The guidelines talk about using a team approach, with the boy in some sort of consultation role ("this is what I want my car to look like--see if you can make that happen with power tools"), and the dad taking on the cutting parts.
I still want the boy to be involved, but I feel a mixture of a wee bit of competitiveness and also a sincere desire for the boy to do well in the races (one of the do-it-yourselfer boys had a car that didn't quite make it over the finish line in three different races).
In my own Pinewood Derby experience, it was always a race for third place because of two boys whose father was an engineer (I think): the Morfords. Their cars always looked like Formula One racers or spaceships from the future. Even the year when I placed best, the year we decided to make our derby cars into Pioneer Wagons (did they consult the boys about this? I don't remember), their cars looked like pioneer wagon spaceships from the future. Mine looked like an actual pioneer wagon, complete with fabric cover and all (aerodynamics be damned! We're in this for the authenticity!). I came in 2nd or 3rd--I'll have to get out the slides to check--but I was ecstatic to have been somewhat victorious.
The boy wanted a Perry the Platypus design, which I was all for. Nothing like something out of the ordinary. Besides, when he's not acting like a super spy, he fortunately resembles a block of wood. We can do this. If you have never seen Perry in inaction, this is what he looks like:
We went to a pawn shop, bought a jigsaw for $20, and, since we really broke the bank last year buying all the equipment, we only put out another $10 or so for paint, weights, and sandpaper.
We drew the design together, sanded parts of him together, and I did my best to be patient as we filed the axles together, sanded the wheels together, and painted him together (although it was mostly him with me helping with touch-up).
We had intentions to include his platypus tail, but figured it would work against the already questionable aerodynamics.
We were some of the first to register and weigh in (which is a miracle in its own right), and so I thought we would race first. Not so. And, because of technical difficulties and typical "standard time" for these sorts of events, we didn't even begin to think about racing until about 30 minutes in, by which time I was ready to throttle an entire gym full of 9 year olds. They ran some test cars, but then the timekeeper's computer went down, causing an unnecessary delay of game. 10 yard penalty.
Now this is important, because we found out at the end that the timing is kept out to four decimal places, which, you will find out was probably necessary.
Nerves.
Long story short, the boy won all three of his races. He was jubilant in the extreme. I loved it.
His sister was pretty excited, too.
He almost won 1st prize in the "Wacky" category. Apparently, we make a lot of "wacky" derby cars and raingutter regatta boats, because this would have been his 3rd win in the "wacky" division. I was up taking pictures of the cars as they were sorting out the awards and saw that they were about to dub him "wacky" once again. I told the wife, and she went and said, "I hate to be the obnoxious mom, but..." and the award was changed to 1st place in the "original" category (i.e., "wacky").
Although he won all three of his races, he did not win for speed. In fact, he was in 8th place, which was surprising because the car seemed pretty fast. We went to look at the timekeeping sheets, and they explained that they average a racer's three different runs on the three different lanes of the track to make up for how different lanes might be faster, etc. The boy's car, although 8th, was separated from the top racer by .08 seconds. Point-oh-eight. I think they had to go out to the third or fourth decimal place last year to determine a winner.
We had fun. I hope the boy feels involved in this somewhat dad-heavy project. I know he liked winning, however, and that makes me happy.