Hawaii or the Caribbean?
It's a question I'm often asked.
I've always found that question very interesting. Interesting because The Caribbean, a grouping of several hundred islands, countries, cuisines and cultures is being compared Hawaii- a chain of 8 islands (+a few islets).
It doesn't quite compute to me. And I always return the question with one of my own: Which Caribbean island?
Usually my question is answered with a blank stare, or a hastily gathered response with an obvious choice like Jamaica, or St. Thomas, or The Virgin Islands.
My honest opinion on those choices:
Jamaica or Hawaii: Hawaii. I'm NOT a Jamaica fan. Sorry if you're a Jamaica fan, but I usually call it "A dirty hole." Take into consideration that I live in California. To get to Hawaii would take one five-hour flight. Getting to Jamaica would mean at least two flights and 10+ hours in the air. And a lot more money. NOT WORTH IT.
St. Thomas or Hawaii: Hawaii
For about the same reasons as Jamaica. St. Thomas isn't quite "A Dirty Hole." But it's darned close. And it's dangerous. Be very, very careful in St. Thomas.
The Virgin Islands or Hawaii: The BRITISH Virgin Islands. Hands down. Jump on a sailboat and go and see why. I plan to.
You see, I'm picky. I'd pick Hawaii only if my other options weren't more tempting.
There is one acceptable time for comparing Hawaii to the Caribbe, and that is when describing the attitudes found in the islands.
Hawaii, to me is beautiful, tropical, fun, sunny... but something is missing for me: The Caribbean spirit, if you will. Aloha spirit is, of course, warm and welcoming, but it's just not the same.
I've thought long and hard about this conundrum. I mean, you'd think that one gorgeous, jungle-clad, azure water island chain would be comparable to another? Wrong. Wrong. Wrong. Wrong WRONG.
I could make a detailed grid of all the pros and cons between the two "places" but for me, the difference is simply this:
Hawaii is Lazy.
The Caribbean is Laid Back.
Now don't get me wrong. I love Polynesian culture. LOVE. IT. But if I were to choose between moving to a Caribbean island and a Hawaiian island, I'd pick a Caribbean island, no brainer. The way of life agrees with my constitution better, with the way I work and function.
So give me Puerto Rico, Antigua, Aruba, Barbados. I leave the Alohas to the rest of the mainland Californians.
It's a question I'm often asked.
I've always found that question very interesting. Interesting because The Caribbean, a grouping of several hundred islands, countries, cuisines and cultures is being compared Hawaii- a chain of 8 islands (+a few islets).
It doesn't quite compute to me. And I always return the question with one of my own: Which Caribbean island?
Usually my question is answered with a blank stare, or a hastily gathered response with an obvious choice like Jamaica, or St. Thomas, or The Virgin Islands.
My honest opinion on those choices:
Jamaica or Hawaii: Hawaii. I'm NOT a Jamaica fan. Sorry if you're a Jamaica fan, but I usually call it "A dirty hole." Take into consideration that I live in California. To get to Hawaii would take one five-hour flight. Getting to Jamaica would mean at least two flights and 10+ hours in the air. And a lot more money. NOT WORTH IT.
St. Thomas or Hawaii: Hawaii
For about the same reasons as Jamaica. St. Thomas isn't quite "A Dirty Hole." But it's darned close. And it's dangerous. Be very, very careful in St. Thomas.
The Virgin Islands or Hawaii: The BRITISH Virgin Islands. Hands down. Jump on a sailboat and go and see why. I plan to.
You see, I'm picky. I'd pick Hawaii only if my other options weren't more tempting.
There is one acceptable time for comparing Hawaii to the Caribbe, and that is when describing the attitudes found in the islands.
Hawaii, to me is beautiful, tropical, fun, sunny... but something is missing for me: The Caribbean spirit, if you will. Aloha spirit is, of course, warm and welcoming, but it's just not the same.
I've thought long and hard about this conundrum. I mean, you'd think that one gorgeous, jungle-clad, azure water island chain would be comparable to another? Wrong. Wrong. Wrong. Wrong WRONG.
I could make a detailed grid of all the pros and cons between the two "places" but for me, the difference is simply this:
Hawaii is Lazy.
The Caribbean is Laid Back.
Now don't get me wrong. I love Polynesian culture. LOVE. IT. But if I were to choose between moving to a Caribbean island and a Hawaiian island, I'd pick a Caribbean island, no brainer. The way of life agrees with my constitution better, with the way I work and function.
So give me Puerto Rico, Antigua, Aruba, Barbados. I leave the Alohas to the rest of the mainland Californians.
















