So I've just started gaming only recently, well, more like a return really. I know I don't own that many games or have played that many to make my own "best of" list but I'll just try to make something up because I feel inspired to (just for the heck of it!).
Best Story:
Ok, I haven't finished that many games to begin with so I can't really talk about that many games and I don't own that many to begin with but I think that GTA IV has one of the best stories ever. It has all the nice little bits of dialogue and self-awareness, touches of ironies and parodies that I, as a Lit student, would appreciate. Thinking back on the other games I've finished like Halo 3, Gears of War 1 and 2, Assassin's Creed, I don't think their stories were any great - I can't even remember the ending of GoW 2! They were fine and engaging while things went along but GTA IV has a poignancy that most other games don't deliver.
Most Frustrating Experience:
I'll always remember the second last boss in Assassin's Creed where you're confronted by 10 Templars, super-sized, super mean bad guys that are incredibly hard to kill and when you kill all of them, the Templar BOSS comes along. I think it was compounded by my 5 hour marathon playing Assassin's Creed that ultimately got me fatigued and therefore more frustrated but that scenario was just incredibly tough and ridiculous.
Most Impressive Graphics:
GTA IV. When you're riding in the helicopter on a tour of Liberty City and you see the sun rise, it's rays reflecting and glittering off the realistic water in the river, you ponder about how far games have come to create such graphics and you never have to bother about watching the sun rise in real life. Besides that, the explosions are pretty awesome and all the shooting stuff. But I do miss the heads being shot off though.
Most Memorable Soundtrack:
World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King. It's most memorable by virtue of playing so many times. But nevertheless, it's pretty great and epic sounding. Like you're going to be a hero and conquer vast lands and all that jazz. But at the same time, the soundtrack also has somber and poignant tunes that fit into the mood of certain landscapes - the Grizzly Hills score comes to mind.
Best Gameplay:
GTA IV. Again! I'm wondering why I don't play GTA IV enough but then I realize that it's because I can't due to it's highly offensive content. But GTA IV is incredibly realistic and each component of it's gameplay is deep and engaging. From the cars with each individual car having it's own feel to it, to the gunplay and the cover system, and all the random things you can do which makes the game feel very realistic.
Other contenders like Halo 3 and Gears of War are pretty fun in their own shooter right but there's really nothing memorable about it when it all boils down to aim, shoot, take cover.
Best Multiplayer:
I don't spend much time on Xbox Live! playing multiplayer games honestly. I think Left 4 Dead is pretty fun to play online but I don't have anyone else I know to play with. Call of Duty's multiplayer is pretty darn good too and it keeps you coming back for more with it's unlockables. But the best multiplayer to be had is definitely in Guitar Hero when you have real friends to play with. It's really a ball of fun to play as a band together. I guess everyone just tires of all the shooting after a while. Oh and intentionally omitted in this award is WoW.
Most fun RPG to play:
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance 2: Grimoire of the Rift. Yes, WoW is an MMORPG but is omitted in this category once again. It's pretty sad that I stopped playing FFTA2 once I got my Xbox. FFTA2 is the best tactical RPG that I'll ever play, considering that it's the ONLY one I've ever played but it's a HECK A LOT OF FUN. I SWEAR. What works for me is how many classes there are to play with and it keeps things very varied and interesting although it just boils down to the same core mechanics of elemental damage (fire, ice, earth, bla bla) and status effects (disabled, immobilized, bla bla). Nevertheless, very fun battles and I liked it a lot but never finished it, just like it's predecessor.
Oh well, it might as well be Best Nintendo DS game for me as well.
Best PSP game:
Ok shit. I've had my PSP for a long time now and bought many PSP games but never finished any of them. Except one: Marvel Ultimate Alliance. That one, I finished by virtue of it's story and variegated gameplay with all the different characters to play as - Iceman is fun :D I can't quite say the rest kept my attention. Notable mentions include Patapon which, despite the hype, I soon gave up on because of it's rather weak story. GTA on a PSP isn't very helpful either because of the way missions are structured although it's fun to cheat and just destroy the city. I think of all the consoles, the PSP is the weakest platform I own.
I try to dissuade anyone from buying a PSP firstly because the games suck. If the control scheme isn't already a put off, the games that come out on it are very uninspiring and just plain boring (when you compare it to the stuff on the Xbox, PS3 and PC). Secondly, the other "swiss army knife" features like Mp3 and video are also lacking for me. Not only are they poorly implemented, it's hard to get your stuff onto it and the interface is poor. In my opinion, it's much better to just get an iPod.
***
So that's about it! Not the most comprehensive and I doubt many people would actually care but since I like to talk about games for the heck of it and pretend I'm good at it, I shall do just that for my own personal gratification.
Note to self:
Fallout 3
Prince of Persia
Braid
Castle Crashers
Future aspirations:
Buy a PS3 to play Resistance 2, Little Big Planet, Metal Gear Solid 4
Buy a Wii to play Super Smash Brothers Brawl, Mario Kart, No More Heroes
To get a life (then again, what life is is subjective)