made a day ahead and left at room temp in well sealed container, and will still come out looking great next day.