I've read a few reports, and it has come to my realisation that depending on what type of die-hard fan you are, you'll react very differently to AC.
Scenario 1: Die-hard fan type AGenerally, these fans begin first with expressing their disappointment after watching AC. They've always had high expectations of FFVII and thus AC as well, and waste no time pointing out all the flaws they've spotted. Which accounts to, in the end, a lot of stuff.
Severe disappointment for these guys.
Scenario 2: Die-hard fans type B These are mainly the people SE hs been targetting at, and sing AC's praises. They are also die-hard fans, but are already satisfied with what they got. They are mostly able to pick out the underlying themes and seem to like the ideas.
See Daniel's reviews:
General and
SpoilerificScenario 3: movie-viewer CThey have a good idea about the FF world, and have a certain amount of experience in dealing with video games and such. They normally see both sides to AC, but, well, can get a bit annoying -yet amusing- at times.
You may read
this to get a better idea of what I'm talking about.
Scenario 4: neutral movie-viewerSimple. They go "WTF?!"
Scenario 5: normal fan of FFVIITypically can lean over to any side, or may be undecided in the end.
Scenario 6: non-fan of FFVIII've seen cases where people who've played FFVII and didn't like it didn't like AC either. Of course there were logical explanations behind everything. Yeah. Sadly so.
But logical in their sense does not necessarility equate to logical in our sense.
--- - ---
You know, I actually felt a little disappointed in AC right after I watched it because there were so many things I had wanted to see but did not.
I had expected more flashbacks, but then there weren't many. There were too may fight scenes, IMO. And another thing is that I think we've all been spoiled by the magazine scans and trailers in recent days, that most of it is nothing new.
There were a few ideas that you just had to get used to, which took some time. Of course, there seems to be some loopholes in the plot.
Nevertheless, I'm rather satisfied with what I got because unlike FFVII, there is a major limitation, which is the time constraint. You have only 100 minutes to tell a story. Naturally, many things get left out or simplified. I'm also glad that SE left AC open-ended. No, we didn't see Cloud and Tifa getting married, though I know people who would have loved that to happen. Whatever became of Aeris, Zack and the SHM are also up to speculation, if you really want to. And till now, I'm not sure where's Seph still. The end of AC seemed even less conclusive than the end of FFVII.
Well, AC may be fanservice, if you want to put it that way, but at least it's impactful fanservice. I haven't seem LO, but from what I've heard, LO is just pure fanservice, much more than AC.
The part I found I love about AC are its themes. Sure some people find it amateurish, but I thought that there were a whole lot behind the SHM. I actually think that the focus isn't really on "Redemption". There's plenty more on relationships... or the lack of them.
AC is a short story, but in comparison to TSW, I think its better because we've already have the basic idea of FFVII. Everything just continues on from there. TSW lacked the basis. People didn't know what that world was like, and thus there were plenty of shortcomings. It had less chances of development because they had to convince the audience to take that entire version of Gaia in, and to accept it. By the time you did, however, it ended.
In the end, AC cannot be compared on the same plane as FFVII. It's not a fair comparison. In fact, we should see them as two different things with some connection, but surely AC is not as well-developed as FFVII, despite being just about as large a project. SE just doesn't have the ample experience in this area.
As for music wise, I did expect so many old songs to make an appearance again, but it's quite to my liking. Come on, it's not
that sappy. I have a distaste for sappy stuff, but since I like the newer version of the songs, my sap-o-meter says it's not.
So there.
By the way, someting funny's going on with the recent FF:AC FAQ. Machine translations are the best/worst! (depending on how serious you are) You'd never think Aerith=air squirrel. lmao.
Besides, I've found a couple of pics of Cloud's swords in AC, which clears things up a bit. One of them can be found
here. Sheesh... who are these hardworking people.