Articles:
http://www.sinchew.com.my/content.phtml?sec=9&artid=200510020728http://www.zaobao.com/yl/yl051109_502.htmlhttp://www.zaobao.com/yl/yl051109_506.htmlthis article has a more accurate and balanced view
香港人壞、台灣人可愛、中國人不可測、新加坡人笨
香港人無情,台灣人無恥,新加坡人無知
虽非人人如此,但天天忙碌的人,
有大条理由只关注眼前及身边而不愿再关心其他。
知识层面欠缺广度和深度,
殊不知深度与广度的知识在融会贯通后往往才是解答人生的参照。
Are Singaporeans stupid?
What a simple yet revealing question. The recent hoo-ra on this question indirectly brought about by李敖 is not something new. Besides, to many other Chinese in the world, this is not a question. It is a commonly acknowledged statement for long. A statement that is as accurate as the statement that Singapore is a prosperous city.
Personally i find that this statement is not without ground. Among my singaporean friends, there are very few (and among these few, most are female) who do read and keep abreast with, and reflect on, social and world issues. Few venture beyond reading academic notes, personal blogs, jokes and lame stories. It is very worrisome, considering that i am in one of the top school, and the people around me are gonna be the leaders of the future, in one way or another. So much about "teach less, learn more", but what is the "more" that needs to be learned in this society? skillglobalisationentrepreneurshipupgradehubhubhubknowledgeITskillknowdledge?
no wonder my friend told me that most of the intellectuals are in humanities stream. science students think much less, but practice more on drawing alpha helix structure and full displayed formula of cellulose (sorry, i have a particular dislike for biochem).
Well, what i said above is mainly the stereotype. a stereotype is, after all, only a stereotype, albeit a prevailing one for this case. Besides, Singaporean youth is not alone in this lack of intellectualism and general apathy in social issues. Malaysia does not have enough critical thinkers too. Even though i personally feel that Malaysian youths are more in touch with social issues (it is true!), not many think the right way. Racial prejudice is a major hindrence if we are to progess as a nation. But generally, a large proportion of my malaysian friends are able to engage in political and social discourse and most generally form their own opinions (whether skewed or not). You might argue that this is because i rub shoulders with elites from my country since most are scholars. But hc is supposed to be a school full of elites, leaders of tomorrow for singapore, yet few students in this school are intellectually aware and curious. This is not hard to see even at another end of the Earth. In Stanford U, there is an active malaysian group who form the Standard Malaysian Forum, for which Malaysian civil servants are invited to give a speech to the Malaysian students in Stanford. Sadly, its Singaporean counterpart has no similar activity
Perhaps because there is no govt ministries to spearhead such activity? maybe this is another sideeffect of having a paternalistic govt. s'poreans are fortunate to have a gd govt who is willing to lead and spearhead in all directions. Youth Changemaker (YCM), eg, is supported and sanctioned by MCYS. (i'm not too sure whether it is initiated by MCYS or by active youths tho.) In Malaysia, such initiatives and other social organisations do exist, but they are mostly self-funded and not overseen by any governmental authority. perhaps it is this difference in the way the 2 countries run that leads to the disparity in the social awareness and attitude btw the youths at the 2 ends of the Causeway.
Another difference is in the kind of topics that youths talk about daily. other than jokes, my msian frens and I do exchange views on social, world, philosophical issues. the conversation among the guys in my class mostly revolves around lame jokes, girls, dota, and schoolworks. Behind the ephemeral laughters and fun, there is nothing much for us to take home and think about it. Men's talks are sorely dull and bland, which involves asking the same old questions over and over again. Among us guys, the number of pple who do read (other than notes and New Paper and newspaper) can be counted by less than half a finger. maybe we can attribute this to different lifestyles and different choices they make in their lives. but i am afraid some of them do not even realise this concern, and the significance of this concern.
maybe they are just not exposed enough to an intellectual envt as most are too caught up in daily life and A lvl. Or maybe they find no cause for them to be active intellectually, since life in s'pore for most is so well air-conditioned that it does not provide a fertile ground for intellectual debates and thinking for most ordinary people. sheryl once told me that she was impressed by the participants from other ASEAN countries for an ASEAN youth forum she took part in. the depth and breadth of social knowledge that they possess, and the kind of patriotism that radiates from them, is rarely seen in s'porean youths today. the difference may lie in the fact that these countries are more tumultuous, and the youths have a cause to be more concerned
. does that mean that s'porean youths, living in a blessed world, should not and need not be concerned about the world outside their own?
but is it not sad that a person lives in a society, yet being unaware of and uninterested in its development? where is the passion for the society then? or does it not matter to some people? living in their own happy world is blissful and meaningful enough a life for them? well, everyone has different takes in life...different people find meaning in different things..
all in all i would say that general singaporean youths are more ignorant and unexposed than stupid. they are not heartless, they are not snobbish, they are not stupid. juz that they are not immersed in an intellectual envt. personally i find the atmosphere for arts here pathetic too as a lot of students were too busy mugging tutorials during breaks to tour around the inner plaza and admire some decent art works from their peers.
i think that my arguments above might not be comprehensive and balanced enough, and may attract some backlashes from my s'porean friends.
we should fear no criticism/comment, but the lack of it.
Do comment on it, and let me hear your views. If you have one, that is.
let me end this entry by a quote that resonates in my heart:
平生只有两行泪, 半为苍生半美人.